Larkin won by a landslide, lidstrom barely won, followed by Howe, then Yzerman

26 comments

  1. I think it just means you can’t include 4th liners since those players are usually less talented than those on the top 3 lines

  8. Ain’t no way y’all let my boy Abby and ras be that….I’m mad at y’all 😡😡😡💔

    ….put my boy jimmy in the right spot tho 🐙

  11. Hard to pick from, lots of options over the years

    Worst all time, including defense: Riley Sheahan, Robert Lang, Stephen Weiss, David Legwand, Eric Cole, Wendel Clark, Uwe Krupp, Derian Hatcher

    Worst currently, including defense – Andrew Copp, Jeff Petry

  16. Christopher Ehn played second line for half of the 2019-20 season which was absolutely abysmal

  18. Current weak link is Copper. Poor bastard just can’t find his hands. Reminds me of Draper when his career was coming to an end. Ol’ stone hands Draper.

    Past worst player should be from the recent drought. 2016-17 to current day. That being said, I’m going with 2018 first rounder, Filip Zadina. That dude was booed more than any other Red Wing that I can remember from poor play alone.

  20. Currently: Copp

    All Time: Nielson. If we’re counting injuries I think it’s Weiss but it feels like cheating. Excluding injury prone players makes the conversation a whole lot more interesting

  22. Current: Copp.
    All time… How about Jurco? 39 points in 114 games, 2nd round pick that never amounted to anything except some locker room stick trick videos

  26. Current worst: Petry (was between him and Holl.. who did not play much. & who I don’t consider on a “top 3 line”)

    All time: Jonathon Ericsson. Drove me crazy with his giveaways/defensive mistakes, like Petry was last year. I wanted to like Jon.. He was big and handsome.

    But I wish he stayed as a forward. Kindl and him switched to defense. He didn’t use his size enough too, on top of defensive mistakes.

    (Sean Avery and Weiss are 2nd).

Leave a Reply