Ran Carthon gives Titans a C- in his re-grade of this year’s draft. I have to wonder how he would grade his own draft picks…

35 comments
  1. A C- for the draft of Cam Ward? (Not the whole draft) So far yeah that makes sense. He hasn’t looked good. Y’all really just looking for any reason to be mad.

  2. How is hunter a b-? He’s been a c at best. And Loveland being a b+ is crazy, he’s had like one good game lol

  3. He gives Membou an A (deservedly) but then Campbell and Banks get a C+? Is there any logic to what he does lmao

  4. Some weird grades on here. Hunter is a C at best, Campbell probably closer to an A than a C, and recency bias at its best on Loveland

  5. Oh that makes me feel better about Ward. Ran’s not exactly the best at evaluating QB talent here.

  6. Who cares??!!?? Ran absolutely sucked and got fired! No one cares about his opinions honestly

  7. Fuck Ran, that being said, objectively this is a fair grade.. On Cam that is, some of these other grades are just strange. Hunter is a C at best, Campbell and Banks is just odd.. But yeah, Cam is a C-, arguably a D.. I hate how bad he’s been, it sucks because I really thought he was gonna be great. That’s what I get for believing in this franchise

  8. The real question is who gives a F what ran carthon thinks about anything football related.

  9. Was wondering why Campbell was so lowly graded, then I saw it’s according to Carthon. 

  10. How is taking a QB with tremendous arm talent a worse grade than the Raiders, who are utterly devoid of talent besides Bowers and Crosby, worse than taking Jeanty at 6? And I love Jeanty

  11. On the flip side of all this, is there any credence to a new gm (regardless of team) going out with the old and in with the new on this scale simply because it makes them look good?

    I am not saying there is credence to it, but now people can look at Rans drafts, free agencies, trades(picks the new gm used) etc, and say “well that gm sucked because those players arent here anymore.” (we were going to have a bad record no matter what)

    I am absolutely not a Ran truther, but Ran left the door open for another GM to come in and take over in the event that he was fired.

    With that said, I think Ran has been hindsight is 20/20’d real hard. Exactly what he is doing here.

  12. When other ex-gms do this exercise they do it for draft classes 3-5 years ago so you can truly view them through the lens of what they have become in the league. Half a season is nowhere near enough time to evaluate anyone in this league, whether their current status be good or bad.

  13. Fuck him that my grade for him as the GM in his only year him. He’s a scrub that’s worse than Jon Robinson was in his last 2 years. Hopefully he never gets another GM spot in this league

  14. This is rage bait at its finest. Ms Amy seems to pour all the gasoline and everyone she fires is more than happy to light the match.

  15. Yea even after Travis Hunter is hurt and OUT for the season…he gives them a B-. Carthon is showing why he clearly got fired.

Leave a Reply