Adolis Garcia has signed a 1 year deal with the Phillies today. Fans are wondering what this means for Nick Castellanos?
December 15, 2025
Adolis Garcia has signed a 1 year deal with the Phillies today. Fans are wondering what this means for Nick Castellanos?
16 comments
Phillies getting rid of a guy that’s 75% washed for a dude that’s 50 % washed
DFa candidate


Nick the Stick signs with a Midwest team
The Phillies would be absolute fools to keep Castellanos around. There’s a chance he can still be productive offensively. But he has a strong case for being the worst defensive outfielder of all time and throws fits when he gets replaced by elite defenders in obvious defensive replacement situations. Seems like a total “me guy” and he has not hit enough over the past few years to put up with that nonsense
I think that Garcia will… and that’s a drive into deep left field by Castellanos. It will be a home run. And so that’ll make it a 4-0 ballgame.
Overpaid imo
We are not wondering what it means.
We are simply waiting for his exit via whatever method they choose.
No Phillies fan is wondering about this, Castellanos has been a goner since the middle of last year.
With national tragedies on the rise who wouldn’t want to sign nick?
why would they be wondering anything? the phillies practically said outright they have no interest in keeping him. he’ll be waived if they can’t trade him
We’ve known Nick is gone for quite a while
PleasePleasePleasePlease come to Texas! We’ll take JT, too.
Sure seems like quite a few FA signings are just for 1 or 2 years? It’s almost like owners know 2027 ain’t gonna happen.
16 comments
Phillies getting rid of a guy that’s 75% washed for a dude that’s 50 % washed
DFa candidate


Nick the Stick signs with a Midwest team
The Phillies would be absolute fools to keep Castellanos around. There’s a chance he can still be productive offensively. But he has a strong case for being the worst defensive outfielder of all time and throws fits when he gets replaced by elite defenders in obvious defensive replacement situations. Seems like a total “me guy” and he has not hit enough over the past few years to put up with that nonsense
I think that Garcia will… and that’s a drive into deep left field by Castellanos. It will be a home run. And so that’ll make it a 4-0 ballgame.
Overpaid imo
We are not wondering what it means.
We are simply waiting for his exit via whatever method they choose.
No Phillies fan is wondering about this, Castellanos has been a goner since the middle of last year.
With national tragedies on the rise who wouldn’t want to sign nick?
why would they be wondering anything? the phillies practically said outright they have no interest in keeping him. he’ll be waived if they can’t trade him
We’ve known Nick is gone for quite a while
PleasePleasePleasePlease come to Texas! We’ll take JT, too.
Sure seems like quite a few FA signings are just for 1 or 2 years? It’s almost like owners know 2027 ain’t gonna happen.
Still doing the outfield bandaid approach I see.