How Ken Griffey Jr. and the Cincinnati Reds Became a Catastrophic Failure

Switch to T-Mobile and get free MLB.TV​. Redeem March 24-30 at T-Mobile.com/MLB. Subject to change. Qualified plan required. Must access T-Mobile Tuesdays in T-Life app and sign up for MLB.TV. Blackout and other restrictions apply. ™/© 2026 MLB

Baseball fans will always picture Ken Griffey Jr. in a Seattle Mariners uniform. It’s easy to forget that nearly half of his career was played in a different uniform. Where did Junior and the Cincinnati Reds go wrong in their near-decade together?

Follow me on Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/jolly_olive
and Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jollyolive_/
Grab some merch: https://shop.jomboymedia.com/collections/jolly-olive
Join my Discord: https://discord.gg/Fbs2hX3r

Sources:
https://www.mlb.com/news/ken-griffey-jr-reds-trade-in-2000
https://www.mlb.com/news/ken-griffey-jr-traded-to-mets-possibilities
https://www.espn.com/mlb/news/2002/0222/1338601.html
https://www.espn.com/mlb/news/2002/1205/1472030.html

How Ken Griffey Jr. came close to playing for Padres


ww.beaconortho.com/blog/reds-medical-director-kremchek-celebrates-25-years-on-the-job/

Music:






All statistics courtesy of Baseball Reference, Fangraphs, Baseball Savant, Inside Edge, and Stathead.

#MLB #Mariners #Reds

32 comments
  1. I guess as a Cardinal fan I consider the year 2000 to be pretty special. Nobody knew who Albert Pujols was yet. But 2000 marked the year that for all intents and purposes kicked off the era of Cardinal success. The connection to the Reds is that both teams acquired superstar centerfielders prior to the season. Griffey to the Reds, and Edmonds to the Cardinals. Griffey was the more acclaimed player between the two, undoubtedly. But the Cardinals simply got out of the gate white hot with a power-packed offense. The Reds would come to St Louis for a July 4th week series, in which the Cardinals would solidify their position atop the NL Central for the 2000 season, with Edmonds slamming 2 homers on July 4th. At the end of the 1st half, Edmonds and McGwire hitting back to back each had 25+ homers and an OPS over 1.100. Perhaps on pace to be one of the most prolific back-to-back combos ever (Soto-Judge was pretty good in 2024). McGwire unfortunately missed most of the 2nd half with a knee injury that would ultimately end his career. But the Cardinals added Will Clark to buffer the loss of Big Mac, and cruised to 95 wins with an exciting mix of veterans (Edmonds, Clark, Matheny, Kile, Eric Davis, Shawon Dunston, Ray Lankford, etc) and young players (Renteria, JD Drew, Ankiel, Tatis, Placido Polanco etc). I suppose I am biased because 2000 was the first season I can remember watching as a young Cardinal fan. Still, to me it was a uniquely exciting team and very talented with a heartbreaking 5 game NLCS loss to the Mets.

  2. What an absolute bonehead move he made leaving Seattle!
    The Mariners could've used him in 2000-2001 when they played the Yankees in the ALCS.
    Some people are their own worst enemy.

  3. He might be THE player I have FOMO over in my lifetime. And I’m someone who went to several Reds games in his era. I didn’t get Griffey being Griffey and that sucks. But I have grown a fondness for the Mariners despite only living in the Seattle area for about 6 months in 2017 (but I went to two games!)

  4. When Ken Griffey Jr was with the Cincinnati Reds the Reds just got new ownership. This ownership did not have the team on the same level as the 1990s teams which includes a 1990s Word Series Championship & getting to the 1995 NLCS. The Reds ownership did not build a good team around Ken Griffey Jr. The Reds never got to the playoffs with Ken Griffey Jr. Ken Griffey Jr also got injured a lot when he entered his 30s which includes his time on the Reds. Even in the present day March 2026 the Reds have not won a playoffs series since 1995.

  5. The kid was such an amazing baseball player and Center fielder. I absolutely loved collecting his baseball cards as a kid. I've recently been trying to collect his cards again as my childhood set was sold or given away years ago

  6. He always looked p*** off the last couple of years in seattle. Grass is not always greener, but I understand why he left. Cincy was really his home, it was where his daddy made his name, and the Reds were much bigger baseball name back then than they are now. JR probably thought they could replicate the big red machine again. but the Reds were just were really bad. And even though his stats were stil pretty good, i don't remember many big hits or good plays when he was with the reds.

  7. Blessed enough to do some work in his home and man him and his family are the nicest people. What could have been without injuries man

Leave a Reply