Exploring which young SF Giants pitcher has the most trade value
December 20, 2025
Birdsong, Whisenhunt, Seymour mentioned here, but McDonald could likely be included in that group as well.
2 comments
If we are counting Seymour as young then Roupp should be in the mix too because they are the same age. If Roupp is included I think he would have the most value.
I would say Birdsong based on the stuff and pitches he has. If he’s able to get his control under wraps and hone his pitches then he can be a good starter. He already has the stuff and he’s definitely shown flashes of being really good
2 comments
If we are counting Seymour as young then Roupp should be in the mix too because they are the same age. If Roupp is included I think he would have the most value.
I would say Birdsong based on the stuff and pitches he has. If he’s able to get his control under wraps and hone his pitches then he can be a good starter. He already has the stuff and he’s definitely shown flashes of being really good