This changes EVERYTHING… | MAJOR Padres News
This changes everything as the first bombshell of the off seasonason has dropped. What does this mean for the Padres’s in the future? What is happening right now? Let’s talk about it. Hi, welcome back to another episode of Padres’s Digest with your host Andrew. Today we have breaking news. I literally woke up like 30 minutes ago, saw the news, jumped on here immediately. We’ll just reveal it. Also, please subscribe. I don’t know why I’m pointing down, but you know, subscribe. Mike Schill is retiring after two seasons as the Padres’s manager. Whoa. What? I woke up, I saw it, and I was like, “No way.” And then I looked at it. Wow. I mean, I’m sure there’s a lot of mixed reactions right now, right? the haters, they’re like, “Thank Christ.” Me, I’m like, I don’t know how I feel. And I’m sure there’s some people are like, “No, Mike Schill, you are our best manager ever.” Uh, so also, please apply. I don’t know. There’s so many mixed reactions I have right now. So, for starters, I don’t think Mike Schult had a great year this year. I don’t think he was bad. I think the players made him look bad in some scenarios, but I don’t think overall he had a great year, but I don’t think it was a year I think this year had a lot of fallacies that can I say that fallacies. Does that work there? I don’t know. I had a lot of fallacies that didn’t work out the way we thought they would have. And I don’t think that’s entirely on Mike Schill. I think it’s an entire organizational problem. I don’t think because of that we should have fired Schil. But now that Schult’s gone, maybe we can revamp and re just redo everything. There’s going to be some uh manager options that Kevin, there’s an article from Kevin AC that I’m going to read. There’s some options he gave us that are internal. We’ll get into it. But I think the biggest problem with this, and like I’ve been saying a billion times all year, the biggest problem with this team is the lack of consistency. And now we’re gonna fire or I guess we’re gonna rehire another manager. So we keep our two years. One year good year. No. Yeah. One year good year, one year bad year. Fired. One year good year. One year bad year fired. We’re keeping the cycle. And I know Mike show wasn’t fired obviously, but still we’re going to have to find another manager. And I think that might hurt the team honestly in my opinion. Depends on who we hire, how great they are. Like if we hire Bob Melvin again, like no, we’re screwed. Uh I would hate that. But if we can find someone who I think internal is a good option. I just don’t know exactly who yet, but we’ll see. Right. So let me start with uh Mike Schultz’s letter to everybody. Uh I don’t I didn’t summarize the article. I just found bits and pieces of it. So we’re going to read a lot of stuff today. Just bear with me. But letter from Mike Schult. It is with a heavy but full heart that I am announcing my retirement from managing the San Diego Padres’s. It is a is a decision that I thought about during the season and became at peace with over the last 10 days. I gave every fiber of my being to help achieve Peter Sidler’s vision of bringing a World Series championship to San Diego. We fell short of the ultimate goal, but I am proud of what the players, staff, and organization were able to accomplish the last two seasons. The grind of the baseball season has taken a severe toll on me mentally, physically, and emotionally. While while it has always been about serving others, it takes time. Wait, sorry, I just lost myself. It’s time I take care of myself and exit on my terms. I am extremely appreciative to the Padres’s, Peter Sidler, the Sidler family, Eric Grouper, uh, AJ Prowler, and staff for the trust and confidence to lead this team. I am confident I left things in a better place. However, I am most grateful for our players. San Diego is rightfully proud of the Padres’s players. It is a group that conducts themselves with class, is dedicated to each other, and the common goal of winning a World Series. I love our players and will miss them dearly. After 34 years of dedicating myself to the rigorous rigors of coaching and managing, I can with great enjoyment look back on achieving my two primarily goals. To help players get the most out of their god-given ability and become better men, also to win games. I move forward with a with a smile on my face, contempt in my soul, and genuine excitement for what God has next. To the Frier Faithful, thanks for all the support and