Do Phoenix Suns OWE Devin Booker To Go ALL-IN AGAIN After Big 3 Disaster?
The Suns right now are reloading, not rebuilding. You know, they’re kind of in this in between phase. Stephen is giving up potentially some of your young pieces and some young pieces that people are going to be mad that I included in this trade. Is that from a philosophy standpoint as a franchise right now worth it? Not saying Trey Young’s a bad player, but to build a team that you and I both believe defensively probably doesn’t have that ceiling to be a true contender. I answer the question with a question of my own and that is with the Booker extension, do you feel like the Suns owe it to Devin Booker to spend the least amount of time that they possibly can in this retool rebuild phase and get back to not just trying to scrap into the playoffs or playing race, but be firmly entrenched in it. I think they owe it to Devin Booker to build the best team possible. And sometimes that doesn’t mean pressing fast forward at every single moment, right? Yes. Would Trey Young be the the the second best player on the team and would be a better player than Jaylen Green? Yes. Would he be a better fit offensively than Jaylen Green? Yes. Could you build a team around Trey Young and Devin Booker easier than you could build a team around Jaylen Green and Deon Booker? Yes. That being said, are you accelerating and giving up what little assets you have left because they’re going to have to part with somebody, right? To accelerate this and not get to the heights that you need to because I don’t see Jaylen Green as a part of this team for the next five years, right? And I think that this situation, this Trey Young Jaylen Green trade is not something that would happen now. This is something I think when we get to the trade deadline, Atlanta’s going to give it a shot. Suns are going to give it a shot to bump up Jaylen Green’s value. And then we’re going to revisit this conversation in February. The Suns owe it to Devin Booker to try to win a championship. That doesn’t always mean trying to put all of your chips to the center of the table at every possible moment, right? So maybe it would make them better in the short term, but by the end of that extension that Deon Booker just signed, would they have the ceiling that they could hit to reach a championship? I think that’s the legitimate real hard-hitting question that comes with pressing this button for Trey Young. I guess to answer my own question, they owe it to him. Yes. But the context has to make sense. So, if you do this, you’re going to be giving up some of the assets that you do have because you don’t have that’s to make up for the assets that you literally just don’t have in terms of draft pick compensation. So, you brought up a point about is it going to put you in the or closer to win now than you are without it. Yes, you would be there, but I think the repercussions might be a little too loud on it. You have to have a firmly entrenched plan to okay, we do this, we have to part with X, Y, and Z. Not you’re not going to recoup those X, Y, and Z pieces you gave up, but you have to find ways to kind of insulate your roster the rest of the way to make it all make sense, right? So, I get the I get the uh cause for pause with people in the chat and anybody else that’s been kind of talking about this lately. Now, maybe we go into this season and let’s just kind of walk down this path and play Little’s devil’s little devil’s advocate because I think you and I are kind of sitting on the same page with this. Let’s say that Jordan finds a way defensively to make it work with Jaylen Green and Deon Booker. Now Jaylen Green physically has much better tools for defense than Deon Booker, but not a good defender right now. And Devin Booker had the worst defensive season of his career. Okay, let’s say Jordan finds a way to make that offense and that defense click. And the Suns are better than expected but not great, right? And you can see the vision of him working with two offensive oriented guards because you saw it with the Cavs, Garland and Mitchell. Then with a 70% of a season, 65% of a season up to the All-Star break with Green and Booker. If you’re the Suns front office and you’re saying, “Well, we like what we’ve seen with Green and Booker. It’s clear that having two shooting guards is not a sustainable build for this team.” Trey Young’s maybe his value has gone down. Maybe he wants to play in Phoenix. Maybe he forces his way here and we can get him for okay value. We’re going to give up something but not five first round