Pittsburgh Pirates Deadline a BIG Swing and Miss
We know the moves the pirates made and those they didn’t. I’m not promising to make sense of what they did, but I sure have takes. And that’s next on Locked on Pirates. You are Locked On Pirates. Your daily Pittsburgh Pirates podcast, part of the Locked On podcast network. Your team every day. This episode is brought to you by 5Hour Energy Transfusion. Go to fiveour energy.com today and use my promo code locked ongolf to receive 20% off your order. Only valid through September 30th. Order transfusion flavored 5-hour energy shots today. Welcome to Locked On Pirates. I’m Gary Morgan. This was largely just gross. I mean, you could spend time assigning blame if you want to, but I think we all know who the the targets at this point. So, I’m just here to go through the deals and use that term lightly. I want to mix in some of Ben Sharington’s post deadline press availability and talk it through with you. I’ve done special shows on Hayes and Bednar, so some of what I say here might be redundant, but seeing the totality of what was done gives me perspective that I didn’t have when either of those deals were made. Not that it helped much, but it could at least give me a little bit more um, okay, what if they do this? Well, now we know what they did and didn’t do. So, let’s go through them, if only, because we really should. all in one place here. We haven’t done that here on this show yet. David Bedar to the Yankees. Pirates receive uh catcher first baseman Raphael Flores, their number eight prospect. Uh Ed Glean Perez, Yankees number 14 prospect. And center fielder, or I guess really just outfielder, Brian Sanchez, unranked prospect. Bedar had a 237 RA and 17 saves this season. He’s been really good after coming back from Triple A especially. Thoughts on this? First, I’m seeing some reports out there that Ben Cherington had a better package on the table and ultimately decided to circle back to this one because he liked the package better. There was a higher prospect available somewhere else. I’m not sure where. I’m not even sure if it’s true. It’s being reported. But, you know, these things that are sourced by one person here and there, I’m not 100% sure how accurate they are. You know what I mean? It could be one guy that didn’t get his way in that room and just feels like talking. You hear what I’m saying? So, I’m not really sure where to go with that, but it is being reported and it and if so, it’s makes it even more frustrating. I told you what I thought about this deal in long form, but just in short form, in case you think something’s changed in a day or two for me, not so much. I still don’t like it. I still don’t think it helps. I think even if it helps in 2026, it’s going to be marginally because this kid’s not going to get here till 2026. And we know how most prospects end up coming here. And I don’t just mean here, I mean most teams. Most prospects don’t come up and flourish from moment one. And this is a guy that I think creates some problems for you. This is a a catcher and first baseman. You’ve got Spencer Horwit, so I think you want to give a little bit of room to. And you got Henry Davis, which okay, if you’re going to call it quits on Henry Davis, I get it. This kid’s got a better bat profile, but I don’t think he’s anywhere near the defensive profile of Henry Davis. In fact, I have a I have doubts that he’s going to stick a catcher. And if he doesn’t stick a catcher, I got to be honest with you, I think it’s the DH at best. The other two, they’re not going to touch this team anytime soon. Let’s move on because we have time to worry about Bailey Falter to the Royals. This one blew my mind, and I haven’t talked to you about this yet. This blew my mind. They received left-handed pitcher Evan Cisk. He’s like a 29year-old reliever. They’re sending him to Triple A. I would imagine he’ll be up this year. I’d imagine they see him being part of this bullpen for a few years as a left-hander. Okay. I don’t mind getting him back. Kalin Moss seems like an interesting prospect, but he’s pretty far down there again. Lower levels. Just drafted in 2023 or 2024. I mean, it’s it is what it is. That said, man, you didn’t have to trade Bailey Falter. He had three more years of control. I’m not saying he had to make your rotation, but it started coming up that this team didn’t want to pay his arbitration next year. Guys, I gotta tell you, I don’t know as a podcaster, as someone covering this team, as a fan, I don’t know how you can evaluate anything for this team moving forward if three or four million in ARB one for a pitcher that has given you what Bailey Falter has given you was going to be something that prices you out. If that’s something you can’t handle as an organization, even if you think he’s going to be replaced in the rotation by younger, better options, that’s