keep rocking Petco Park. It is the best home field advantage in Major League Baseball. The team is on its way to that World Series championship you so deserve. Respectfully, Schulty, it’s too early for me to read this much. But no, honestly, like when you read that, like managing is one of the hardest things you could do. Not just in like in general, but like in sports, but like in general, right? You’re you’re basically the captain of an multi-million billion dollar franchise and a lot of things rest on you. Obviously, the players and all that, right? But GM and all that, but like the coach or the manager or Yeah. And the manager is one of the most integral positions in an entire baseball organization obviously. Uh but I guess we’ll put it this way. I want a manager who enjoys that. You know what I mean? Like obviously like I’m not like saying I’m not blaming Schult. I’m not being like, “Oh, Schult’s a little baby boy. A little baby boy wants to manage his team.” I’m not going to say that. That’s messed up. I’m just saying I I want a manager when his heart isn’t there. Like I didn’t want like like if English like if Mike Shield came back next year and his heart wasn’t completely in it, I wouldn’t want that. You know what I mean? Like I need like like Mike Shield definitely gave his all, but he has nothing left to give. So let’s find someone else who was willing to give more than everything 110% for this team. Has his heart in it. Again, no shade whatsoever towards Mike Schill. I am so happy for what you’ve done for this team. Uh but we got to move on. You know what I mean? Uh, but let’s move on to the next thing real quick. This is from AJ Pller. He said, “We would like to congratulate Mike on a successful career and thank him for his significant contributions to the Padres’s and the San Diego community over the last four years, including consecutive 90 win seasons and two postseason appearances as manager. His dedication and passion for the game of baseball will leave an impact on our organization, and we wish him the best in his next chapter. The search for a new manager of the Padres’s will begin immediately with the goal of winning a World Series championship in 2026. As it should, as it should. Uh, but yeah, I mean, AJ probably done it like 15 times at this point. I think I have faith that he’ll choose someone good. I know Bob Melvin was kind of a bad call the second season. First season wasn’t horrible. Uh, but I think if we find someone similar to Mike Schul, maybe a little bit more uh Latin flare, let’s say, to more uh be more relatable to the players like uh I know you named me and Christian just throughout uh from the last time when Bob Melvin got fired, Benji Gil, I think his name was the Mexico manager during the World Baseball Classic. I liked him. I don’t think he’s going to be an option anymore, but I did like him. I don’t know what they’ll do. AJ Per will do his due diligence, but I don’t know. I liked it. And then yeah, so this is some possible options to be hired internally from Kevin AC. Uh they’re looking at some uh internal options. Pitching coach Ruben Yebla, who has molded a successful pitching staff that has been in nearly constant flux over the past four seasons, would seemingly be a lock to be interviewed. Baseball operations special assistant AJ Ellis, a longtime major league catcher who worked closely with Schult this past season, is widely considered a future manager. Scott Service Servius I remember from the Mariners but yeah who managed the Mariners from 2016 to 24 and was a catcher in the major leagues for 11 seasons is now a special assistant in player development who is highly regarded in the organization. The Padres’s could also interview bench coach Brian Espacto and former player Mark Loretta who serves as a person special assistant to CEO Eric Grouper. Honestly, the only person here I would really like is Ruben Yevla. I mean, don’t get me wrong, like, uh, Scott Service, Scott, if I say his name wrong, I’m so sorry. Like, I I know he’s a good manager, but like the Mariners have never been to a World Series, and over that almost 10 year stretch, I just don’t think he has a lot of playoff uh experience, and I don’t really want a a manager without any playoff experience. Obviously, Ruben Nebula has never managed before, but like, he knows this team very well, and he could still work his magic, you know what I Now, we just talked about it in another video, too, about how we could lose Ruben Neba to a managerial position, but I