Let’s count down the worst Giants of our recent era. Starting with matchup 1, of 2 GMs! Most upvotes wins, defend your choice!

48 comments

  1. Gettleman built a bad team and we had no cap space after he left. Bad and expensive is a lethal combo. Reese got bad after a good start, Gettleman was always bad.

  9. I’d imagine an Eagles fan would post negative shit like this on the Giants sub in August.

    I don’t know about anyone else, but Gettleman is the last thing on my mind right now.

  10. Gettleman should 100% take every match-up, he might have set them back an entire decade with his decision making

  15. I vote Kadarius Toney, he was bad with us and then bad on a Super Bowl team, no doubt left at that point just a bust.

  16. Joe judge vs Kadarius Toney! lol 😂 Joe judge was the worse in this bracket imho. Joe schoen and Brian Daboll gonna be here next year if this year is awful.

  21. Jake Fromm can only dream of damaging a franchise as much as Daniel Jones and his huge contract did.

  22. I’m gonna die on the hill of Joe Judge wasn’t that bad. We had a terrible team and he was forced to work with piles of crap.

  23. Why waste the time with a whole bracket when we all know gettleman is taking this down in a landslide.

  24. I want to create a team of alt accounts just to vote Gettleman over and over. He was the worst GM I have witnessed in my 44 years!

  28. It’s not a GM, coach, or player. It’s John Mara. He’s the reason this is a sorry ass franchise in 2025.

  29. You can’t really put front office guys and players together.. FO sucks on a whole other level

  30. Reese. As much as I hate Gettleman, Reese took a championship team and drove it into the ground. He neglected what made the Superbowl winning teams great. And to cap it off, used Coughlin as a scape goat.

    Gettleman was a bafoon, but was handed a shit show. He did draft a lot of all-pros, couldn’t figure out how to keep them around or hire decent coaching staff. So, he was a net zero. Reese was a net -90 to our locker room, front office and culture.

  31. I met Dave Gettleman the other day, super nice guy him and his wife. Chatted for a few minutes and took a pic. Was pretty crazy. That being said yea Dave Gettleman 100%

  32. Reese was worse than Gettleman, but neither of them is going to be worse than Chris Mara, so it doesn’t matter.

  33. This is close to a tie. Gentleman was responsible Golladay, Toney, Solder, Baker and picking up Fromm from the Bills practice squad. Reese was responsible for Hart, Flowers & Apple. I go with Reese, I think Getleman had more pro-bowlers.

    Edit: Changed my mind. I forgot that Getleman put the Giants in cap hell.

  38. Kenny Golliday his free agency was a bust! If you draft a guy and they suck, oh well that’s the draft gamble. But if you get a guy in free agency and they’re a pro and don’t produce and bitch all the time, that’s the worst.

  43. Flowers vs Solder in the first round is rouuugggghhhh. I might go Solder just based on how insane it was that after Flowers we got someone even shittier, but Flowers was bad for so long. That’s a tough 1st round matchup.

  46. The judge vs mcadoo and eli apple vs flowers thread are going to be very interesting.

  47. LMAO its REESE and its not particularly close.

    I can make a long post why, but everything on this list is a direct result of Jerry Reese.

Leave a Reply