This Blockbuster Trade Already Looks Like a Disaster

This Blockbuster Trade Already Looks Like a Disaster

Orlando start is flatout bad. They made huge investments in the off seasonason to upgrade their offense. They are in the bottom five in the NBA in offense, three-point percentage, three-point makes. Desmond Bane, the guy that they spent four first round drafts, and Kentavius Caldwell Pope is off to a rough start. Five months ago, the Orlando Magic were being hyped up as one of the biggest threats in the Eastern Conference. Analysts were calling them a dark horse to potentially win the East. They made the move everyone wanted them to make. They went allin. They traded for Desmond Bane in what was supposed to be the missing piece that would elevate them from a good defensive team to a legitimate championship contender. And it made a lot of sense. Jason Tatum is out for the entire season. So is Tyresese Hallebertton which takes the Indiana Pacers and the Boston Celtics out of the running to become Eastern Conference champions. But here we are just five games into the season and things are looking rough. Like really rough. The Magic are sitting at 1 and four. And here’s the kicker. They were favored to win every single one of those games. Every single one of them. And they managed to lose four of them. But before we dive into what’s going wrong, let’s rewind to this past summer when Orlando decided to make one of the boldest moves we’ve ever seen in recent years. Because to understand why this is so devastating, you need to understand just how much the Orlando Magic bet on this working. So, real quick before we get to the content, make sure you subscribe and turn on our notifications for the latest NBA news and analysis. And now that we get all that out of the way, cue the intro. We had a dominant night last night making $900 with my plays on prize picks. I have a play for you guys in this video. But first, make sure you sign up with my promo code microphone to get $50 in lineups when you make a play of $5 or more. Then tail this relatively safe play. I have Jaylen Brown going higher than 29.5 P. I have Nicole going over 11.5 rebounds and assists. I got Jokic getting at least 10 boards and Evan Mobley going over 29.5 P. I’m trying to turn 50 bucks into $130. And on top of that, if you guys want more plays, my Discord server has been absolutely killing it. It’s the W link in the description down below. It’s where I got most of my plays that made me $900 last night. So, if you guys want additional plays, make sure you check that out. And thank you Prize Picks for sponsoring today’s video. Mike Chuck 1212. What’s going on everybody? Back on June 15th, 2025, the NBA world woke up to some shocking news. The Memphis Grizzlies were trading Desmond Bane to the Orlando Magic. But it wasn’t just Bane changing teams. The price Orlando paid was absolutely staggering. Orlando sent out Contavius Caldwell Pope, Cole Anthony, and four first round picks to Memphis. Four first round picks. We’re talking about the 16th pick in the 2025 draft, plus unprotected first round picks in 2026, 2038, and 2030 along with a pick swap in 2029. This wasn’t just going allin. This was literally pushing every single chip into the middle of the table and saying, “We’re winning now or we’re going down swinging.” Immediately, people started comparing this to other massive trades. Some people thought it was very similar to when the New York Knicks gave up five first round picks from Mikuel Bridges, saying Orlando was essentially making the same bet. When you look at Bleacher Report’s ranking of the largest trade halls of the past decade, this deal came in at number eight. That’s how massive it was. And at the time, it made sense. The Orlando Magic had a clear problem. Actually, they had the problem. Last season, the Orlando Magic finished dead last in the NBA in both three-point makes and three-point percentage. They were making just 11.2 threes per game while shooting 31.8% from deep. That’s not just bad. That was the worst three-point shooting percentage for any team since the 2015 to 2016 Lakers. They were historically awful from three. Meanwhile, Desmond Bane was everything the Orlando Magic needed. He was a career 41% shooter from three-point range who had averaged 19.2 points, 6.1 rebounds, and 5.3 assists for the Memphis Grizzlies last season. The guy was one of just three NBA players with 800 made threes and 40% shooting from deep since 2020. He had shot 43.2% on catch and shoot threes over the past five seasons, which was the third best rate among players with at least 1,000 attempts. But here’s what made Bane even more valuable. He wasn’t just a shooter. He could create his own shot. He could playmake. And most importantly, for a team that built its identity on defense, he could defend. The Orlando Magic had been second in defensive rating last season. And Bane had shown that he could hold his own defensively on multiple Memphis units that ranked among the league’s best. This wasn’t just about shooting. This was about finding that perfect third star to go alongside Paulo Beno and Fron Vagner. a