NEW Mel Kiper Jr. Giants Mock Draft

36 comments

1. Grade the pick of Carnell Tate at #5! A, B, C, D or F

2. Nabers WILL NOT be the same

3. Sign Tyler Linderbaum, let Wandell Robinson go (he'll be too expensive for what he is), then get Carnell Tate to replace Wandell.

4. Feel like it’ll be Downs, Styles or whoever they prefer out of Fano and Mauigoa. Maybe a little “rich” for S/LB but if it hits it could be pretty nice

5. So if Malik Nabers gets hurt again..then what?? DRAFT A WR NO QUESTION

6. 1st time im not stressing out. Let the chips fly.

7. I want downs …I honestly like Tyson better than Tate

8. I like a wide receiver because Malik is coming back from ACL takes 2 years to come back from that…

9. We need to build up the OL. If we sign a couple OL vets in FA then I’d be ok w drafting a WR in round 1

10. I rather trade down. We're kinda screwed on picks. Besides we have no choice to get a WR early. We have no idea what Naber's going to be like after an ACL. He may never be the same again.

11. B grade we do need it but he’s not that great that’s so high to take a WR#2 the needs a lot of other players you can take in the #5 spot

12. Marshall. What are you going to be saying if they have a losing season? You are all hey yay beautiful day right now. But I already know you speak from emotion not logic an reality.

13. I’d be happy with either Tate, Downs, or Tyson but I’m leading more towards Caleb Downs

14. Ah yes my favorite TV show

15. Tate is the best pick only true valuable hole on our team is WR2 who’s worth a top 5 pick

16. Kiper lacks whatever credibility he once had. Last year’s temper tantrum over NFL GMs ignoring his Board makes him just another sports bar prognosticator.

17. Shiii, 💪🏽Tate n Nabers?💪🏽

18. I think Harbaugh taking us to NFC divisional playoffs. He immediately recognized that his new team has a serious ILB issue. I mean immediately spotted that not having adequate LBs cost us leads in the 4th and horrible ST coverage.

19. I think I may try to get someone like Romeo Doubs in free agency, and then go BPA at #5 which is likely Caleb Downs if he's there. I just want that leader in the secondary, a Kyle Hamilton esque leader who can play deep middle of the field, who can play nickel, who can play in the flat and around the line of scrimmage, who can do it all. Just a swiss army knife kinda safety who you know is gonna be physical and lead the way under someone like Harbaugh.

    Nubin's lack of athleticism is hamstringing the safety position for the Giants. It's a high pick to spend on a safety, but the safety position is more important than ever, and guys who can be flexible and play free safety, strong safety, nickel corner, can play man or zone… that versatility adds so much more value to the position.

    Romeo Doubs is the kinda receiver who would compliment Nabers. Vertical threat, can play the flanker position if Nabers stays as your X receiver. Like is he a power house name? No. Can he be a 700-1000 yard receiver as a #2? Yes. It would be a noticeable upgrade from Slayton. Green Bay isn't gonna keep all those young receivers and Doubs seems like someone who's not gonna get re-signed. If I can get someone like that without having to break the bank, it saves me from having to spend a top 5 pick on a WR2. I like both Tate and Tyson, but man I look at Tyler Nubin and see a lot of room for improvement lmao. The secondary has to be better. If we don't keep Wan'dale Robinson though, then my opinion changes where taking a receiver at #5 becomes a lot more necessary imo.

20. B+ Tatee or Tyson

21. I trust whatever Harbaugh does. But the way I’d do it personally, I’d focus on drafting defense (preferably Downs) and I’d focus on bolstering the offense through free agency. The offense is young and dynamic and needs some veterans. The defense has plenty of vets and could benefit with more younger high ceiling guys.

22. I don’t concern myself with the opinions of “Mel Kiper”

23. I don't like Wondale in the slot, he's better as a wideout, Slaton would be more reliable in the slot if he is kept. I see Harbaugh drafting the line of scrimmage on both sides of ball and then LB and safety. I don't see Jermaine Eluemunor getting a large payday because Harbaugh will build for the future and I think he's planning on developing Even Neal at RT, hence firing Carmen Bricillo, but just guessing.

24. ye im wondering about a trade back scenario as well

25. If we are smart our first option for the #5 pick should be to trade down inside the top 10 and no lower than the top 12 . If we get offered a 1st rounder for next year that would be gold. Next year draft will be alot better for teams looking to trade up and draft QB's in the 1st round ala Archie Manning mania.

26. 1st Round: Caleb Downs S Ohio State, 2nd Round: KC Conception WR Texas A&M, 3rd Round: Jocob Rodriguez LB Texas Tech

27. It would be an A you're building around the most important player on the team

28. A+ Grade

29. Wan'dale is going to walk there's no way we're paying 60 million and Darius slayton has never been productive

30. I like the young man Carnel Tate

31. Something tells me MN won’t be ready till after the season starts. His surgery was more involved than they had said so if they draft a WR I’m ok with it. I’d rather Downs or Reese but whoever they draft I’m good with it

32. The stupidity of the talking heads all having us pick a WR is just the nature of sports talk. Everyone is about offense and having to build the next "greatest show on turf". Defense in both the media space and the Rules committee is something to be suppressed in seeking highlight clips. Real football, LB Oline or Secondary in the first round. That and I would rather have Lemon then Tate.

33. Giants have a bigger need on Def than Off. I'm picking Downs first. The return of Nabers and resigning Wan Dale plus free agency and a 4th round draft pick should be enough. Gunnar could take a step up or even replace Wan Dale. Hopefully Theo and Fidone can contribute more too.

34. 5:43 Games are won in the trenches, offensive and defensive lines. Draft a offensive lineman, then get a corner, receiver in the later rounds.Or in a trade, or free agency.

35. Id give Tate pick a B. Taking a prove prospect, but not exactly what we need

36. Tate is good but i believe that Malacki Fields is the better receiver for the NFL plus Harbaugh is gonna bring IBJ back for a farewell tour!