[Passan] Right-hander Dustin May and the St. Louis Cardinals are in agreement on a free agent contract, pending physical, sources tell ESPN.
December 13, 2025
[Passan] Right-hander Dustin May and the St. Louis Cardinals are in agreement on a free agent contract, pending physical, sources tell ESPN.
31 comments
Cool ig
Dustin May is such an enigma, dude has got elite stuff and movement that constantly lands in the middle of the zone and is then rocked.
I’m surprised the cardinals are spending any money this offseason to begin with
I dunno how I feel about this, mostly because I honestly didn’t even know that May was even a free agent lol, I was paying a lot more attention to the trade markets
But our rotation is really young/crappy rn, so makes sense
Such red
I mean someone’s gotta pitch. Libby, McGreevy, and Pallante were the only rostered actual starters before this. Was hoping for Scherzer on a 1 year.
Great work with that trade, Breslow
I’m all for it. Guy is filthy, or at least he was pre-injury. Didn’t really watch him this year
Giving up some of the already bad Devers return for this guy was just icing on the worst cake I’ve ever had
Pending physical should be lit up in bright neon colours
Yep, that’s a Cardinals signing
I like this. Couldn’t have cost much, he has good stuff, maybe he turns it around. Not a signing I ever expected they’d make, but there’s definitely potential here.
Plus. Red hair. Red bird. Match made in heaven
Boston really made the trade of all time
Nasty stuff that will be fun to watch as a Cards fan. Hoping for the upside but probably not going to come. The long red hair will pop in a Cards uniform. Always wanted them to connect on May trade in the past before injury and him struggling to figure it out
Hope he can put it all together. When he’s on he’s on but when he’s off you want to throw things at the television.
Also: he looks like a character from one of those 1960’s holiday stop motion films so I’ll always root for him.
okay
I’m actually cool with this.
thank God
Most frustrating guy to watch could be dealing for 4 innings gets shelled once and just spirals after that.
Or you think he’s dealing and then you realize he’s at 90 pitches in the 4th inning 😭
He’ll go on a stinker spree and when you’re about to give up on him he’ll pull out an 7IP 1ER 9Ks gem from God knows where
Huge fan of his
Hoping he breaks out this year
Could be good, could be bad. Red on red tho
Wish him well. Wasn’t ever able to quite put it all together here, but there’s definite upside.
I wish all my exes well.
I dig it
When he’s healthy he’s elite I think this a good move hopefully it works out well
This actually has potential to be a great signing. What the hell lol
I still think he’s gonna be great he was just finally coming back this year so a full offseason should do him good
I dig it. Big upside, not much risk.
Midwest is great for him. Less salads.
I enjoyed Dustin May but plan to enjoy 6 controllable years of James Tibbs III more!
Honestly I’m for it, this upcoming season has low expectations and we need to fill out the rotation. Unless we’re massively overpaying I don’t see any downsides. Honestly I’m just happy we finally made another move.
31 comments
Cool ig
Dustin May is such an enigma, dude has got elite stuff and movement that constantly lands in the middle of the zone and is then rocked.
I’m surprised the cardinals are spending any money this offseason to begin with
I dunno how I feel about this, mostly because I honestly didn’t even know that May was even a free agent lol, I was paying a lot more attention to the trade markets
But our rotation is really young/crappy rn, so makes sense
Such red
I mean someone’s gotta pitch. Libby, McGreevy, and Pallante were the only rostered actual starters before this. Was hoping for Scherzer on a 1 year.
Great work with that trade, Breslow
I’m all for it. Guy is filthy, or at least he was pre-injury. Didn’t really watch him this year
Giving up some of the already bad Devers return for this guy was just icing on the worst cake I’ve ever had
Pending physical should be lit up in bright neon colours
Yep, that’s a Cardinals signing
I like this. Couldn’t have cost much, he has good stuff, maybe he turns it around. Not a signing I ever expected they’d make, but there’s definitely potential here.
Plus. Red hair. Red bird. Match made in heaven
Boston really made the trade of all time
Nasty stuff that will be fun to watch as a Cards fan. Hoping for the upside but probably not going to come. The long red hair will pop in a Cards uniform. Always wanted them to connect on May trade in the past before injury and him struggling to figure it out
Hope he can put it all together. When he’s on he’s on but when he’s off you want to throw things at the television.
Also: he looks like a character from one of those 1960’s holiday stop motion films so I’ll always root for him.
okay
I’m actually cool with this.
thank God
Most frustrating guy to watch could be dealing for 4 innings gets shelled once and just spirals after that.
Or you think he’s dealing and then you realize he’s at 90 pitches in the 4th inning 😭
He’ll go on a stinker spree and when you’re about to give up on him he’ll pull out an 7IP 1ER 9Ks gem from God knows where
Huge fan of his
Hoping he breaks out this year
Could be good, could be bad. Red on red tho
Wish him well. Wasn’t ever able to quite put it all together here, but there’s definite upside.
I wish all my exes well.
I dig it
When he’s healthy he’s elite I think this a good move hopefully it works out well
This actually has potential to be a great signing. What the hell lol
I still think he’s gonna be great he was just finally coming back this year so a full offseason should do him good
I dig it. Big upside, not much risk.
Midwest is great for him. Less salads.
I enjoyed Dustin May but plan to enjoy 6 controllable years of James Tibbs III more!
Honestly I’m for it, this upcoming season has low expectations and we need to fill out the rotation. Unless we’re massively overpaying I don’t see any downsides. Honestly I’m just happy we finally made another move.
Code red