Good choices but Parrish over Rodriguez is wild. I get that you could argue Pudge wasn’t here long enough, but the same could be said about Scherzer and Skubal.
I can’t argue with that list. But if I did it would look like this
C: Don Kelly
1B: Don Kelly
2B: Don Kelly
3B: Don Kelly
SS: Don Kelly
LF: Don Kelly
CF: Don Kelly
RF: Don Kelly
SP… Nate Cornejo
Whitaker or Gehringer is quite difficult. Obviously I’m picking Lou because the other only exists in my mind as a glorious stat page on baseball reference.
Shoutout to Dizzy Trout
8-man rotation. Baseball is getting soft!
Gibby needs to be on the team somewhere.
Ugh. Didn’t realize Todd Jones was the Tigers all time Saves leader. Doesn’t seem possible.
I’d put Mike Henneman on here over Valverde, who only had one really great year with the Tigers. Henneman was basically a career Tiger, except the very end, and seems more worthy of a spot.
Our bullpens just haven’t really been much to write home about over history, have they?
The correct D being featured. Change it back.
Did Scherzer have a enough of a dominant career with the Tigers to make the list? First couple of years so so. Last few years were amazing. But would think other starting pitchers with the Tigers with a longer tenure.
9 comments
Good choices but Parrish over Rodriguez is wild. I get that you could argue Pudge wasn’t here long enough, but the same could be said about Scherzer and Skubal.
I can’t argue with that list. But if I did it would look like this
C: Don Kelly
1B: Don Kelly
2B: Don Kelly
3B: Don Kelly
SS: Don Kelly
LF: Don Kelly
CF: Don Kelly
RF: Don Kelly
SP… Nate Cornejo
Whitaker or Gehringer is quite difficult. Obviously I’m picking Lou because the other only exists in my mind as a glorious stat page on baseball reference.
Shoutout to Dizzy Trout
8-man rotation. Baseball is getting soft!
Gibby needs to be on the team somewhere.
Ugh. Didn’t realize Todd Jones was the Tigers all time Saves leader. Doesn’t seem possible.
I’d put Mike Henneman on here over Valverde, who only had one really great year with the Tigers. Henneman was basically a career Tiger, except the very end, and seems more worthy of a spot.
Our bullpens just haven’t really been much to write home about over history, have they?
The correct D being featured. Change it back.
Did Scherzer have a enough of a dominant career with the Tigers to make the list? First couple of years so so. Last few years were amazing. But would think other starting pitchers with the Tigers with a longer tenure.