The training camp wide receivers tried, but no one was going to take down the lego expert, the one they call Specs, Hot Rod himself…..Rodrigo Blankenship, as the player most loved by fans but sucked complete ass!! But the game moves on!!! Who was a great player that fans were so divided on??

20 comments

1. JT

2. Andrew Luck

3. Eric Dickerson fits very well here.

4. Bob Sanders?

5. Ricky Jean-Francois

6. Shaq Leonard

7. If we are divided, then we’ll not have a consensus that he is a great player…

   That being said, I think Eric Ebron

8. Probably JT

9. I think it’s Luck. When he played it was pretty universal love, but a lot of people don’t like the mention of his name any more – because of what he did to the franchise.

   He has all the tools to be better than Manning. But fans are now clearly divided on whether or not he’s loved or hated.

10. Edge James. Never showed up when needed most

11. Marshall Faulk

12. Pat McAfee

13. Whoever the answer is should depend on sorting by controversial.

14. I feel like I have to go with Luck here as odd as it seems. There’s definitely still some division because of the way he left and the thoughts of what might have been, and I think that makes some fans look at him in a negative light.

15. Anthony Richardson.

    Half this sub thinks he is Himothoy the other half thinks he’s a bum

16. Kenny Moore

17. I feel like the JT hatred by some fans will be a blip on the radar, but Luck’s is longer lasting. So, Luck is my clear choice for this square.

18. Just seeing Rod on here pisses me off. I have vitriol towards anyone who liked that guy.

    Anyway, this one has to be Luck. The fan base has turned on him more and more as time goes on imo.

19. The correct answer here is Pat McAfee, and you can’t convince me otherwise.

20. Great player Fans Divided – how many games did Mike Vanderjagt win for the Colts and how many BS comments came out of his mouth?