a price you got to be willing to pay. That’s nothing. That’s nothing for a proven starting pitcher. And speaking of nothing, the return on that for three years of control for a lefthanded pitcher. I just have to repeat that because here’s what’s going to happen now. And and I’m getting ahead of myself a little bit because I’m just fired up about this one in particular. Next year, they’ll be looking for a left-handed pitcher to be in that rotation. I wouldn’t be shocked if they went out and signed another Andrew Heene type. And that Andrew Heeney type, he won’t be as good as Bailey Falter. It makes absolutely no sense. They’ll end up paying five, six, $7 million for a guy that won’t give you what Bailey would have for three. It makes no sense. None. It certainly doesn’t help you in 2026 unless Evan Cisk turns into an incredible reliever that throws about 55 innings and just is the quintessential lefty out of the bullpen that does everything. If he turns out to be as good as Caleb Ferguson was this year, okay, and even then I would suspect you probably could have gotten him for Andrew Heane. And I’m not lying. This didn’t make any freaking sense. Period. Caleb Ferguson to the Mariners. Pirates receive. Jeter Martinez, a 19-year-old prospect from Single. A. I actually don’t hate this one. This was a rental. You should get a rental return. That’s what they got. I’m okay with that. I would have been okay with them doing it a few more times with some players. They decided not to move. You got Cabrian Hayes to the Reds. Boy, we talked this one to death already. But Sammy Stfura, great prospect. I really do like him. He’s the Pirates number seven. Now, Taylor Rogers, they already went ahead and flipped on to the Chicago Cubs for another low-level nobody that we won’t hear or see for a long time. Hayes wasn’t good and they’re making room by getting rid of him. I have no problem with that. I’ve suggested it on this show, especially if you could get out of that contract or whatever, but I just feel like this return didn’t make a lot of sense. I I didn’t understand exactly what they were. It It was a dump. Salary dump. And a salary dump is fine as long as you actually refill it. That’s the part that we don’t trust them on. Adam Frasier obviously couple weeks ago, it still counts as deadline deal. Cam Deanny. Who the hell knew Cam Deany was going to be the most realistic addition to the 2026 roster that they would receive in this entire trade deadline. Cherington didn’t comment on every individual trade, but his general remarks kind of help distill at least whatever he’s calling logic for these things. Okay. So on urgency and readiness, he said, “We have to deliver better for our fans. Our intent is to be prepared to strike if we see something that helps us towards being better in 2026.” Okay, so either they didn’t see anything that helped them get better in 2026 or they just didn’t pursue it. I I’m sorry. not nothing they did here really definitively helps them in 2026. We sent out five major league baseball players and you can talk about their individual warts and everything else. We spent sent out five major league baseball players and brought back none. I don’t see any way that you can spend that where this deadline improved 2026 on acquiring players with long-term control. He says whether it’s this week or the off season, we may acquire players that jump right onto the roster or might soon jump on or trade for players further along. That’s not a changing course. Of course, it’s not a changing course, Ben. just you just literally named all the different ways you could acquire players and all the different levels of where the hell they are in their development. Of course, it didn’t change because you’ve basically said we could do anything on the type of players targeted. We’re going to be acquiring players who are not fully proven yet, who we believe can contribute but aren’t fully proven yet. Gee, how inspiring for 2026 that will be the proving ground for them on payroll movement. He says it’s pretty easy because it’s not about moving payroll. The exercise is to get better. Where where did you get better, Ben? I don’t know how you say that. I don’t know how you say that in a press conference. You didn’t get better. You didn’t get better. Let’s talk in the next segment specifically via his quotes how this deadline set up 2026. Time to fuel up and turn it up with 5hour energy transfusion. It brings the bold grape, ginger, and lime flavor of your favorite golf drink, minus the alcohol, into a quick, energizing shot. Whether you’re sinking birdies or making memories with friends, this one’s a holeinone for your energy game. Let’s be honest, some days on the course or off it, you just need the extra boost to stay sharp and energized. I was on this hole the other day. It was an island shot and all four of my buddies