[Bears Muse] Highest-Graded QB’s in Week 9: 92.0 — Sam Darnold 91.7 — Caleb Williams These two were sensational Sunday
November 7, 2025
[Bears Muse] Highest-Graded QB’s in Week 9: 92.0 — Sam Darnold 91.7 — Caleb Williams These two were sensational Sunday
9 comments

I see MITCaleb just got out of school
Quite surprised it wasn’t Flacco but I guess that Hail Mary interception made a big difference?
Watching the All-22 was honestly pretty impressive when I watched the breakdown of every play via the QB School. Watching the live, I felt like he scrambled too quickly and missed several check downs. Felt like maybe a meh game.
On re-watch though, I only really noticed a few mistakes. He missed the tight end on one check down early in the game, and then had a couple other subpar check down throws later. The first ball of the game could have been maybe a bit better to Kmet, but honestly Kmet probably still needs to catch it after it hits him in the chest. And then the ball to Kmet that got him concussed was a bit high, but Kmet also probably didn’t need to jump to grab it.
Otherwise, every time Caleb scrambled it was the right decision – either there was no one open after going through progressions, or we had early pressure from the left side. The ball to Rome in the end zone seemed to be tipped, which is why it was behind. On the last drive of the game when Caleb scrambled, it was the right call – there was no one open.
While I do think accuracy is always going to be a bit of an issue with Caleb, I feel confident that as the game slows down with this play book, it will improve. This game was also the best so far in terms of processing. In general though, since the Vikings opener, I’ve felt like Caleb’s processing isn’t all that bad for a 2nd year QB in a new offense.
Regardless, even if things don’t improve (they will) we seem to have a league average quarterback finally, leading an explosive passing attack. Hell yeah.
PFF? Fuck out of here. Don’t need them to tell us he played well
“Yeah, but do you think that Caleb is the guy?” -Haters & Packers Fans
9 comments

I see MITCaleb just got out of school
Quite surprised it wasn’t Flacco but I guess that Hail Mary interception made a big difference?
Watching the All-22 was honestly pretty impressive when I watched the breakdown of every play via the QB School. Watching the live, I felt like he scrambled too quickly and missed several check downs. Felt like maybe a meh game.
On re-watch though, I only really noticed a few mistakes. He missed the tight end on one check down early in the game, and then had a couple other subpar check down throws later. The first ball of the game could have been maybe a bit better to Kmet, but honestly Kmet probably still needs to catch it after it hits him in the chest. And then the ball to Kmet that got him concussed was a bit high, but Kmet also probably didn’t need to jump to grab it.
Otherwise, every time Caleb scrambled it was the right decision – either there was no one open after going through progressions, or we had early pressure from the left side. The ball to Rome in the end zone seemed to be tipped, which is why it was behind. On the last drive of the game when Caleb scrambled, it was the right call – there was no one open.
While I do think accuracy is always going to be a bit of an issue with Caleb, I feel confident that as the game slows down with this play book, it will improve. This game was also the best so far in terms of processing. In general though, since the Vikings opener, I’ve felt like Caleb’s processing isn’t all that bad for a 2nd year QB in a new offense.
Regardless, even if things don’t improve (they will) we seem to have a league average quarterback finally, leading an explosive passing attack. Hell yeah.
PFF? Fuck out of here. Don’t need them to tell us he played well
“Yeah, but do you think that Caleb is the guy?” -Haters & Packers Fans
good coaching + talent = the recipe
we’ve only ever had (possibly) one of these
I give Caleb a 92.1.
USC