Still early…but I don’t view any of these QBs as worthy of a Top 5 pick at this moment
August 31, 2025
Still early…but I don’t view any of these QBs as worthy of a Top 5 pick at this moment
50 comments
Good thing we don’t need a QB
Nuszmeier was better than Cade yesterday
Arch is just a huge question mark. LaNorris is insanely athletic but hasn’t impressed me much with his arm. Cade is overrated asf. Sam Leavitt, Drew, and Nuss are decent but I wouldn’t spend a Top 5 let alone 10 pick on any of them.
Arch manning being #1 is laughable even before the game yesterday.
Super not a fan of Arch’s side arm delivery.
Ok Mel Kiper which players are top 5 picks after week 1?
Nuss’s avg time to release was an insane 2.1 sec yesterday. Now, I’m sure the plan was to throw quick hitters to offset the best pass rush in college football, but I promise you, the scouts took note
It’s week one of a long CFB season. Chill
I’d be more than happy taking a flier on Sellars. I get the danger of buying into physical traits, but I think he could be dangerous in Moore’s offense. Otherwise, I do like Nuss but not in the top 5
Say you don’t know ball without saying you don’t know ball. Nuss is the guy.
I think Lanorris will be the best one
It’s been 1 week bro
Nobody thought cam ward was gonna be the 1st qb of the board at the beginning of last yr
Shit, Nuss looked pretty damn good against a #4 ranked team. Arch looks to be overrated. We’ll see though.
#buss4nuss
Arch
Ngl I wouldn’t draft Allar at all simply due to his hair
I really like Cade. Looked great yesterday and a third year starter. Excited to see Sellers as well
SELLERS #1
AS of … This moment.
Or do we get DJ Lagway in 2027?
Let’s wait 3 or 4 years for Bryce Underwood
Okay smart guy. Who are your top QBs worth drafting in the top 5 after week 1. Name drop them
I really like Leavitt, but that’s just me
Refs robbed Nuss of one of the best thrown balls we’re probably gonna see all season and he was able to make quick throws and be effective and have a clean game against a top 5 team on the road. Sorry he’s not Shadeur, or that you think he has the aura of a punter or some shit
Carsen Beck
Currently beating ND
This is a comical ranking.
Nuss easily had the best performance this weekend – early on of course
My top QBs after this week are Allar and Nuss
Ok.
Is Castellanos out because of size, age, ability, or all the above?
He looked better than 4 on this list…
[deleted]
too soon
Arch is gonna be fine.
what makes you think we are getting a number 5 pick?
It’s week one. Too early to really judge these guys.
That said, Nussmeier and Sellers impressed me. No one else on this list moved the needle.
I didn’t have any QB in this class as a clear top 10 pick, but I think Nussmeier and Sellers have the best chance to separate themselves from the pack.
Manning isn’t even in the conversation right now and shouldn’t be listed with the others. It’s his first year starting and he’s most likely not declaring this year anyway.
Ain’t no Cade Bumdick that’s for sure. Mf looked pedestrian as all hell
I’m confused, I thought Nuss was great last night
We are going to be picking at 32 so idk if QB will be available at that point /s
fym??? #NussorBust
What are you even talking about bro. Idk if you’ve paid attention but with the RatMan at the helm. I’m thinking 10-7. We’re not gonna have a top 5 pick bud.
Nuss is the only one who played well against an elite defense. I still need to see more, but he’d be my leader right now.
The NFL season hasn’t even started. Let’s actually get a couple of weeks in the books before the draft talk starts.
If you’re ONLY going off of this first week, then Sellers played lights out. But, there’s no reason to even be talking about this right now.
By the logic of everyone arguing about what week 1 QB play means for the draft, Byrum Brown from South Florida is who we should be tanking for.
Nussy!
Ask this same question about 2 weeks ago and you’d tell me all of the quarterbacks are superstars waiting to happen. Why don’t we both try an exercise in “managing expectations”
Sawyer Robertson season
he can see the future!!!!