were like, “We’re going to make this shot.” Not a single one of us made it. I wish we had had one of these fivehour energies. Maybe it would have given us the boost we needed. Golf is all about good times with good people and good flavors. Of course, the grape ginger lime flavor gives you the best parts of your clubhouse goto without chasing down the bevart. If you go to fiveourenergy.com today, that’s the number five hourgy.com, you can use my promo code locked on golf to receive 20% off your order. This offer is only valid until September 30th on one order and cannot be used with other promotions. This code is not good on subscription orders. Whether you’re meeting up with friends or trying to turn 18 holes into 36, get the energizing boost you need to power through. Order transfusion flavored 5hour energy shots today. Hey, welcome back to Locked on Pirates. First of all, I want to just acknowledge all of you. I appreciate you sticking with me and again finding all the different shows that I’ve offered you this week and just in general being here and in a good spirit, a relatively good spirit. In other words, thanks for not taking it out on me. I’m just trying to tell you what’s going on. I’m not trying to I’m not trying to uh run cover for this team and what they do and why they do it. Okay? Not what it’s about. So, how does this really set up 2026, this deadline specifically? I knew Ben Cherington would get asked the question, and he got asked it multiple times, and he evaded it in multiple different ways. He repeatedly emphasized that the goal was 2026, competitiveness, not short-term fixes. Here’s one of his quotes. Our focus is shortterm, not necessarily August 2025, but how do we get this thing on track and win more games in 2026? Fine question. The question I think we all thought you were going into this deadline looking to address. I think we thought there’d be a lot more pickups along the lines of like Cam Deany guys who could step right in. We thought you’d start to clear out guys like Tommy Fam and Andrew Heeney and IKF and start making room for the prospects that we do have to come up here and try, including some of the guys that you picked up in the process of the deadline. To me, that was the goal. To me, that’s what we were trying to do. That’s what we should have been trying to do. If you want to win more games in 2026, then it stands to reason that you have to improve on the roster. That means you can’t stick with the roster. It means you have to understand that the roster didn’t work. I think we can all accept that. I think we can all accept that change needed to happen. But none of these moves, none of these moves touch 2026. not on their own. What we’re being asked to do here to me is unfair. Okay? We’re staring at a at a general manager who at the very least is on the hot seat. Okay? That’s the lowest level of hell I can give. He’s on the hot seat, right? And you make a bunch of deals at the deadline. None of them affect the 2026 team tangibly except for to subtract talent from it. You know, you have taken away talent and now I’m supposed to just sit here and wait for you to come back with act two. I’m He kept referencing like, “Wait till November. That’s when we’re going to continue this job.” And okay, well, if you’re going to continue this job in November, are you telling me I got to sit here and just trust that the dumping you did at this deadline sets you up for November? In what way? I don’t understand that. Third segment, I’m going to specifically talk about money. I think that’s important to to note exactly what they saved and we’ll talk about how they could use it, but just what he did actively. I didn’t see it. Here’s another quote. To win more games in 2026, we’ve got to score more runs. Einstein stuff here, right? Our pitching and defense have mostly kept us in games, but we’re not scoring enough. Okay, fair, valid, true. God, we’ve all said it. It’s something that we’ve all said repeatedly. This was an offense problem. Get some offense in here. Some way somehow. Trade some pitching for offense. Seems logical. Maybe it is a better thing to try to do in the off season. I didn’t even hear him say those words. That would have been more comforting than than some of what he said. But this quote in particular, to win more games in 2026, we’ve got to score more runs. Our pitching and defense have mostly kept us in games, but we’re not scoring enough. So, we traded one of our starters who we had control of for three more years, cheap, our two-time all-star closer, and our allworld defensive third baseman. No matter what you think of Kabrian Hayes, Ben Sharington just called out, “Our pitching and defense has mostly kept us in games, and you traded away three very big pieces of that pitching and defense.” And I’d been fine with it if you had brought back some of that offense that we