You Ask, We Answer: What to make of the Bills season now, Who to re-sign and who to let walk

47 comments

1. "So close" is this franchises identity…always will be….

2. 2:50 It's honestly just weird how scared people are to give Josh Allen any blame because they know they'll receive backlash. Last year, Billls fans were saying that it wouldn't have mattered if Bass made the FG against KC in the playoffs because Mahomes would've for sure gotten at least a field afterwards with seconds left to win it. The same can't be said for Allen… But fans do everything they can to try to blame anyone other than him for that.

3. and sorry, I know all 3 of you love MCDermott but he's reached his ceiling. FACE IT. How many more years does he kept screwing up the same ways every year? When will the majority of his loyal ignorant supporters see that he can't get a Lombardi to BFLO. He's going to waste JA's career. MCDipstick chokes and gets outcoached every critical game. Prob is,, who we gonna' get?" We're stuck with him and I think he'd never get traded/fired anyway. And I hate that soft Z we play.,,,and leave 10 feet distanc eon their covering a wr. Our Pass rush was not up to snuf all year esp. Again : Major Prob; COACHING" I'm 66 years old. and still waiting. Iain't' broken hearted as I was 99 percent sure they' lose anyway. After67 years and seeing the 4 SB loses I dont expect anyhtng frm them anymore. JA is this entire team. We'd be a .500 team (or less) without JA17. And if/when he gets injured bad then what? I'm blaming the coaches. Especially McClappy. Sorry.

4. I am 6 minutes into the video and you two have made no mention of the purposely unfair calls made by the refs.
   I am guessing you lose access to the team if you criticize the game fixing aspect of the league.

   That means that you all ain’t real journalists, just entertainers. 😂

5. 100% agree with AndrewWelford. While I can admit I was in the dumps immediately following the game on Sunday, I view this Bills rebuilding season as an overwhelming success.

   The Bills pushed the Champs to the final play to get to the biggest game of the year on a roster with dozens of millions in dead cap, who doesn't have a receiver who can get open and has big gaps in the secondary, and has no APs and 1 PB outside of Josh Allen.

   Come on. Calling this season a failure is looking for reasons to be miserable.

6. Jenna, you mean the Supreme trust that the refs will bail them out when they're behind in a game. Love you guys! I was born a Bills fan, and I'll die a Bills fan!! I've lived through the 90s heartbreaks, and we'll live to fight another day!💙❤️😉🙏🫶🫂🕊🦋🌈🦬🏈

7. We missed it on kincaid and colman. Put on the practice squad like you did Elam. But do not keep them as long as Elam. Elam great guy. But he is no NFL player

8. And yes definitely bring Mack back, seeing the pictures of how he showed up to arrowhead softened the blow this loss gave.

9. Are the scouts letting us down? Do we have poor talent evaluators? Is Beane getting bad info or is he the problem? I think we went as far as we could, and frankly, I was surprised we got by the Ravens. We have average talent, especially on the D side of the ball.

10. I couldn't find a clip of Kincaid, so not sure how he said it. But just based on what you guys said, I agree with Mike. He should have made the statement more forcefully, but I think he took responsibility.

    Also to note, Kincaid was on pace to set an NFL rookie record for most TE catches, and was at the top of the league leaders in catch rate last year. We know he has it in him. Something was off this year. Injury makes more sense than he just decided to suck. I expect bigger things from Kincaid next season.

11. Bring back Ty and Mack.

12. We need a complete D-line revamp. I’m done getting excited for Ed, Greg, Vonn and co having a good 3 game stretch for us to get excited about going into the playoffs only to unbelievable letdowns. None of the cut it as reliable starters when it counts…. Against the one of leagues worst O-line too. Disgusting.

13. Last year they were terrible in the playoffs. They're very close to the big game. Need a couple good draft picks and better veteran signings. Aka Curtis worthless Samuel, von the waste of space Miller. Damar Hamlin is trash, rapp is trash, the rest can stay 😁

14. Seriously damar Hamlin is so bad, doesn't everyone else see it?

15. You all had your Superbowl in November when you beat the Chiefs back then. On Feb 9th, you can block out the real Superbowl and locally show the replay video of that game and still have SB parties…!!

16. Beane definitely deserves his fair share of blame for this teams' failures through his bad drafting.

17. KC is waaay ahead of all the NFL teams in terms of the draft, organization, coaching staff, culture,..they just don't acquire good players, they acquire the RIGHT players to fit their schemes. Picking up Kareem Hunt in the middle of the year and giving him a second lease on life was brilliant just to give an example.

18. If Lamar hadn't fumbled the Ravens would've beaten the Bills AGAIN and knocked you guys out of the playoffs. The Buffalo Bills are OVERATTED!!!

19. Im a lifelong Redskins fan that has always rooted for your Bills.
    That said, the defense needs a sledge hammer on the line, specifically, edge, to set the edge and collapse the pocket and have the agility to flip their hips on a dime and not lose contain. … imagine what a miles garret or even max crosby could provide.
    Secondary could use a sideline to sideline literal headhunter ballhawk at free safety.
    Draft the fastest , good hands wr you can . Too bad that trade was made with kc. I was like wtf , worthy to kc????? Tyrek light
    Hang in there. Love ya Bills Mafia

20. Agree with Jenna 100%, there is no way on this planet that you “accommodate” Kansas City. Beane accommodated them with their Worthy pick. He displayed clueless management. Absolutely a pathetic decision by Beane.

