The fairway and sand traps overlooking Boston, at Granite Links golf course in Quincy, Mass. (Robin Lubbock/WBUR)
High on a hilltop, 10 miles south of downtown Boston, Tom Palmer surveyed the sweeping views of the harbor and the nearby Blue Hills reservation. Gray clouds hung above the islands in the distance, slowly moving toward Boston’s skyline.
Palmer was standing on a site in the city of Quincy once known for landfills and granite quarries — until 13 million tons of dirt from the Big Dig was trucked in.
Now, hundreds of acres of this publicly owned land is occupied by a golf course.
“I’m seeing, like, dozens of square miles from one spot,” he said. “This is a special place.”
That’s the one thing people on both sides of a long-simmering battle over control of Granite Links agree on.
More than two decades after the 27-hole course opened, the debate surrounding its future has landed on Beacon Hill, where the House is led by Speaker Ron Mariano, a Quincy Democrat.
Deal for a lifetime
House lawmakers last month slipped an amendment on the golf course into a multibillion-dollar spending bill meant to close the books on the previous year’s state budget. It would extend the current operators’ remaining 30-year grip on the links by another 50, until 2106.
Beacon Hill lawmakers are negotiating the final version of the spending bill. But the golf course amendment has put Quincy’s mayor and state senator, who served together inside City Hall as the development came together in the 1990s, at odds. Mayor Tom Koch backs the lease extension, while state Sen. John Keenan has questions about what he describes as a “sleight of hand” maneuver.
The driving range at Granite Links golf course in Quincy, Mass. (Robin Lubbock/WBUR)
The budget bill’s provision waives two state laws for the current operators, Quarry Hills Associates. One law limits leases of publicly owned land to 30 years, and another requires local governments looking to lease property to enter a bidding process.
Critics like Palmer, a 70-year-old Milton resident who has long pushed for more walking access to the Blue Hills through the golf course, say setting aside laws through a state budget provision sidesteps the legislative process.
But supporters say the lengthy lease is necessary to help finance improvements to the revenue-generating property.
“When I look at this, I don’t like it.”
state Sen. John Keenan
A spokesperson for Mariano, who has represented Quincy since 1991, deferred comment on the deal to Koch, a longtime political ally who is one of the main supporters of the proposed lease extension.
Koch said the existing deal has worked out well for the city, calling it a “phenomenal” agreement. The seven-term mayor was a young City Hall aide to another mayor when the deal with Quarry Hills was first brokered in 1992. The developers put tens of millions of their own dollars into the project, Koch said.
In return for the lease, Koch said the city has received athletic fields and open space, along with a percentage of revenue from the golf course and its restaurants. (Under the current lease, Quarry Hills is obligated to pay the city 10% of the gross golf revenue, as well as 10% of its net revenue on the hospitality side.)
A putting green with a view of Boston at Granite Links golf course in Quincy, Mass. (Robin Lubbock/WBUR)
According to Quarry Hills, the golf course employs 500 full- and part-time workers, and has sent the city $11.6 million since its opening in 2003.
“People have the right to have their opinion, of course, and the right to question and get answers, absolutely,” Koch said in an interview. “But I think this is a good thing for the city of Quincy. It has been from day one, and I’d like to see it continue.”
He also said lengthy leases are common. He pointed to the 2016 approval of a 99-year ground lease of the MBTA’s North Quincy station parking lot, near the border with Boston, which led to a mixed-use retail and residential development.
But Keenan has raised concerns about the lease extension and pressed for an audit of the existing arrangement. And while he agreed lengthy leases for public land are common, and some have required the Legislature’s approval, a lease for a golf course operation isn’t, he said.
“When I look at this, I don’t like it,” Keenan said. “I don’t like what I see. I think there needs to be more work done to determine whether it’s a sweetheart deal or a fair deal.”
For his part, Koch said the existing golf course deal gets regularly reviewed, and Quarry Hills Associates has shared some studies with Keenan.
“I love the senator, but I think he keeps moving the goalposts,” Koch said. (Keenan also happens to be Koch’s brother-in-law, and the two served in Quincy Mayor Jim Sheets’ administration during the golf course’s development.)
A similar proposal extending the lease also exists as a home-rule petition, a municipal bill that was approved by Quincy City Council in 2024, as well as House lawmakers in 2025. It remains in a Senate committee.
But after the council’s approval, voters swept out Koch-friendly councilors who backed the deal and elected new councilors who have taken a more combative stance on the mayor and the golf course situation.
Earlier this month, councilors voted to support Keenan’s push for an audit, and they passed a resolution declaring their opposition to the state budget amendment on the golf course.
Councilors also pointed to Falmouth as a comparison. The Cape Cod town recently switched operators of its 27-hole country club, after it held a competitive bidding process for the lease. One Quincy councilor said the 10-year deal will bring in more revenue for the town than Quincy sees, because Falmouth gets money from golf cart rentals and taxes on the land.
The club house overlooking Boston at Granite Links golf course in Quincy, Mass. (Robin Lubbock/WBUR)
Thomas O’Connell, president of Quarry Hills, declined to comment and instead pointed to a letter to the editor that ran this week in the Quincy Sun, a local newspaper.
Quarry Hills argued they need the deal to build a hotel and additional parking, which would increase the revenue the golf course sends to the city.
“Without additional investment, revenues are expected to plateau as facilities age and physical constraints—such as limited parking—remain unresolved,” O’Connell wrote. “Another operator might be content to continue operations as they are and ride out the remaining lease term. As the developers responsible for the vision and execution of Quarry Hills, we see an opportunity to do more.”
To help them, Quarry Hills has hired a top lobbyist: former state Rep. Brian Dempsey, who chaired the powerful House Ways and Means Committee. Meanwhile, several people who stand to benefit from the deal opened their checkbooks with donations to Beacon Hill leaders. The general manager at Granite Links, Walter Hannon, donated to Senate President Karen Spilka’s campaign for the first time this year. At least three others who work for a business with ties to Granite Links also gave Spilka’s campaign the maximum amount for a single year ($1,000), all on the same day in May
To Keenan, the hiring of a lobbyist and the maneuver to get the lease extension into a budget bill tells him Quarry Hills Associates “badly” wants the deal. The House and Senate have each passed their own versions of the closeout budget bill. (The Senate bill did not include the golf course lease extension amendment.) Negotiators have started work on a compromise that they hope to send to Gov. Maura Healey in the coming weeks.
But Keenan, who remembers as a young Quincy City Hall aide standing on the site as the first trucks hauling Big Dig dirt came off the expressway, remains firm that city officials “should do more work on this,” especially an audit.
“It’s a great facility,” Keenan said. “But, you know, this [proposed deal] goes out longer than the life expectancy of somebody born today.”