were just talking about needing. We’re not scoring enough. Nothing they did at this deadline will add to that. Nothing. That’s what I can’t get past. That’s where I can’t move past. We want to be opportunistic. If there are things clearly of benefit to the pirates long term, that’s our job. that aligns with the types of players they acquired like Raphael Flores, Jeter Martinez, and Sammy Stafura. Long-term. Okay. I I don’t disagree. I don’t mind getting more prospects in here, especially some of them have a power profile. I really don’t mind that. They they they acquired some some of them are real far away. Some of them aren’t. Understood all that. Thought for Reynolds that’s what I should expect. But opportunistic at this deadline needed to be about pouncing on things that could help this team in 2026. Like, let me throw an idea out at you. Like, the Rangers were rumored to want to be cutting salary. They wanted to dump some salary and the Pirates need offense. The Rangers at the same time as wanting to cut salary would like to add bullpen help. So, I’m thinking to myself, all right, well, let’s see if they might want to be interested in David Bedar or something or Caleb Ferguson or somebody along those lines. If they want to cut salary, if they really want to cut salary, we can give them a a rental reliever. Hey, I could even give them a reliever with a little bit of term if they want. I can find something like that. I’ve got plenty of them. I got a guy they could take a shot at, Kyle Nicholas. He’s a 40man guy. He was great last year, not so much this year. You want to dump salary? Here’s how I plan to help you. Take Kyle Nicholas off my hands and give me a dollar Garcia. He’s only got one more year of arbitration. He’s really struggled this year, but he still has 15 home runs, and he would step right in here and be a starting outfielder and probably hit the same amount of home runs, which is an improvement over what I currently have. Is it the final answer? Is it the best answer? Does it get us to the World Series? No. But it would have tangibly helped 2026. It’s the type of thing I expected to see this team try to pull off. Get creative. Go help other teams dump the way they always come and help you. People stand here like it’s a freaking breadline, their hands out, just expecting us to dump them stuff. And we do every single time. I have to step away again, but when I come back, we’re getting into the money because this stuff adds up and I’ve got the totals. Today’s episode is brought to you by Game Day Hugh and so is this hat I’m wearing. For the Pirates fans like me who sometimes like to go out there and support my team colors, this one really hits the mark without the logo. Game Day Hugh makes clean no logo gear with team inspired colorways for every pro and college fan base. It’s all about letting your color speak for you. No giant logos, just smart, versatile style that works on game day, on course, or anywhere in between. I love rocking it on the course because honestly, sometimes when I’m out there, I don’t feel like answering pirates questions or hearing pirates comments, but I do want to rock the colors, so I like to do that. And it’s not just hats. Check out cool split shade gloves made for the golf course or the perfect gift for the fan who has everything. I mean, I don’t have everything, but I’ll take a couple of more of these gloves. They’re pretty sweet. Right now, you can get 15% off with code MLB15 at gamedayhw.com. That’s gamedayh.com. The code even stacks on bundle deals. So, now is the time to load up. Let your colors talk because colors speak louder than words. That’s gamedayhw.com code MLB15. Hey, welcome back to Locked on Pirates. Hey, cream rules everything around me. Get the money dollar bill, y’all. That’s exactly what we’re talking about. The money aspect of things. At the deadline, the Pirates cleared approximately $18 million from trading. Cabrian Hayes, Bailey Falter, David Bednar, and Caleb Ferguson. They saved another 16 million next year when Andrew Heene, Isaiah Connor, Falefa, and Tommy Fam all leave the books. And then 7.3 million more if you want to count Andrew McCutchen, Tim Mesa, and Ryan Bari. I think they’ll probably bring Andrew McCutchen back, but all that totals up to about $41.3 million. Cherington’s stance on payroll. Again, from his quotes, the exercise is not to move payroll. The exercise is to get better. We’re open-minded. $41.3 million. How do you think they’ll allocate that next year? Do you think it’s a guarantee that that $41.3 million goes right back into payroll? Their payroll before this trade deadline was sitting at about 92 million. There’s a really really good um local source for this named Ethan Hulahan. He keeps detailed track and I mean down to every call up and send down and waiver and everything they do. He details their their payroll to