21. Beyond poor judgment by Beane. You do not do business with Kansas City. And does anyone have any idea what the Bills scouting Department saw in Elam. They got jumped by KC when they picked McDuffie and just selected the 2nd best CB on the board who was Elam. Question whether they even looked at his tape. He is a disaster and w/o question cannot be on this roster next season.

22. Agree with Jenna again. Kinkaid and others need to help Josh out. Allen constantly carries this team. His teammates have to step up in key moments of the game. All too often they don’t. What more can Allen do. Look yourselves in the mirror and for God sake help him out. He carries all of you.

23. Dalton Kincaid had one of the best rookie TE seasons ever but apparently that's still no good.

    Also, the Chiefs have stunk at assessing WRs for awhile. Mecole Hardman, Kadarius Toney, Skyy Moore and Xavier Worthy is probably not much more than faster Isaiah McKenzie. I don't really care that the Chiefs got him. They made an effort to scheme plays for him against the Bills but over the season he was pretty mediocre. They didn't even crack 30 points until this game.

24. Chiefs fans aren’t smug, trying to act like Allen is equal if not better than Mahomes is what is smug and is what y’all do every year. How many times do we need to beat you in the playoffs to get bills media to respect #15 and admit your guy isn’t him?

25. They got away from cook. James was cooking as he always is. Should of kept getting the ball to jimbo..!!

26. Honestly, been a Bills fan for over 30 years and this is so similar to the 90s. This is who Buffalo, and unless they change their mindset they are not making the SB. In my opinion, as much as everyone likes to call out the refs, specific plays, coaching, etc, the most glaring issue is the mindset and psychology of the entire Buffalo Team, including the coaches. The Chiefs are completely in their head, and they have to figure out a way to overcome that problem. I don’t care who they pick up in the draft, if their mindset is off they are going to lose. The Chiefs have a dominant alpha winning mindset and the Bills don’t. If Mahomes had 3+ minutes and needed to walk down the field to get the winning touchdown I think we all know he would make it happen. Buffalo is not that team at the moment, nor have they been ever. The only game I ever recall where they overcame adversity in an AFC Championship game was when they came back and beat the Oilers in the 90s, but then they were decimated in the SB.

    Lastly, it’s great when guys are accountable, but after hearing the same things year after year and nothing changes, it loses its impact. That said, the Bills
    Definitely exceeded expectations from the beginning of the year, and the incredibly positive part about that is Buffalo showed the world you don’t need All Pro players at every level to be great. If they could just change their mindset when playing the Chiefs they would get over that mountain. However that’s easier said than done. I wonder how much of the Bills preparation in training is focused on the psychological aspects of having a winning mindset vs just the physical attributes and playbook.

27. HC has bad energy

28. So close!!!!????? That is not true!!!! This was the second worse loss in the 4 games against KC. Our squad was worse our coaching staff was worse….. and of course a worse team that is on the bad side of ref calls has even worse chance to win!!!

29. How many more years will we excuse the Front Office and the Head coach to fail in the playoffs!!!! We always get to this stage with squads that are lacking in skill set and depth!!! Look at the number of pro bowlers and potential hall of fame players on each side!!! That shows we have not drafted well or we are not using or developing our players well enough!!!!

30. You say the Bills didn’t play as good. You’re playing a great team. A great defense with an all time DC. In the AFC Championship game. I don’t expect the team to play perfect I expect miss haps

31. Does the Front Office/Beane make decisions on its own without the input of the head coach!!!???? I have been frustrated the last few years with the lack of early rounders impact players like we have seen across the league. When have the Bills have had a Rookie of the year player in their roster???? Then we excuse the early rounders for being too young and expect the late rounders to be productive!!!!

32. I honestly think Keon Colemam was having a good rookie season and making big plays until the injury. After that he was a total non factor. Kincaid and Elam were both wasted draft picks. They didn't get the guys they wanted and panicked and just drafted them. 1st round draft picks are supposed to be high impact players that change your team. Elam didn't even dress half the season and Kincaid is just a guy.

33. Offense gets you to playoffs DEFENSE win CHAMPIONSHIPS What needs is defensive coordinator bills defensive unprepared 4 queefs ps eagles 🦅 win soup bowl 🥣. we need one larger linebacker 1 and strong safty . Personally I WANT BING CROSBY

34. They did not use Cook nearly enough. He should have had twice the number of carries he had.

35. Fire Beane. He’s got too many misses.

36. Brady was terrible the last two games where was the passing game why was Cook on the sideline most of the game when he was ripping off 9,10 yards a cracked we have no defense

37. Not hurt numb same old same old 59 years only 2 actual titles 1964 and 1965 AFL championships the only ones that count

38. Should have let Kincaid go to the cowboys he could suck down there with the rest of there stars

39. They probably would have been blown out in the superbowl Philly is a much better team

40. Edge rushers we have none

41. Hamlin the mascot

42. Ty Johnson has to come back

43. .. The reason the Bills has not won the SB yet because its not only having a great team, you need to be lucky, healthy, refs, one play , one bounce, .. 32 teams that want to win a SB.

44. Betting on games are the reason teams win or lose bad ball placement when there are 1st downs bad officiating come on Miller's right its all scripted

45. I don't think it is beane he can only go off of the information his scout team tells him on players.

46. I wish i could have caught that is not taking accountability .. No, you should have caught it

47. no question Beane is overrated. The Worthy trade we all new would haunt this team and he still did it, plus he is horrible at drafting