Ranking all 63 starting quarterbacks from the 2025 NFL season
February 12, 2026
Love at 14 is laughable in my opinion. Not sure guys who played half a season or less deserve to be ranked ahead. No way you can tell me Herbert, Caleb, Goff, or Darnold were better during the regular season.
14 comments
Why are Love stans so insecure?
Love was top 5 this season, he even missed some games and was hamstrung by poor play calling and and a bad O-Line. His efficiency so should count for a lot more than volume stats like yards. Nice to see his interception rate be low as well.
That’s hilarious. Maye ranked that high and lost to rodgers
Caleb Williams being that high is kind of a joke. He is dog water for 3 quarters in a lot of games and then pulls a rabbit out of his ass in the 4th to bail himself out of the hole he put himself in.
Herbert at 5 is a fucking joke.
No.14 Jordan Love — “Love just needs to throw 4 TD more often for the Packers to reach their potential”
No.5 Justin Herbert — “Herbert deserves a medal of courage”
lol get the fuck out of here with this.
Not one of the QBs listed in tier 2 performed better than Love this last season.
What a silly list.
Hell yeah, nice to see Love getting some recognition. He’s sandwiched right between mahomes and Purdy and on the cusp of top 10. Valid
The list is a joke. Love should obviously be higher. Williams lower.
However, I think Williams really did turn the corner in the playoffs with a lot of momentum and surging talent around him going into next year. He also is pretty damn good in high leverage situations.
On the other hand,
Love’s play worries me and he often makes me rather nervous but usually gets the jobs done. But, he has failed more often than not in the biggest moments.
Yes, the Bears still suck.
Just being a realist here
Below Caleb is a wild take. Caleb didn’t even break 60% completion rate. 😂
All QB metrics have Love in the top 5. What a fucking joke.
14 comments
Why are Love stans so insecure?
Love was top 5 this season, he even missed some games and was hamstrung by poor play calling and and a bad O-Line. His efficiency so should count for a lot more than volume stats like yards. Nice to see his interception rate be low as well.
That’s hilarious. Maye ranked that high and lost to rodgers
Caleb Williams being that high is kind of a joke. He is dog water for 3 quarters in a lot of games and then pulls a rabbit out of his ass in the 4th to bail himself out of the hole he put himself in.
Herbert at 5 is a fucking joke.
No.14 Jordan Love — “Love just needs to throw 4 TD more often for the Packers to reach their potential”
No.5 Justin Herbert — “Herbert deserves a medal of courage”
lol get the fuck out of here with this.
Not one of the QBs listed in tier 2 performed better than Love this last season.
What a silly list.
Hell yeah, nice to see Love getting some recognition. He’s sandwiched right between mahomes and Purdy and on the cusp of top 10. Valid
The list is a joke. Love should obviously be higher. Williams lower.
However, I think Williams really did turn the corner in the playoffs with a lot of momentum and surging talent around him going into next year. He also is pretty damn good in high leverage situations.
On the other hand,
Love’s play worries me and he often makes me rather nervous but usually gets the jobs done. But, he has failed more often than not in the biggest moments.
Yes, the Bears still suck.
Just being a realist here
Below Caleb is a wild take. Caleb didn’t even break 60% completion rate. 😂
All QB metrics have Love in the top 5. What a fucking joke.
Written by a bears or lions fan for sure
Only 10 higher than Malik… wtf..
14 is absolutely comical lmao