the minute. And you can always go and check exactly what that figure is. It was 92 million right before the trade deadline. I’m waiting for him to recalculate it, but these numbers are pretty much telling me what it’s going to be. Payroll is going to go down. and 41.3 million just to kind of get back to where they were is what we should start with in that magic month of November. Right? That’s the only way that this whole thing makes sense is if these deals were done with an eye toward we’re going to create this bulk of money that we have and we’re going to go out and spend it. If they do go out and spend that $41.3 million, I think you have a couple concerns there, right? One, you got to convince people to come to this team. And this team has not signed a free agent to a multi-year contract unless you want to count Harleen Garcia, who I don’t believe ever. I think he maybe pitched one game for us before he got hurt and ultimately got traded before that last um before that last year ever took effect for a player to be named later that I don’t believe ever got named. So, they haven’t done it. But I think like you’re talking about this kind of money. If you want a gamechanging player, like you really need some offense in here, right? You’re going to have to replace you’re going to probably have to go out there with the mindset of I’m going to try to sign somebody to more than one year. I’m going to have to take a swing at somebody. And you’re probably going to have to overpay to get them here. Like, don’t get me wrong, people want to play with like Paul Skins and whatnot, but if you’re a right-handed bat, okay, and you’re not on your last contract, like this isn’t like Tommy Fam where you’re just hoping there’s one more year in there or you’re going out and getting somebody that nobody else seems to want and you’re hoping for a rebound. That’s the type of guy that the Pirates tend to go with and Ben already primed us for it. Ben already told us, “Hey, we’re gonna get guys that aren’t ready, you know, and turn them into ready. So, it doesn’t sound to me like we’re going to go out on the open market and try to sign some big free like, do you think we’re going to go out and be a player for Eugeno Suarez? You know, do you think we’re gonna That’s how we’re we’re we traded to Brian Hayes so we can make room to go out and get a big free agent third baseman that’s going to come in here and hit in the middle of our order. It makes a ton of sense. You think they’re going to go out and get Kyle Schwarber? They could afford him 41.3 million. You can’t tell me they couldn’t go and offer Kyle Schwarber 22 million a year to come here and play or something like that. I’m not saying he would. I’m not saying the Phillies would let him go ultimately, but those are two free agents that are going to be on the board. Two big answers that could actually help improve this offense immediately in 2026. Maybe even to a differencemaking degree. Although Eugino Suarez, I think you should look at his history and see that these home runs don’t come every year. He’s having an extraordinary year this year, but he doesn’t always have that. and his defense is a little bit more questionable. But hey, that was a sacrifice I think you’re willing to make. You traded your defensive specialist for the opportunity to add offense at that position. Do you think that’s what they’re going to do with the money? I don’t I don’t I think we’re going to see Cam Deany up here. I thought it was funny in his press conference, the only guy he named as somebody that might get an opportunity out of this third base situation was Jared Triolo. And it seems to me like if you thought Cabrian Hayes being defensively incredible and essentially not good on offense, not good enough on offense to be in this lineup. Seems to me that you should probably have the same mindset for Jared Triolo and what he’s been able to do. Tremendous fielder. Again, I I have no problem with him coming up and being a third baseman if he can hit, but he hasn’t hit. And I don’t want to go into 2026 assuming he might. But it feels very much so like that’s what they’re setting up. If Ben Sherington stays, to me, the path forward very much so is going to be more of the same. It’s going to be trying to trust internal growth, trying to hope for rebounds from internal players, and signing one-year contracts of veterans to fill in holes around the diamond. And I don’t think that’s good enough. And I don’t think it was worth shedding this salary if that’s how you’re going to reallocate it. And furthermore, and this is probably the main point, I just don’t trust him to spend it the right way. And I don’t trust Bob Nutting to let him spend all of it. And I don’t trust them to reallocate dollars. And I don’t trust them to do smart moves with any of their current players in order to bring in talent and eat