You Ask, We Answer: Cook’s contract, odd man out on the Bills & perception of Kincaid

Your home for coverage of the Buffalo Bills.

Mike Catalana, Dan Fetes and Jenna Cottrell talk James Cook’s next contract, the Bills DLine and the perception of Dalton Kincaid.

For links to all our coverage and the Buffalo Plus Store: https://www.flowcode.com/page/buffaloplus

Don’t forget, you can also catch all our episodes on your
favorite podcast platforms like Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and
more: https://www.flowcode.com/page/buffaloplus

For more behind-the-scenes content and on the field coverage on game day from Orchard Park, follow us at:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/buffaloplusdotcom
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/buffaloplus_/?hl=en
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@buffaloplus_
X (Twitter): https://twitter.com/BuffaloPlus

Mike’s X: https://twitter.com/MikeCatalana
Dan’s X: https://twitter.com/danfetes
Dan’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/danfetes/
Jenna’s X: https://twitter.com/JennaCottrell
Jenna’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jennacottrell/?hl=en

Buffalo Plus MERCH: BuffaloPlusStore.com

Website: https://13wham.com/buffalo-plus

Please like, comment and subscribe!

29 comments

  3. How is Elijah Moore and his 61 catches not being mentioned, especially for a horrible offense and multiple bad QBs throughout the season he has 4.35 speed and can actually create separation outside the numbers vertically.

  7. 1. Already stated… Cook needs to learn from big bro mistake. 2. Henry and Barkley play at 230, Cook is at 190. He wants to play 3 downs… he needs to bulk up. Even Ray Davis is at 220.

  8. 1 deep safety on D, send Moore / Palmer and Coleman / Samuel deep – make the safety chose which side he covers. If 2 deep safeties, Shakir, Kincaid and Knox all day underneath / middle…..
    Very, very simple – but the idea to build around…..

  10. Because of how he did it, the Bills can not give Cook 15 million per year. Other players are signing extensions at less than projected. What tone / mindset does it set for other players going forward if the Bills give Cook what he publicly demands?

  12. The PGA Championship was last week but your channel didn't cover it. I'm grateful Thad covered it and now you lost a viewer. Always plug your YouTube channel but don't bother with the rest of the details. Thad even wears a tie DAN! B league coverage!

  14. if you can resign Dawson for absolutely no reason and you can give Greg Rousseau 80 million dollars to be the 28th best pass rusher in the league you can give cook 12 million. It's a dumb debate that this guy is where we draw the line, he has actual production worthy of a contract extension 16 touchdowns, a thousand yard season and taking running snaps from Josh which will extend his career. IDC what position he plays find a way to pay him.

  17. '25 is looking better than '24 on paper. Besides the schedule, a lot to look forward to on defense. Samuel was looking nice at the end of last year. He went from total bust to wow and hopefully he's healthy and that carries over. Cook situation is dicey. He has really improved, but he is also not a 3 down back and works well by committee, almost like a specialist. Agreed though that he is probably gone. I was a little surprised they didn't draft someone knowing they are not re-signing him. I'm with Dan, Kincaid makes that play, it's a statue. That was going to be legendary.

  18. The stench on Dalton Kincaids production in 2024 is the odor of MVP17.

    61% of targets to Kincaid were catchable passes…
    Only 37% of targets over 10 yards to Kincaid were catchable passes.

    Allen was the least accurate quarterback in the NFL in 2024 when targeting TE’s with at least 40 targets.

  19. Here’s a question: Is Dalton Kinkaid a potential great trade candidate? Someone mentioned earlier that he doesn’t seem to fit the offense. They want another bigger TE with reliable hands and it seems they may have found one in Jackson Hawes.

  22. Jenna is correct on Cook. Mike and Dan are wrong. His contributions to the Bills offense are absolutely needed. Both are talking like he’s easily replaceable. I’d pay him $10m to $12m a season for three years and get the offense together right now. Cook is needed, don’t agree with those thinking otherwise.

  24. According to Joe Marino at Locked on Bills Dalton Kincaid had one of the highest rates of uncatchable balls thrown to him in the whole league. Whether you want to admit it or not, as good as Josh Allen is, he has to be better for Dalton Kincaid. Kincaid can separate and has good hands, but he can't catch balls that are uncatchable.

  26. Cook was not on the field when the game was on the line with the chiefs. That is all you need to know how the Bills view him. Also, I think Jenna is being stressed in her personal life as she is being more negative than Dan lately.

Leave a Reply