player who could space the floor, create when needed, and wouldn’t destroy the defensive identity that made Orlando special. The excitement was real. Magic President Jeff Welman said, “Over his 5 years in the NBA, Desmond has distinguished himself as one of the elite guards in our league, and we look forward to his shooting, IQ, and wide-ranging skill set in helping our team take a step forward.” The Ringer wrote that the Magic could now realistically win the East. Analysts were projecting them to finish somewhere between third and fifth in the Eastern Conference, with some even suggesting a finals run wasn’t out of the question. The timing seemed perfect, too. The Celtics had lost Jason Tatum to a torn Achilles. The Pacers lost Tyrese Hallebertton to the same injury. The East was wide open. If there was ever a year for the Magic to make their move, this was it. And even Desmond Bane himself was confident. When asked about the price Orlando paid for him, Bane said, “It’s time to win. It’s pretty much as simple as that. if we do what we’re supposed to do. Not to say those picks weren’t valuable, but they would have fallen in place that we’ve got a lot of young talent here already in the building and we have a lot of talent at the top of the roster. So, I think it’s the perfect time for the organization to do what they did. But keep those words in mind because after five games, the Orlando Magic are absolutely doing what they’re not supposed to do. Let me fast forward to right now, the end of October. The Magic just got blown out 135 to 116 by the Detroit Pistons. It was their fourth straight loss. They’re sitting at 1 and4. And if you’ve been watching these games, you know it’s been ugly. Let’s start with Desmond Bane because that’s what everyone’s looking at. Bane is averaging 17.6 points, 4.8 rebounds, and 2.8 assists through five games. On the surface, that doesn’t look terrible. But when you dig a little deeper, it gets concerning. In the season opener against Miami, Bane hit three of his first six three-pointers and scored 23 points. Everyone thought, “Okay, here we go. This is what we paid for.” But since that first game, he shot just 4 for 20 from three-point range. That’s 20%. For a guy who’s supposed to fix your shooting problems, that’s a nightmare. Against the Bulls, he went 0 for two from three. Against the 76ers, he was two for seven from deep and ended up fouling out. And then in that recent Pistons loss, Bane went 1 for4 from three and shot just 4 for 15 overall, scoring only 12 points, his lowest output of the season. There was even this moment that went viral where Bane had a wideopen three-pointer in the first quarter against Detroit, and he hit nothing but backboard. Pure backboard. The internet had a field day with that one. It’s the kind of clip that ends up on Shack in a fool. And it perfectly captured just how off Bane has been over his last four games. Bane is shooting 26.9% from three. For context, the Magic as a team are dead last in both three-point makes and attempts. So, not only has Bane not fixed the shooting problem, but the problem might have actually gotten worse. Now, it’s fair to say that Bane is still adjusting. He’s learning a new system, playing with new teammates, figuring out the rhythm. These things take time. But when you trade four first round picks for a guy, you don’t have the luxury of a long adjustment period. Especially when you’re supposed to be competing for a championship right now. But here’s the thing, and this is what makes the situation even more troubling. The shooting isn’t even the biggest problem. Not even close. The real crisis in Orlando right now is the defense has completely vanished. And for a team that’s built its entire identity on being a defensive juggernaut, that’s catastrophic. Let’s put this into perspective. Last season, the Magic held opponents to a league best 105.5 points per game. They were number one in blocked shots and sixth in steals. They held opponents to their league’s worst three-point percentage and the fewest offensive rebounds. They finished second in the NBA in defensive rating, which is basically the gold standard for team defense. Defense was supposed to be the one constant. The Magic could struggle to score. They could have offsights offensively, but they could always lock you down on the other end. That was their calling card. That was their identity. Fast forward to today and in their last two games alone, the Magic have given up 271 points. They surrendered 136 points to the 76ers and 135 points to the Detroit Pistons. That’s more points given up in back-to-back games than they allowed in any twoame stretch all of last season. Through four games, they’ve allowed 110 plus points in every single contest. For comparison, last season they only gave up 120 plus points nine times total, and they never surrendered more than 125. Now they’re doing that every other night. The numbers are even more alarming when you break them down. The Magic have dropped from forcing 8.9 steals per game last season to just 6.2 this season. They’re turning the ball over themselves at a 