salary because they’ve never done it. There’s a lot of smart things that I think I can come up with for how to keep this ball moving forward. I can come up with a detailed plan and I’m sure I will. I’ve got five shows a week. I can come up with a detailed plan for how I would attack 2026. And I’m sure I will. And I’m sure some of you will buy into it. But even as it comes out of my mouth, I’m almost equally sure they won’t do it. I’m frustrated as a Pirates fan. I really am. I’m I’m frustrated because of all the things they could have done at this deadline, the one thing I didn’t think that we would see would be a a step back. I thought stand still might have been worse. That might have been the worst situation we could have is just stand still. This is worse than that. And again, I should reiterate, I don’t have a problem with any individual that they traded. I have a problem with the return and the focus of the returns. And when you’re trading controllable guys, guys, that you don’t have to move because you’ve got another year or whatever. I just don’t think that I can accept this was the best offer we got because in my mind that’s not enough. Like if I owe if I have a a a car I’m selling and I put a price tag on it for $5,000 and it’s out there for about three days and someone comes along and knocks on my door and says, “I’ll give you three for it.” I don’t think many people, including me, would go, “Well, yeah, sure. That’s fine. 3,000 sounds fair. That’s the only offer I got. I might as well take it.” I think what I would do instead is just go I think I’m just going to let that car soak out there a little bit longer and see if someone else comes along first. Maybe if I’m two months into trying to do it, I’m like, “Okay, hey, the market is telling me, but I saw the market for for closers.” yesterday and the day before. And David Bedar is better than some of them. Disappointed, underwhelmed. They don’t they don’t really do it justice. I’m disillusioned. This franchise is as confused as I’ve ever seen it from top to bottom. I don’t know who’s in charge. I don’t know who’s going to be in charge. I don’t know who’s getting fired. I don’t know who’s getting brought in. I don’t know if organizational changes are coming. I don’t know if ultimately they’re going to come back in that November when they’re planning on doing all these other things and start moving off pieces that I can finally mark safe from the deadline of 2025. But I can tell you right now, the frustration level that this season started with, it’s going to be amplified next year. You thought planes and billboards sucked last year. You thought Chance at the stadium blew this year. Wait till next year. And that’s if they’re lucky. That’s if people care enough to still do it. I got skin in this game, right? I do a show every week. Die Hards are plentiful. Don’t get me wrong. I’m still climbing. this team, they didn’t do anything to move the ball forward. Not at this deadline. Not at all. And it’s rich to expect us to just accept it and move on and wait for November to see their the rest of their brilliant plan. Why do I already know I’m going to be doing spring training shows next year where I’m telling you things they didn’t address that they should have addressed and money they left on the table? Don’t lose that $41.3 million number because we’re going to talk about it next year. And if the salary doesn’t at least hit exactly what it was this year, I’m going to first of all call And second, I’m going to I’m going to wonder why it wasn’t 20 more. Because really, the payroll should be slanting up. You should be moving into a place where you’re spending 110 120 now. So really that 41.3 that’s all cleared, that should be 61.3 at least. And you should be able to get whatever you want or need with that in order to move this ex excellent pitching staff into some kind of playoff situation. That should be more than enough to get you two quality bats if you have the balls to sign them. I need this weekend real bad, guys. I really do. And I think you all do, too. Playing Colorado, probably the perfect storm for them. See if they can go ahead and get uh three wins against Colorado. Last time they played a team they should have beat, they got swept. And the White Socks, we’ll see if they can make this one any better. That’s all I got for you this week. I think I’ve done seven shows this week. So like like on on the locked on network. So at 8 if you count MLB squad, make sure you check that out. That’s going to be on the feed, too. Thanks everybody. Good stuff. Let’s go Bucks. Yeah.
This was largely just gross. You can spend time assigning blame, but I think we all know the targets at this point, so I’m just here to go through the deals and I use that term lightly, mix in some of Ben Cherington’s post deadline press availability and talk it through, with you.
