The Giants Are Completely Lost
Keith McPherson unloads on the New York Giants decision making after yet another organizational contradiction. What was once sold as a package deal between Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen has officially unraveled, and Keith is not buying the explanation.
From John Mara’s own words last year to the Giants flirting with meaningless wins, tank confusion, and a shaky plan around Jaxson Dart, this is a full breakdown of how the franchise once again finds itself stuck in the middle. Keith questions why Joe Schoen appears safe, why Brian Daboll paid the price, and whether the Giants can be trusted to get the next head coach right.
He also dives into the myth of “needed wins,” the dangers of repeating past Giants mistakes, and why this job might be attractive to outsiders but still terrifying for fans who have seen this movie before.
If you are a Giants fan, this one hits close to home.
Chapters:
00:00 The Giants Lied About the “Package Deal”
01:05 John Mara’s Words That Changed Everything
02:10 Daboll Fired but Schoen Survives
03:05 The Proven Coach Question No One Wants to Answer
04:15 Why This Feels Like the Same Old Giants
05:20 Jaxson Dart and the Development Debate
06:35 The Myth of the “Needed Win”
07:45 Why Giants Wins Actually Hurt Them
08:55 The Tank Conversation the Team Avoids
10:05 Do the Giants Already Have Their QB
11:15 How the Giants Lost Control of the Draft
12:25 Why This Coaching Hire Is Everything
13:45 Why Giants Fans Are Furious Again
#Giants #NYGiants #KeithMcPherson #WFAN #BrianDaboll #JoeSchoen #JohnMara #NFL #GiantsFootball
Subscribe for the latest New York sports news & videos!!
📡 LISTEN LIVE ➡️ https://go.audacy.com/eYtjvOIRpjb
Download the Audacy App today and stream your WFAN wherever you are!
FOLLOW US:
TWITTER – https://twitter.com/WFAN660
INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/wfansportsradio/
FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/wfan660/
26 comments
Last yr they were totally lost. This yr they have QB1, WR1, Edge1, Edge2, RB1, so they have some pieces now.
Giants are irrelevant
No top head coach wants Joe Schoen as a GM. They’re a circus l
I wish they would sell the team they never do anything right
Keith that’s a big IF, they never have gotten anything right
I hate this team
This crao goes on year in year out with the giants and ownership is responsible. Are they telling us the reason they don’t fire Schoen is because they don’t want to do the work? I think you’re right and thats bs
Yes!!!! Hes back baby!!!!!!
Mara owes the fans on a new direction, you can’t do things half assed and have a new coach and gm on different time lines. They’re pathetic!!!
The nfl is made to get between 7-9 wins Every year and the giants only hit that once or twice decade lol
I can't wait till Kafka is FIRED. AND JOE SCHOEN SUX!! I DON'T TRUST HIM TO DRAFT ANYMORE PLAYERS. OR PICK A COACH!! HE IS CLUELESS!!
NFL and baseball need a relegation league like European soccer let the Pittsburgh Pirates be demoted to the 4th division and the Giants, Jets same
dart sucks lol
Thought keith was gone
Keith is back!!!
I'm not familiar with this dude, but he's 100% on point. I thought he was just a fill-in or a backup but the comments apparently know and love him.
I don't know what setting this is where he gets to talk by himself but it works for him. WFAN, please keep this dude on the radio/Youtube.
Came crawling back
Fire Joe
hes not back
Don’t be surprised when it’s Lou Anarumo. Shoen doesn’t want someone with any power. All he’s gotta do is sell it to the Mara family.
The Haters are gonna act like someone pi$$ed in their Cheerios 🥣 this morning.
Shoutout to Keith! 😂
Dart is not the guy, he openly admitted that “I’m not joe Flacco” (pocket passer).
No only running QB wins a Super Bowl, you have to learn how to throw that’s literally a qbs job.
The Giants aren’t a serious team or franchise.
Deonte Banks is mainly good at returning punts and is more of a special teams player. He struggles with coverage and tackling and isn’t suited to play cornerback.
Organization is hiring not JS
We had a good team with a bad record. That's Joe and his camp work. He needs a aggressive DC with the HC.