16.7% rate, which is 24th in the league. And they’re allowing 21.6 points off of turnovers per game, which is 27th. Remember how dominant they were on the glass last year. They’re now giving up 12.6 offensive rebounds per game. That’s up from 9.2 last season. Against Detroit, the Pistons grabbed 14 offensive boards for 22nd chance points. That’s not just bad defense. That’s a complete lack of effort and toughness. And here’s the stat that really tells the story. Last year, the Magic were second in the league at forcing turnovers with a 16.8% turnover rate and scored 19 points off of turnovers per game. This year, they’re 18th in turnover rate at 14.7% and scoring only 14.6 points off of turnovers, which is 29th in the league. Their defense used to create offense. Now, it’s doing neither. After the Pistons game, the Magic’s defensive rating had plummeted from sixth to 15th in the league at 114.1 points per 100 possessions. And that marked the first time since Kyrie Irving’s 60point game and Sadique Ba’s 51-point game in March of 2022 that the Magic gave up more than 130 points per 100 possessions in consecutive games. That was back in the depths of their rebuild when they were actively tanking. This team is supposed to be competing for championships. When Jamal Mosley was asked what the problem was, this is what he had to say about it. I could sit here and tell you a whole bunch of things that happened throughout the game, the rotations, this we got to guard. You got to take some pride on defense. You got to sit down and sit and want to guard your man and not worry about what’s happening on the offense of the floor. 64 points in the paint, starting with 17 turnovers for 26 of them. So, take care of the basketball and we got to sit down and guard when we are in the half court. That’s about as frustrated as you’ll hear Mosley get, and he’s right to be. Paulo Beno even admitted after the loss, I just think sometimes when our offense slows down, you know, we we let it affect the defensive effort, give too many easy buckets. Yeah, I think it’s just a combination of everything. You know, we just got to play with more heart. So, what’s causing this defensive collapse? Well, there are a few factors at play here. First, there’s the pace issue. The Magic have completely changed their offensive philosophy this season. Last year, they played at the slowest pace in the league with 96.51 possessions per 48 minutes. This year, they’re playing at the eighth fastest pace at 104.88 possessions per 48 minutes. The idea was simple. get Bane in transition where he could use his shooting to space the floor, generate more offensive possessions, and take pressure off of Banero and Vagner in the half court. But in reality, the faster pace means Orlando isn’t getting set defensively. And it’s allowing opponents to get easy transition buckets. Banero himself said after the Sixers loss that we need to be smarter about how fast we’re playing. If you’re just going fast without any direction, it’s not the best. Direction is more important than speed. So, we can play fast, but if there’s no direction, then it’s going to be tough. Bane, for his part, doesn’t think pace should be an excuse. He said, “I wouldn’t say so. It’s hard to win in this league. It’s hard to do anything in this league, but there is a way to do both, and we have to in order to win. But the reality is they haven’t figured out how to do both yet. And until they do, they’re stuck in this no man’s land where they’re not good enough offensively to justify the faster pace, and they’re not locked in enough defensively to survive it. Secondly, there’s the Jaylen Suggs situation. Suggs is arguably the heart and soul of this team defensively. He made the alldefensive second team in the 2023 to 24 season, and he was having a breakout year last season before season ending injury in March cut his season short. Right now, Suggs is averaging just 18.7 minutes per game, as Mosley manages his minutes coming back from surgery. He didn’t even play in the backtoback against Chicago, and the impact is massive. Against the Pistons, the Magic were 10 points better than Detroit in Suggs’s 21 minutes on the floor, but minus 29 in his 27 minutes on the bench. That’s a 39point swing. When your defensive anchor is playing limited minutes and your new high-priced acquisition isn’t defending at the level that you expected, that’s how you end up giving up 135 points to the Pistons. Speaking of Bane’s defense, that’s been another issue. Reports indicate his defense hasn’t been strong, and he’s not been the two-way player that Orlando envisioned when they made the trade. Against Philadelphia, Bane fouled out trying to guard Tyrese Maxi, who torched the Magic all night long. Third, the bench has been a disaster. Taius Jones, who was signed to provide steady point guard play and reduce turnovers, is shooting just 25% from the field and averaging only 1.8 assists. That’s supposed to be one of the best facilitators in the league. a guy who’s known for his elite assist to turnover ratio and he’s barely producing. And then there’s the fact that the team as a whole is shooting