Follow & Subscribe on all Podcast platforms…
🎧 https://lockedonpodcasts.com/podcasts/locked-on-pirates/
Locked On MLB League-Wide: Every Team, Prospects & More
🎧 https://lockedonpodcasts.com/leagues/mlb/
Support Us By Supporting Our Sponsors!
5-Hour ENERGY
Time to fuel up and turn it up with 5-hour ENERGY®️ Transfusion! Go to https://5hourenergy.com today and use my promo code LOCKEDONGOLF to receive 20% off your order. This offer is only valid until September 30th on one order and cannot be used with other promotions. The code is not good on subscription orders.
Supply House
Join the TradeMaster program today at SupplyHouse.com/TM and start ordering plumbing, HVAC, and electrical supplies with just a few clicks. Plus, use promo code S-H-5 for 5% off your first order. That’s SupplyHouse.com!
OpenPhone
Streamline and scale your customer communications with OpenPhone. Get 20% off your first 6 months at www.openphone.com/lockedonmlb
Gameday Hue
Let your colors talk—because colors speak louder than words. Right now, you can get 15% off with code MLB15 at GamedayHue.com.
Monarch Money
Take control of your finances with Monarch Money. Use code LOCKEDONMLB at monarchmoney.com/lockedonmlb for 50% off your first year.
Gametime
Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code LOCKEDONMLB for $20 off your first purchase. Terms apply. Download Gametime today. What time is it? Gametime.
FanDuel
Right now, new customers can get ONE HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS in BONUS BETS when your first FIVE DOLLAR BET WINS! Download the app or head to FANDUEL.COM to get started. Bet with FanDuel—Official Partner of the NBA.
FANDUEL DISCLAIMER: 21+ in select states. First online real money wager only. Bonus issued as nonwithdrawable free bets that expires in 14 days. Restrictions apply. See terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit FanDuel.com/RG (CO, IA, MD, MI, NJ, PA, IL, VA, WV), 1-800-NEXT-STEP or text NEXTSTEP to 53342 (AZ), 1-888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org/chat (CT), 1-800-9-WITH-IT (IN), 1-800-522-4700 (WY, KS) or visit ksgamblinghelp.com (KS), 1-877-770-STOP (LA), 1-877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), TN REDLINE 1-800-889-9789 (TN)
#Pirates #PittsburghPirates #MLB
37 comments
This just feels like a set up of more of the same in 2026 with a lower payroll. I can hear Cherington now giving GM speak of being "in" on a number of players that didn't work out. I wouldn't even mind resigning IKF but if they run out IKF and Pham-types with, say, a Keller trade for a 3B I think the fans will be at a point of no return. This year has already felt different then years past with fan frustration
With Hayes gone they can pocket 2 million while spending 5 million for a 35 year old replacement for Faltor who will probably flop.
Wait until next year when they'll move everyone including Cruz and Skenes for the 2027 season. This will probably be the best Pirate team you'll see for at least a decade or longer.
This is a bigger set back than most people think because many assumed this team could compete with a few bats. Now, a few bats which they're not going to get, that fairytale is now gone. This team is decades away from competing.
Gary! Thank you for doing what you do as much as this team finds a way to break your heart over, and over, and over again. They're always my team, but they just urinated on any optimism. I'll always tune into your shows, and I appreciate it more than you know since DK discontinued Daily Shot of Pirates for the foreseeable future. This team is hard to wanna discuss or have any desire to cover. God Bless You, Brother! Thank you for somehow finding it in you to cover this organization!
i think it's funny you've known for a long time that Ben trades for only shit prospects and still you were rooting for him to make trades and now your bitching about his return make up your mind ben is never going to trade for good prospect because Bob Nutting won't let him. so you have to be prepared for this kind of thing I always dread the trade deadline
Cherington lives in the upside down, he works on a completely different thought process than the rest of the league. Embarrassing
MLB needs to step in and offer Nutting 500 million for the team or we're going to pull the MLB franchise making the team worthless if he doesn't accept.
