[BBWA] Cade Horton Finishes 2nd Place in 2025 NL Rookie of the Year Voting
November 11, 2025
[BBWA] Cade Horton Finishes 2nd Place in 2025 NL Rookie of the Year Voting
26 comments
Nice. Not enough innings pitched & the everyday player will always get the close call.
Makes sense. Hell of a season!
Fucking robbed
Heist of the century
I guess we will have to settle for a 2026 Cy Young award.
Matt Shaw beat Misery-owski. Nice.
Great job by Paige Leckie of MLB.com Washington on not even putting Horton in the top 5.
Same person voted Shaw 3rd…
ROTY in my heart, though
Too many Brewers on this list for my liking.
Disappointing as Cade had a bigger impact in my opinion on a team that made the playoffs. This vote reminds me when Chris Sabo was the 1988 NL ROY over Mark Grace
Based on how he carried the team to the playoffs I feel it should have carried more weight, but let’s be honest, baseball writers don’t know shit
All Star Misiorowski finishing strong 💪🏻
I mean I think he should have won it, but I’m biased, so I’m not mad he got second
Im mad that those who didn’t vote him for first place didn’t vote him for second
And there’s one who didn’t vote for him at all, which shows that person doesn’t actually watch baseball
I think if Horton plays the full season from opening day and puts up comparable stats, he wins it. Baldwin did have a great year.
Robbed
Who tf is Drake Baldin?
Boo!
Well this sucks. Because Horton finished top two he now gets to his contract year a year early.
As a die hard Braves fan who’s been rooting for the Cubs secondary because of Dansby Swanson I can say that Baldwin and Horton were easily the best of the NL and really just came down to how voters view the pitcher vs position player impact. Horton was a beast the second half. Hopefully he continues to improve and be a cy young candidate
Baldwin had a really good rookie season, but Horton was one of the best pitchers in all of baseball. The 2nd half of the season he was a top 5 pitcher in the NL!
Man the Brew Crew had FOUR fucking players on this list.
Holy crap
Honestly feels right.
Baldwin had a great season but I’m super happy we have Horton.
Highway robbery.
Robbed 🤦🏼♂️ i thought he had it locked, tf happened
Let’s be real – fanatics paid them off because Cade Horton red rookies were hella more printed than either of the winners….. it’s all rigged
![[BBWA] Cade Horton Finishes 2nd Place in 2025 NL Rookie of the Year Voting](https://www.rawchili.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/5gzsioak0j0g1-1183x1024.jpeg)
26 comments
Nice. Not enough innings pitched & the everyday player will always get the close call.
Makes sense. Hell of a season!
Fucking robbed
Heist of the century
I guess we will have to settle for a 2026 Cy Young award.
Matt Shaw beat Misery-owski. Nice.
Great job by Paige Leckie of MLB.com Washington on not even putting Horton in the top 5.
Same person voted Shaw 3rd…
ROTY in my heart, though
Too many Brewers on this list for my liking.
Disappointing as Cade had a bigger impact in my opinion on a team that made the playoffs. This vote reminds me when Chris Sabo was the 1988 NL ROY over Mark Grace
Based on how he carried the team to the playoffs I feel it should have carried more weight, but let’s be honest, baseball writers don’t know shit
All Star Misiorowski finishing strong 💪🏻
I mean I think he should have won it, but I’m biased, so I’m not mad he got second
Im mad that those who didn’t vote him for first place didn’t vote him for second
And there’s one who didn’t vote for him at all, which shows that person doesn’t actually watch baseball
I think if Horton plays the full season from opening day and puts up comparable stats, he wins it. Baldwin did have a great year.
Robbed
Who tf is Drake Baldin?
Boo!
Well this sucks. Because Horton finished top two he now gets to his contract year a year early.
As a die hard Braves fan who’s been rooting for the Cubs secondary because of Dansby Swanson I can say that Baldwin and Horton were easily the best of the NL and really just came down to how voters view the pitcher vs position player impact. Horton was a beast the second half. Hopefully he continues to improve and be a cy young candidate
Baldwin had a really good rookie season, but Horton was one of the best pitchers in all of baseball. The 2nd half of the season he was a top 5 pitcher in the NL!
Man the Brew Crew had FOUR fucking players on this list.
Holy crap
Honestly feels right.
Baldwin had a great season but I’m super happy we have Horton.
Highway robbery.
Robbed 🤦🏼♂️ i thought he had it locked, tf happened
Let’s be real – fanatics paid them off because Cade Horton red rookies were hella more printed than either of the winners….. it’s all rigged
WE GET SNUBBED. YET AGAIN. WHEN WILL IT END