Do YOU think that any of these players will make an All Star team?
December 24, 2025
Do YOU think that any of these players will make an All Star team?
29 comments
Nico most likely I’d say.
It’s a crime that Nico hasn’t, but I think he will eventually.
rojas
Adames and Nico will soon
Adames is about to have a breakout year.
I agree with most here that Nico seems most logical
Crazy how Kiké still hasn’t made the all star team. Adames is due for one imo.
I really enjoyed rooting for Tommy Pham as a dback fan. Dude played like his life was on the line everyday.
Varsho will get in by fan vote if he’s healthy, hits like he did last year, and the Blue Jays carry last year’s momentum into ’26
Ramón Laureano certainly could after last season
JP won’t and shouldn’t even be on the team, but will for at least one more season unless Colt Emerson kills it this spring forcing M’s hand.
Adames needs to get on base more.
Nimmo had a 3 year stretch where he absolutely should have been on the Allstar team.
As a Dodger fan, I’m pretty confident that, as much as I love them, Miguel Rojas and Kiké Hernandez will not make any all-star teams.
Nico will
Lol none of them are worthy
Varsho and Adamas. Nimmo should have been on an all star team for years now
I hope JP, Nico, and Varsho will some day
Nico is the unsung hero and never gets any love from MSM
Many of these are good enough, but some are injury prone and haven’t had a good first half and none of them have the star power it takes to get over the hump in voting. Personally I think Nico will be soon, edman certainly could as well.
I guess ? There’s 68 players on the roster (34/ea) – 40-44 positions players and 24-28 pitchers. There has to be a rep from each of the 30 teams. Starters are chosen by fan vote and everyone else is picked by either players, managers, or commissioner’s office. Also, if a selected player decides to skip or is injured, a replacement is found and “both” effectively are still All-Stars.
Any one of the players listed can also put up a strong first half or get the token nod from the NL/AL manager to land one of the final spots. There’s a reason why Daniel Vogelbach, Bryan LaHair, and Tommy La Stella made the trip.
All Star teams aren’t that special (for the MLB) because every team has a rep. Anybody on this team lands on the Rockies and there’s a good chance they’re an All Star this season.
Kepler and Nimmo surprised me.
I think the easiest path would be any of them going to a bad team and being the default representative. A lot of them are on teams which have other talent which has made it harder for them to get on.
God, Braves really gave up on keeping Ramón in favor of Eli White
No
Considering a war of 5 in a season is considered all Star, yeah I’m ok with all of this
29 comments
Nico most likely I’d say.
It’s a crime that Nico hasn’t, but I think he will eventually.
rojas
Adames and Nico will soon
Adames is about to have a breakout year.
I agree with most here that Nico seems most logical
Crazy how Kiké still hasn’t made the all star team. Adames is due for one imo.
I really enjoyed rooting for Tommy Pham as a dback fan. Dude played like his life was on the line everyday.
Varsho will get in by fan vote if he’s healthy, hits like he did last year, and the Blue Jays carry last year’s momentum into ’26
Ramón Laureano certainly could after last season
JP won’t and shouldn’t even be on the team, but will for at least one more season unless Colt Emerson kills it this spring forcing M’s hand.
Adames needs to get on base more.
Nimmo had a 3 year stretch where he absolutely should have been on the Allstar team.
As a Dodger fan, I’m pretty confident that, as much as I love them, Miguel Rojas and Kiké Hernandez will not make any all-star teams.
Nico will
Lol none of them are worthy
Varsho and Adamas. Nimmo should have been on an all star team for years now
I hope JP, Nico, and Varsho will some day
Nico is the unsung hero and never gets any love from MSM
Many of these are good enough, but some are injury prone and haven’t had a good first half and none of them have the star power it takes to get over the hump in voting. Personally I think Nico will be soon, edman certainly could as well.
I guess ? There’s 68 players on the roster (34/ea) – 40-44 positions players and 24-28 pitchers. There has to be a rep from each of the 30 teams. Starters are chosen by fan vote and everyone else is picked by either players, managers, or commissioner’s office. Also, if a selected player decides to skip or is injured, a replacement is found and “both” effectively are still All-Stars.
Any one of the players listed can also put up a strong first half or get the token nod from the NL/AL manager to land one of the final spots. There’s a reason why Daniel Vogelbach, Bryan LaHair, and Tommy La Stella made the trip.
All Star teams aren’t that special (for the MLB) because every team has a rep. Anybody on this team lands on the Rockies and there’s a good chance they’re an All Star this season.
Kepler and Nimmo surprised me.
I think the easiest path would be any of them going to a bad team and being the default representative. A lot of them are on teams which have other talent which has made it harder for them to get on.
God, Braves really gave up on keeping Ramón in favor of Eli White
No
Considering a war of 5 in a season is considered all Star, yeah I’m ok with all of this
Varshon and Adames
No.