The Pirates won't be getting any free agents unless they're washed up and unwanted by everyone else.
Cam Devanny spent 10 years in the Royals minor league system without ever getting a call up I don't know about anyone else but that's a huge red flag for me and Gary your forgetting Sammy stifura is going to be blacked by Konnor Griffen so where is he going to play Ben is such an idiot he trades for a drafts to many shortstops we have like a million shortsops in our system where are they going.
I was hoping you would have have gathered details about what the Pirates are hiding which are the cash considerations in these trades. Can you tally that up?
Until this year, no one thought much of Davis defense either.
Pirate fans have been listening to the same garbage for 35 years. Next year will look like this year. The fans want to win, front office is bean counting. No commitment to winning. Trump needs to buy the team. "Cherington your fired."
We are all being trolled by the most legendary trolling operation in human history…this is bizarre af
Hi Gary What about HOrowitz playing 3b?
MArcus from nyy just got released
should we sign him? 5 years for 50MIllion?
You do an awesome job. You really do. I love following you. We gotta all stick together during this terrible chapter in Pittsburgh Pirate history. Keep up the good work.
The Pirates hope that ……..add any player you want . this is the pirates philosphy way of building a better team for 2026.
Worst GM in the league …. Again. Groundhog Day.
Remember the Cole deal for whomever it is they secured. Different GM same result.
Gary I could never doyour job …ever thefrustation i feel as a life long fan is nothing to how you must feel, I did not like our draft and I dont like our trades but mostly i dont like playing people who will not be on our 2026 roster, Please let us see the future I dont care how old they are I can take losing with youth and inexperience but with a future goal I cant take last place standing with a mixed bag of players who will not be here net season
Cubs fans feel the same way cept on the opposite direction. We feel we desperately needed a TOR starter, and we didn't get one. The only solice is that we get to keep our top MLB ready hitters Owen Cassie and Moises Ballesteros. But the Cubs are definitely not a strong favorite in the post season.
Gary thanks for all the work you do for us die hards. I was just hoping for one decent player to be acquired that could help us next year…but it’s always ground hog day in PA. We’ll probably be having same conversation again next year at this time.
Cherrington said bats were available but, you know, they cost money. The suckage continues.
Anyone who still has belief in the pirates I have but one question for you: Why? If you haven't figured out by now that profit is the priority, not winning, then you're very dumb, to put it frankly.
I think they fundamentally misunderstand the business they are in. Yes, it's entertainment, but in sports it has to be more than that. You have to give people the hope that their team can at least compete for championships. They seem to think people will just come out to spend the night at the ballpark, enjoy the views and take in a ballgame. You'll get a few, sure. Not enough to make you profitable.
Cherington is a liar. He sucks as a GM. I hope Skenes walks into Nuttings office and asks to be traded after the season. We don't deserve him.
Ben C. Screwed the next G.M.
I'll take the one guy who didn't get his way than the other morons in the room.
Thank you for saying what we are all thinking. Summed it up perfectly. I'm a 53 year old life long Pirates fan and this is by far the most disappointed I've ever been. Absolutely no hope for next year. I thought last off season was bad, but this is just a complete injustice to the city of Pittsburgh and any fans they have left.
Gary your the best. My gosh was this disappointing. Why are the three rentals still here and why not bring up Yorke???
Agree on Falter. Paid more for Heaney…when you had Falter. WTF! I’m ticked cause I love baseball.
Brought up Triolo, I like him, but I want te see what we have in Yorke or Cook or Davanney.
No one on these podcast are as prepared as you or as knowledgeable.
Why not trade for a rental to get someone in here that not normally do. Hopefully approve the team and have a shot to resign? Just a thought.
Can’t stand these assholes any longer…. Done… just done
Why Bailey Falter for nothing. A affordable left hander who was above good on a shitty General Mangaged team. Same with Bednar. These two players were actually happy to be Pirates. A commodity not many players in MLB want to be a Pirate. We got worse. We will never hear of these prospects again.