said if Schult leaves, uh, we could put Neba in as the manager and then, uh, Ben Fritz as the pitching coach. So, I actually don’t hate Ruben Ya. I feel like we can maybe do better. No offense to him, but I feel like we can do better, but he is definitely an option. You know what I mean? Uh, and then, yeah, just couple more things. He managed virtually every game with an urgency that was uncommon in a sport that has 162 games in a season. He has worn out at the end of days that involved spending 12 hours at the ballpark. He is unmarried and essentially never stopped thinking about the players, the opponent, the best ways to win. And by and by his telling, his single-minded devotion to all aspects of the the job came at the expense of his overall well-being. So, the man whose path to becoming a major league big league manager was extremely unique given that he did not play past college and got his start as a high school coach made a rare decision to call it a career. It was in the seasons last month he said that he came down came to the realization that he might need to step down. It is way too early for me to be reading. So, sorry y’all. Uh but yeah, let’s look at his records though. I mean, 2018 positive, positive, positive. Everything he’s done is positive, right? and he’s had four 90 win uh seasons. So, I mean, it’s not like he’s been bad. Like, he’s never been bad. Uh but, well, I guess 2020 was kind of close to being bad, but you know what I mean, right? So, yeah. I mean, he was good for us. I’m not going to lie. He was definitely good for us. Out of all the managers we’ve had, like AJ Green, uh uh Mike Schil, Bob Melvin, uh why can’t I think of the other guy? Uhhuh. AJ Oh god, you know what I’m talking about. I don’t know about my memory. Hold on. This is going to bother me. Give me a sec. Jace Tingler. There we go. Andy Green, Jayce Tingler, Bob Melvin, Mike Schill. I think out of those hires, I guess Bud Black too from the AJ Prowler uh era, I think Mike Schult is probably the best one in my opinion, right? I mean, Bob Melvin is a old school guy and it worked for like a season, then it kind of just fell off. But yeah, I mean, also a fun fact I saw that I absolutely hated, uh, two Padres’s interimm managers are now in the NLCS with, uh, uh, Pat Murphy for the Brewers and then, uh, Dave Roberts for the Dodgers. So, I hate that fact. Anyways, yeah, just last one real quick. Oh, yeah, there we go. Uh, Schil, 57, who had two years remaining on the contract extension he signed, was a team in November 2024. The Padres’s went 183 and 141 in his two years at the helm in San Diego, making the postseason in both seasons. Before joining the Padres’s uh before joining the Padres’s, my bad. Schult managed the Cardinals from 2018 to 2021, including winning NL NL manager of the year honors in 2019. The surprising news means the Padres’s will become the ninth team to change managers this offseason and the eighth with an active vacancy after the Rangers hired Skip Schumacher to replace Bruce Bochi on Friday. And I like Skip Schumacher. So, you know, it’ be a wild It’s not going to happen, but it’d be wild if we had Will Venibal as a manager from the White Socks, but I don’t think he wants to leave the White Socks just yet. Uh, but yeah, that’d be funny. But, but yeah, let’s just look at some reactions real quick. Uh, congrats to Mike Shill on his retirement. Did not see that being the way this relationship ended, but happy for him and grateful for the postseason runs he brought to the San Diego Padres’s. Yeah, I mean, I’m grateful for him. Like I said, if he’s not if his heart’s not in it, full full happiness for his retirement, but we need to move on. Uh, here’s another for the haters. Here’s one for you guys. Uh, not surprised one bit. The pattern that played out in St. Louis reared its ugly head in San Diego. Philosophical differences in lineup construction. Too stubborn in sticking with his players and inability to make adjustments. He lost the clubhouse and wasn’t comfortable in being stern. Actually, I don’t necessarily disagree with that. Uh, I don’t think I don’t think it’s wholly, like I said, wholly his fault, but I I don’t necessarily disagree. And I think the players made him look bad a little bit from being inconsistent, but yeah, I mean, if we can get a new manager to get those consistencies consistent, then absolutely, I will love that for the rest of time. Uh, and then coach John, coach Kent, I should say, before you yell at me. Uh, Mike Shel announces his