May I introduce you to a man who plays for Oklahoma University? His name is John Mateer! I am aware Oklahoma qb’s have a very weird history in the nfl but this guy looks like the real deal, like a smaller Josh Allen
50 comments
Good thing we don’t need a QB
Nuszmeier was better than Cade yesterday
Arch is just a huge question mark. LaNorris is insanely athletic but hasn’t impressed me much with his arm. Cade is overrated asf. Sam Leavitt, Drew, and Nuss are decent but I wouldn’t spend a Top 5 let alone 10 pick on any of them.
Arch manning being #1 is laughable even before the game yesterday.
Super not a fan of Arch’s side arm delivery.
Ok Mel Kiper which players are top 5 picks after week 1?
Nuss’s avg time to release was an insane 2.1 sec yesterday. Now, I’m sure the plan was to throw quick hitters to offset the best pass rush in college football, but I promise you, the scouts took note
It’s week one of a long CFB season. Chill
I’d be more than happy taking a flier on Sellars. I get the danger of buying into physical traits, but I think he could be dangerous in Moore’s offense. Otherwise, I do like Nuss but not in the top 5
Say you don’t know ball without saying you don’t know ball. Nuss is the guy.
I think Lanorris will be the best one
It’s been 1 week bro
Nobody thought cam ward was gonna be the 1st qb of the board at the beginning of last yr
Shit, Nuss looked pretty damn good against a #4 ranked team. Arch looks to be overrated. We’ll see though.
#buss4nuss
Arch
Ngl I wouldn’t draft Allar at all simply due to his hair
I really like Cade. Looked great yesterday and a third year starter. Excited to see Sellers as well
SELLERS #1
AS of … This moment.
Or do we get DJ Lagway in 2027?
Let’s wait 3 or 4 years for Bryce Underwood
Okay smart guy. Who are your top QBs worth drafting in the top 5 after week 1. Name drop them
I really like Leavitt, but that’s just me
Refs robbed Nuss of one of the best thrown balls we’re probably gonna see all season and he was able to make quick throws and be effective and have a clean game against a top 5 team on the road. Sorry he’s not Shadeur, or that you think he has the aura of a punter or some shit
Carsen Beck
Currently beating ND
This is a comical ranking.
Nuss easily had the best performance this weekend – early on of course
My top QBs after this week are Allar and Nuss
Ok.
Is Castellanos out because of size, age, ability, or all the above?
He looked better than 4 on this list…
[deleted]
too soon
Arch is gonna be fine.
what makes you think we are getting a number 5 pick?
It’s week one. Too early to really judge these guys.
That said, Nussmeier and Sellers impressed me. No one else on this list moved the needle.
I didn’t have any QB in this class as a clear top 10 pick, but I think Nussmeier and Sellers have the best chance to separate themselves from the pack.
Manning isn’t even in the conversation right now and shouldn’t be listed with the others. It’s his first year starting and he’s most likely not declaring this year anyway.
Ain’t no Cade Bumdick that’s for sure. Mf looked pedestrian as all hell
I’m confused, I thought Nuss was great last night
We are going to be picking at 32 so idk if QB will be available at that point /s
fym??? #NussorBust
What are you even talking about bro. Idk if you’ve paid attention but with the RatMan at the helm. I’m thinking 10-7. We’re not gonna have a top 5 pick bud.
Nuss is the only one who played well against an elite defense. I still need to see more, but he’d be my leader right now.
The NFL season hasn’t even started. Let’s actually get a couple of weeks in the books before the draft talk starts.
If you’re ONLY going off of this first week, then Sellers played lights out. But, there’s no reason to even be talking about this right now.
By the logic of everyone arguing about what week 1 QB play means for the draft, Byrum Brown from South Florida is who we should be tanking for.
Nussy!
Ask this same question about 2 weeks ago and you’d tell me all of the quarterbacks are superstars waiting to happen. Why don’t we both try an exercise in “managing expectations”
Sawyer Robertson season
he can see the future!!!!
May I introduce you to a man who plays for Oklahoma University? His name is John Mateer! I am aware Oklahoma qb’s have a very weird history in the nfl but this guy looks like the real deal, like a smaller Josh Allen
Pick Garrett the groundhog I dare you