picks because we don’t have that to trade. Mhm. You can talk yourself into building a hyperoffensive team with Trey Young as your two hoping he can improve a little on defense and revisiting this. were going to score 130 points per game, but a better fit in that back court than Bradley Beal and Devin Booker. Like, you would have the best passing back court in the NBA with Trey Young and Devin Booker. If Book works on his pull-up threes, you’d have one of the best three-point shooting back courts in the NBA. You’d have one of the best ball handling back courts in the NBA, one of the best pick and roll and pick and pop threats at the one and the two in the NBA. And if you say that’s our identity, that’s more buildable than Jaylen Green and Devin Booker, then I can see that being a path that the Suns do explore. Yeah. Issue comes for me though, which we’ll dive into when we get to looking at the um when we get to looking at the trade prospects in terms of trade templates we’re looking at there. You have to have you have to have certain types of fives with Trey Young to make that to get the most out of it. He’s going to make it work. He’s no different than like a Chris Paul or Steve Nash where you can just he can run pick and roll with anybody and make it a positive in terms of points per possession. But to get the absolute most out of it, you need some variance there. And I don’t know if the Suns front court will have it to the extent that they would maybe hope to after partnering with what they need to to even get him in housing to begin with. Yeah. I mean, and that’s and that’s also the thing at the end of the day. Trey Young has to want to come here and the Atlanta Hawks have to want what the Suns are offering. So, what could the Suns offer? We have eight trades that they could make that work. Technically, we’ll let you decide whether or not that is realistic here. Hit that like button. Hit that subscribe button. It’s a Trade Machine Friday edition of PHNX Suns.
The Phoenix Suns are in a widely accepted reloading phase, not a full-on rebuild. But, should they forgo the show play and push all their chips into the center and get ANOTHER superstar to pair with Devin Booker? Should they try to win now AGAIN, instead of playing a semi-long game and letting their young pieces develop alongside the all-time leading scorer in franchise history? PHNX Suns breaks it down on one of their latest podcasts.
SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKaPEqS_Mc6eGNNBQN1QgQw
Website:
http://gophnx.com/
PHNX Locker:
PHNXLocker.com
Social
Twitter: @PHNX_Sports
Instagram: @PHNX_Sports
14 comments
Trae is not getting better at defense.
Jalen + fodder for Trae. Yes but not giving up Dunn. Trae is better fit next to Book.
I’ve never seen a team try so hard to build around a second option. We put Booker in a category he never belonged. Booker is closer to Jamal Murray than he is sga….. you don’t build around Jamal Murray….
No thanks. The suns just got under the aprons..why the hell would you want to add another 200m for a guy that doesn't play defense, and is a ball dominant guard? This is just another shiny object that we don't need the owner going after
I would say Book, Dunn, Maluach, Brea and Fleming need to stay. Would prefer to keep Oso as well. Any combo of other players for Young and I'm with it
Also, bringing in Young puts Book back at the 2, not the other way around.
If suns do something dumb to get Trae young. They’ve obviously not learned a damn thing
Green Dunn and Grayson or Royce is fair trade I think . Anything other than that I ain’t doing it . But a lineup of Young Book Brooks and Mark Williams would be insane . Deff gotta figure out the 4 tho
Hawks dont want to give Young the max, but i know one owner who wouldn't hesitate to. Trae to Suns is so real!
Fu$& Booker. Suns owe it
to the fans to be all in. They started in 1968 and no championship with on three title appearances. So yes go after Tre, but not for the Book but for the fans. Let’s go purple and Orange 🍊!
We have zero picks. How exactly do you think you’re getting a 4x All Star/All NBA franchise player that’s a certified playoff assassin in a trade when we don’t even have assets worthy of returning Kuminga (a career bench merchant.)
Nah, it’d rather keep Green.
THis would be so dum dont do it
Josh Giddey is who the Suns need! He's 6'8" and able to play multiple positions, and would cost us less.
Y’all really spent the whole offseason gassing up Jalen and the first sign of a crappy star being available, y’all are jumping ship? We know your true feelings now