Denny Hamlin and Justin Allgaier, two of the most talented drivers in recent NASCAR history, have been in the news recently for dealing with a question that has vexed motorsports stars for many years: When do I retire?

Hamlin and Allgaier have crossed into the territory that brings the question to light. Hamlin is 46, Allgaier is 40. Generally, athletes in most other sports are well into their retirement years at such ages, but, for any number of reasons, racers typically stay at their jobs longer.

This is both good and bad. Bobby Allison won a Cup championship at 45. Dale Earnhardt won one at 43. Harry Gant won a race at 52. But even superstars like Richard Petty and Darrell Waltrip drove too long, ending their careers by stacking year after year of winless seasons.

The decision about closing the garage door for good is a complicated one. The big money is tempting. Even without winning, “name” drivers can collect piles of cash, and losing that income stream can be difficult to imagine. Also, driving a race car is pure fun, an addiction that is hard to cast aside. This idea played a significant role in Petty’s long driving career; he simply loved to be in the seat of a fast race car.

NASCAR Cup Series Cook Out 400 – QualifyingJonathan Bachman//Getty Images

Denny Hamlin.

This brings us to the cases of Hamlin and Allgaier, two of the sport’s prominent names—and most successful competitors—in recent years. Over the past four Cup seasons, Hamlin has scored 16 wins. Allgaier, a mainstay of the O’Reilly Auto Parts Series, has won 15 races and two championships in the past four years.

Often, both are among the smartest people in the room. Good on television and, particularly in Hamlin’s case, ready with a sharp verbal jab to the kidneys.

At the start of the 2026 season, it appeared that Hamlin and Allgaier had dealt with all of the issues surrounding retirement and had made their decisions. Hamlin planned to drive through the 2027 season for Joe Gibbs Racing, and Allgaier had determined that 2026 would close the curtain on his career.

Not so fast, fast guys.

Allgaier, enjoying one of the best years of his time in NASCAR’s No. 2 series, took a renewed look at the rest of his life in the spring and decided to sign a new contract with JR Motorsports, his forever home, meaning he’ll return in 2027 in what was described as a multiyear deal. “At the beginning of the year, I knew that it was the year I was going to retire,” Allgaier said at the time. “But I wasn’t quite ready yet.”

NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series MillerTech Battery 250 presented by KOA - QualifyingJames Gilbert//Getty Images

Justin Allgaier.

Times were good. Too good.

And this week Hamlin put a new spin on his future, stepping tentatively into the unknown by saying 2027 “most likely” will be his final year but leaving the door slightly ajar for more racing.

The story around Hamlin will continue to be his eternal pursuit of a Cup championship, a quest that ended in failure again this year as he finished third in the final standings after a disappointing run through the Chase weeks.

In a social-media world in which new drivers seemingly can become stars overnight, either with wins or shenanigans, Allgaier and Hamlin have earned their stripes through years of hard work and hard driving. They get older, but they win, a tribute not only to them but also to the top-of-the-line teams they represent.

The fact that Allgaier will—and Hamlin might—compete beyond 2027 is good news. Let them race on.

Lettermark

Mike Hembree has covered auto racing for numerous media outlets, including USA Today, NASCAR Scene, NBC Sports, The Greenville News and the SPEED Channel. He has been roaming garage areas and pit roads for decades (although the persistent rumor that he covered the first Indianapolis 500 is not true). Winner of numerous motorsports and other media awards, he also has covered virtually every other major sport. He lives near Gaffney, South Carolina and can be convinced to attend Bruce Springsteen concerts if you have tickets.