poorly. Against the Sixers, the Magic shot 32% from three on 8 for 25 shooting. In their last two games, they’ve shot just 22.4% from three-point range. When you’re missing shots, turning the ball over, and not getting back on defense, you’re going to get blown out, which is exactly what’s been happening. Now, let’s talk about Paulo Bancero. Because while he’s not the reason for this slow start, he hasn’t been quite himself either. Through four games, Bancero is averaging 22.8 points, 8.5 rebounds, two assists, and 1.5 blocks while shooting 39.4% from the floor. Those aren’t bad numbers, but they’re down from his career best 25.9 points per game last season. Part of this is just natural variance. Banero had a great game against Philadelphia with 32 points and he’s been getting to the free throw line at a high rate, but the shooting percentages are concerning and there’s a sense that he’s still trying to figure out how to play with Desmond Bane. The chemistry between Bancer and Bane was supposed to be one of the selling points of this trade. One analysis highlighted how Bane popping off of pick and rolls gives Banero space to work and there have been glimpses of that potential. But five games in and they’re still trying to figure each other out. And that adjustment period is costing them games that they should be winning. Fron Vagner has been similarly inconsistent. He struggled in second halves, making only two shots in the second half against Chicago and just three against Atlanta. When your two stars are struggling to close games, and your new acquisition is shooting 20% from three over his last four games, you’re going to lose a lot of close games. But meanwhile in Memphis, the Grizzlies are probably feeling good about the Bane trade right about now. Let me be clear, it is way too early to declare winners and losers here. But the early returns are interesting. The Grizzlies ended up using the 16th pick that they’ve got from Orlando to trade up and select Cedric Coward at the 11th overall pick, who’s been showing promise so far. They got Contavius Caldwell Pope, a two-time NBA champion who provides championship level defense. and they’re sitting on three more Orlando first round picks that could end up being incredibly valuable if this Magic experiment doesn’t pan out. ESPN projected the Grizzlies to finish 42 and 40 this season, which would be a step back from their 48 and 34 record last year. But here’s the thing, they cleared salary cap space to potentially extend Jiren Jackson Jr. They added draft capital and they maintained flexibility. Even if they take a small step back this year, they’re set up for long-term success. Orlando, on the other hand, is all in right now. They’re going to be a second apron team in the 2026 to 27 season when Berrow’s Max extension kicks in, and they don’t have the luxury of a long-term view anymore. They need this to work immediately, or they’re going to be looking at a very narrow championship window that could close before it ever really opened. So, where does this leave us? Five games into the season and the Orlando Magic are sitting at 1-4. What are we actually looking at here? Well, let’s go through the possible scenarios because this story could go in several different directions. Scenario one is it’s just early season growing pains and we’re overreacting. This is the optimistic view and honestly, it’s not unreasonable. Five games is a very tiny sample size. Teams need time to build chemistry, especially when you’re integrating a new star player into your system. The faster pace is a major adjustment. Jaylen Suggs is still working his way back from surgery. Maybe this is just a rough patch that every team goes through. Bane said himself after the Sixers loss, “I do feel like we have a really close-knit team, and we’re trending into the right direction. The belief is still there. The talent is still there.” Analysts wrote, “With better health and getting Bane comfortable, this team should be able to beat up on teams all regular season.” And we’ve honestly seen this before. The Celtics started 8-2 after trading for Chris’s Porzingis and Drew Holiday in 2023 before eventually figuring it out. The Bucks struggled early after getting Drew Holiday. Sometimes it just takes time for everything to click. If this is the case, we’ll look back on this 1 and4 start as a footnote in a successful season. Bane will start hitting his threes and the defense will rediscover its identity. Suggs will get back to full strength and the Magic will climb back into contention. They still have 77 games left. There’s plenty of time to turn this around. That brings us to our next scenario. This could potentially be a fit problem, and this is where things get more concerning. What if Bane and this Magic team just don’t fit together as well as everyone thought? There are some legitimate questions here. Bane thrived in Memphis playing alongside John Morand who’s one of the most explosive rim attacking guards in the league. That gravity opened up everything for Bane. In Orlando, he’s playing with Paulo Bancero and Fron Vagner who are both more methodical