retirement. Padres’s need to hire someone from the outside the organization that will hold all the players accountable. Hopefully, they take their time and get it right. You’re you’re out to win ball games, not popularity contest. He says outside the organization. I don’t necessarily disagree, but I feel like someone who’s at least slightly familiar with the players. Like I I uh like Tatis Senior for example, why not him? I would prefer him as a hitting coach over V-Rod, but he’s like an example of someone outside the organization that does know the players a little bit. You know what I mean? I guess technically also Bob Melvin, but I don’t want Bob Melvin. Why would you want Bob Melvin? Uh but you get what I’m saying, right? Uh and then possible internal managerial options. We just saw this, but uh Ruben Ya, Mark Loretta, AJ Ellis, Scott Service, Servis, I think it’s how you say it. Brian Espacito, and Bruce Bochi is technically an option, but he’s I don’t think he wants to manage anymore to be honest. He’s getting really old. Uh and David Ross, I don’t think I want David Ross either to be honest. I mean, if he gets hired, I’m not going to like hate it, but like I think we can do better in my opinion. Uh and then Machado and Tatis Jr. will enter the eighth season together with the Padres’s without playing for a single manager for more than two years during that season. really thought Schult would be the end of that trend. And then one more and I’ll release you guys. Hope Schult is good physically and mentally. He was a solid ass manager and seemed like a good dude. Appreciate his time in San Diego. But yeah, there’s so much to go over. We’re going to have a lot of videos coming up. I mean, Christian’s going to have a video talking about possible options eventually. Uh, but how do you guys feel right now? Are you upset? Are you happy? Do you wish him the best? Or do you hate him and want want him to go away and retire forever? Who do you want as a possible option? Just let me know how you feel. But yeah, thank you guys so much for watching. Have a fantastic rest of your day. Please subscribe. Go Padres’s and AJ Peller. It’s all up in your hands now. Get us someone good, please. Goodbye.
Today, Andrew McFarland has BREAKING NEWS for you: our manager has retired and left a massive gaping hole that AJ Preller will have to fill as soon as possible…
—
Padres Digest is a YouTube channel dedicated to covering all the latest news, trades, reports, and rumors about the San Diego Padres. We provide in-depth coverage of game highlights, player performances, and analysis of team strategies. Our channel features discussions on key players like Fernando Tatis Jr. Luis Arraez, Manny Machado, and Xander Bogaerts, along with insights from Manager Mike Shildt and General Manager A.J. Preller. Stay connected for exciting updates and engaging content on everything Padres!
Have you ever wanted to break into sports media as a write or content creator? Apply to join the Digest Media team today here: https://digestmedia.ca/join-us/
for_digest_redistribution
—
Unchanged
—
MLB Trade Rumors, MLB Free Agency, MLB Draft, World Series Predictions, Fantasy Baseball Tips, MLB Betting Odds, MLB Jersey Review, Player Performance Breakdown, DraftKings MLB Picks, FanDuel MLB Strategy, Baseball Analytics, MLB Highlights, MLB News Update, MLB Stats, MLB Roster Moves, MLB Predictions
19 comments
Ruben Niebla may be an option. He's been reportedly interested in doing so. Give him the job before he leaves to do that for another team.
Fired or retire!!!
Can't blame the manager for $billion players not hitting. Dont tell me theyre keeping the hitting coach.
Time for Bochy to come home where he belongs
AJ interferes too much. Bochy is available and doesn’t like to be interfered with. AJ needs to be fired.
My Christmas wish came true
Ryan Flaherty was the second choice to Shildt, plus he had been both bench coach and hitting coordinator with the Padres.
Joe Giradi or Buck Showalter??
Highest win % of all Padres managers that were at the helm for more than 1 game.
Yes. Tatis Sr. The guy that provided the PEDs to tatis and Profar lol.
Let’s go for Bruce Bochy
I'm sorry but Ruben needs to stay where he is. Pitching is doing so well at the moment.
Bruce Bochy
Wasn’t he just confirmed staying or was it confirmed not going to another team?
Bruce bochey coming back….yeeee….he's coming back home….
kinda brings a 😢 my eye
Its all because of Manny and AJ they are the problems
AJ has to go please
Kevin acee is a horses ass