[Talkin Yanks]: Aaron Judge received 11 votes for New York City mayor in the 2025 election
December 3, 2025
[Talkin Yanks]: Aaron Judge received 11 votes for New York City mayor in the 2025 election
38 comments
That number seems way too low
That’s actually way lower than I’d expect
Brunson got 28
Serious question.
What happens if he won?
He will also leave New York because of this
Pete Alonzo got 3 votes.
He’s a Judge, not a Mayor. Are New Yorkers stupid?
He beat the Polar Bear.
It’s one louder
Juan Sucko didn’t get a single vote! Biggest contract bust in history??
imagine if aaron judge or pete alonso won the mayor race and instead of mamdani and socialist government grocery stores we instead had socialist baseball grocery stores where everyone got tons of free hot dogs and beers and ice cream every time one of them hit a homer
Is that enough to win?
Seems like a major violation of separation of powers for Judge (judicial branch) to be Mayor (executive branch).
11 for Judge, and only 3 for PCA?
This is the real evidence for the MVP of New York baseball.
how many do we think juan soto got ?
I’m just thrown off by Judge in a suit!
stop the steal
Ha! Beat that, Pete!
still a better use of a vote than the 7k that still went for adams
Yet another post season loss for Judge
NY POST in some alternative reality:
# MAYOR JUDGE HAMMERS CRIME, ALSO A BALL
Probably more than Eric Adams
Is that normalized for his ballpark dimensions?
We all know who the real Mayor of NYC is…

Unironically a better choice than some of the ones on the ballot
All rise, the judicial and executive branch of the government presides.
If he became Mayor he’d have to give up the bench because you can’t be the chief executive and a member of the judicial branch
Is there anything in the rules stopping him from being both mayor and a player
Should’ve been Cal
I voted for Francisco Lindor for president once
Politics isn’t a game and I hate when people do shit like this and make it into one
38 comments
That number seems way too low
That’s actually way lower than I’d expect
Brunson got 28
Serious question.
What happens if he won?
He will also leave New York because of this
Pete Alonzo got 3 votes.
He’s a Judge, not a Mayor. Are New Yorkers stupid?
He beat the Polar Bear.
It’s one louder
Juan Sucko didn’t get a single vote! Biggest contract bust in history??
imagine if aaron judge or pete alonso won the mayor race and instead of mamdani and socialist government grocery stores we instead had socialist baseball grocery stores where everyone got tons of free hot dogs and beers and ice cream every time one of them hit a homer
Is that enough to win?
Seems like a major violation of separation of powers for Judge (judicial branch) to be Mayor (executive branch).
11 for Judge, and only 3 for PCA?
This is the real evidence for the MVP of New York baseball.
how many do we think juan soto got ?
I’m just thrown off by Judge in a suit!
stop the steal
Ha! Beat that, Pete!
still a better use of a vote than the 7k that still went for adams
Yet another post season loss for Judge
NY POST in some alternative reality:
# MAYOR JUDGE HAMMERS CRIME, ALSO A BALL
Probably more than Eric Adams
Is that normalized for his ballpark dimensions?
We all know who the real Mayor of NYC is…

Unironically a better choice than some of the ones on the ballot
All rise, the judicial and executive branch of the government presides.
If he became Mayor he’d have to give up the bench because you can’t be the chief executive and a member of the judicial branch
Is there anything in the rules stopping him from being both mayor and a player
Should’ve been Cal
I voted for Francisco Lindor for president once
Politics isn’t a game and I hate when people do shit like this and make it into one
Where’d that number come from? I’m looking at the election summary from https://vote.nyc/page/election-results-summary
And it seems like Judge got 7
I mean, he’s big enough to carry New York on his back.
Wouldn’t District Attorney be more up his alley?
I feel like mayoral duties might interfere with his on-field performance. I mean it’s already affecting his time in the courtroom…
Surprised he didn’t at least beat Eric Adams…
Less than half of what I had hoped for
Would have been a better choice.