mid-range oriented players who don’t put the same kind of pressure on the rim. The pace change might actually be hurting Bane’s shooting. He was used to Memphis’s system, used to those specific actions, used to where his spots were on the floor. Now he’s learning everything from scratch. And maybe the Magic system just don’t maximize his strengths the way Memphises did. And on defense, maybe the Magic overestimated what Bane could do on that end. Yes, he played on good defensive teams in Memphis, but he was also playing alongside one of the best defensive bigs in the league in Jiren Jackson Jr. And with the lead perimeter defenders around him in Orlando with Suggs Limited, Bane is being asked to do more defensively than he’s capable of. and it’s exposing weaknesses that weren’t as visible in Memphis. If this is a fit problem, it’s not necessarily fatal. Teams can adjust their schemes, change their approach, and find ways to maximize their talent, but it would mean the road ahead is going to be bumpier than anyone expected. And there’s no guarantee that they ever fully figure it out. Which brings us to the nightmare scenario. This trade was a horrific mistake. Let’s be real about the stakes here. If the Magic can’t turn this around, if Bane doesn’t start performing at the level they need, if the defensive identity is permanently damaged by this roster construction, then Orlando might have just torpedoed their future for nothing. History is littered with blockbuster trades that backfired spectacularly. The Nets giving up a massive hall for Kevin Garnett and Paul Pierce in 2013 set that franchise back for a decade. The Lakers trading for Russell Westbrook destroyed their championship window with LeBron. The Clippers giving up seven first round picks for Paul George resulted in zero conference finals appearances and Paul George leaving in free agency. The common thread in all these disasters is the team that made the trade was absolutely certain it would work. They saw the upside. They convinced themselves that the fit would be perfect and they paid a premium price because they believed that they were one piece away from a championship. And then reality hit and it turned out the problems were deeper than one player could solve. Could that be Orlando? Are we watching a trade that will end up on the worst trades of all time lists in 5 years? It’s possible if those unprotected 2028 and 2030 picks end up being lottery picks because this core couldn’t sustain success. If Bane never figures out how to mesh with Manero and Vagner, if the defensive identity is permanently lost, then yes, this could go down as a franchise altering mistake in the worst possible way. And here’s what makes this situation very dangerous for Orlando. They don’t have a plan B. This wasn’t a let’s add a piece and see how it goes move. This was a we’re going allin move. They’re going to be a second apron team, which means they’ll face severe restrictions on how they can improve the roster. They gave away their future draft picks. They don’t have the trade assets to make another big swing if this doesn’t work. And right now at 1 and four, this team looks more like a play-in team than a conference finals team. And every loss makes the pressure that much worse. Every game Bayon shoots poorly from three, the questions get louder. Every defensive breakdown makes people wonder if they broke something that was working. This isn’t a young team that can afford to be patient. Here’s my take on all of this. I genuinely don’t know which scenario we’re in yet. Is this just early season struggles that will smooth out over time? Possibly. Bane is too good of a shooter to keep shooting 20% from three. This defense has too many good players to keep giving up 135 points per game. Logic says that they’ll figure it out. But I also can’t ignore what we’re seeing. The fit concerns are real. The defensive decline is alarming. The fact that Mosley is openly calling out his team’s effort five game into the season is not a good sign. And when you trade four first round picks for a player, the margin for error is razor thin. But let me know in the comment section down below. Was this trade a horrific mistake or is this just an overreaction? I’d like to hear what you have to say. Aside from that, I’m your boy Mike and I’m dropping our mic. Until our next upload.

Go to https://bit.ly/PrizePicksMikerophone or use Promo Code “Mikerophone” to get $50 when you make a lineup of $5 or more!

Get my picks here: https://whop.com/checkout/plan_H1oLSdEU9Egka/?a=mykecheque&d2c=true

Mike Mafia Memberships: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQo7Kkt6UOnPP114Xwi5Qeg/join
Instagram: http://instagram.com/theflightmike#
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@theflightmike
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Mikerophone
Discord: https://discord.gg/sHexntZpSZ
Twitter: https://twitter.com/TheFlightMike
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Theflightmike
Snapchat: FlightMikeSnap

MUSIC BY: https://open.spotify.com/artist/5CEQDOtEb9UftqMWwoJXrL
https://www.instagram.com/winterfreshmusic/