Cristopher Sanchez not being on the first team is a joke. Dude was the third best pitcher during the 2025 regular season.
PCA was abysmal for a good part of the year. Downright terrible
Perdomo got robbed
I love Bo but cmon Perdomo had a crazy year
Can we make a third team? Please? From Atlanta.
The Matt Olson disrespect is insane. He hit just as well as Vladdy but is a much better defender. Kurtz wasn’t even qualified.
Olson lead all qualified 1B in fWAR and as far as I can tell bWAR. And it wasn’t really close.
I’m just here for the comment section 👀
Justice for Maikel Garcia. He was an absolute revelation this season.
How is Edwin Diaz not on the first team?
Who votes on this again? They make some absolutely batshit picks every year. Max Fried first team over Brown and Sanchez? Bichette over Perdomo? Give a a break.
Nico Horner snubbed
Duran over Mason Miller is cute
What is Nico Hoerner, chopped liver?
where is webby? 🙁
I love Vladdy, but what is he doing ahead of Kurtz?
perdomo robbed…
I’m glad Will Smith got second team!
He’s my favorite player on the Dodgers, and had a great year, and was a beast in the playoffs. After Yoshi, was arguably our second best player in the World Series, and he hit the go ahead run in the 11th
Brown was a Cy Young finalist. Fried was not.
There’s no reason Fried should be First team and Brown Second team
Theoretical 162 Season, what is the W-L of each of those teams facing the rest of the league and each other 6 times? Someone also tell me how much the team cost
Christian Sanchez robbed
I’m sorry but how the fuck is Bo here over Perdomo lol
Why do they select 5 full SP for team 1/2 for 10 total and only 2 RP for 4 total.. gotta be a few relievers that deserve a little more love, it’s a crowded field
Happy to see Will Smith get his shine
Kurtz on here for that crazy HR game and that’s all 😭
Where the fuck is Logan Webb
Which team wins in a 7 game series?
Woo for Woo!
Vladdy over Kurtz and Alonso 😂😂😂😂
Why is there no Rockies players? /s
Duran doesn’t get a nice smiley photo too?
As a Twins fan, the Dhuran pick hurts
Dude let’s do one week practice Jan 15-20 and a three game one weekend series. Win the first, double header, lose, Sunday night 1st v 2nd team. One week in mid January
What! No Rockies on this team 🤪
This is the first time in a while I’ve payed close attention to the MLB awards and damn, a lot of them do not make much sense
I am a mets fan, but finally no overrated lindor.
Sanchez not on first team 😭
Aroldis Chapman making first team at age 37 after several down seasons is nuts.
37 comments
Cristopher Sanchez not being on the first team is a joke. Dude was the third best pitcher during the 2025 regular season.
PCA was abysmal for a good part of the year. Downright terrible
Perdomo got robbed
I love Bo but cmon Perdomo had a crazy year
Can we make a third team? Please? From Atlanta.
The Matt Olson disrespect is insane. He hit just as well as Vladdy but is a much better defender. Kurtz wasn’t even qualified.
Olson lead all qualified 1B in fWAR and as far as I can tell bWAR. And it wasn’t really close.
I’m just here for the comment section 👀
Justice for Maikel Garcia. He was an absolute revelation this season.
How is Edwin Diaz not on the first team?
Who votes on this again? They make some absolutely batshit picks every year. Max Fried first team over Brown and Sanchez? Bichette over Perdomo? Give a a break.
Nico Horner snubbed
Duran over Mason Miller is cute
What is Nico Hoerner, chopped liver?
where is webby? 🙁
I love Vladdy, but what is he doing ahead of Kurtz?
perdomo robbed…
I’m glad Will Smith got second team!
He’s my favorite player on the Dodgers, and had a great year, and was a beast in the playoffs. After Yoshi, was arguably our second best player in the World Series, and he hit the go ahead run in the 11th
Brown was a Cy Young finalist. Fried was not.
There’s no reason Fried should be First team and Brown Second team
Theoretical 162 Season, what is the W-L of each of those teams facing the rest of the league and each other 6 times? Someone also tell me how much the team cost
Christian Sanchez robbed
I’m sorry but how the fuck is Bo here over Perdomo lol
Why do they select 5 full SP for team 1/2 for 10 total and only 2 RP for 4 total.. gotta be a few relievers that deserve a little more love, it’s a crowded field
Happy to see Will Smith get his shine
Kurtz on here for that crazy HR game and that’s all 😭
Where the fuck is Logan Webb
Which team wins in a 7 game series?
Woo for Woo!
Vladdy over Kurtz and Alonso 😂😂😂😂
Why is there no Rockies players? /s
Duran doesn’t get a nice smiley photo too?
As a Twins fan, the Dhuran pick hurts
Dude let’s do one week practice Jan 15-20 and a three game one weekend series. Win the first, double header, lose, Sunday night 1st v 2nd team. One week in mid January
What! No Rockies on this team 🤪
This is the first time in a while I’ve payed close attention to the MLB awards and damn, a lot of them do not make much sense
I am a mets fan, but finally no overrated lindor.
Sanchez not on first team 😭
Aroldis Chapman making first team at age 37 after several down seasons is nuts.