If Aroldis Chapman had a sub 1.00 ERA or close to it to end the season, would you consider him an AL CY Young candidate?
August 28, 2025
He's been insane with a 1.04 ERA in 57 IP. Hasn't allowed a hit as of this post since July 23rd. I know Skubal and Crochet are the favorites right now, but for a relief pitcher this is impressive enough to at least be in the conversation.
32 comments
Candidate? Yeah for sure, but he’s not winning it. He should finish top 5 if that happens, maybe even 3rd
No
Candidate? Absolutely. But, he’s not even winning the Sox Cy Young…
Clase just had a season like that last year and got 3rd.
If he keeps it up with not allowing any hits or runs to end the season. He should be considered maybe he can win it if he gets it to a 1 or below.
Clase had better numbers last year and didn’t win, so no.
Yes. Aside from Skubal and maybe Crochet, the field is weak this year.
He is certainly going to get votes, but if Zack Britton couldn’t win in 2016, Chapman has no chance of winning it.
Sure but he ain’t winning it. Zack Britton’s 2016 season is still the modern gold standard.
He’ll be top 10 in Cy Young voting
No
He’d get votes but no shot of actually winning
Nope. He doesn’t even have 60 innings yet.
If 2016 Britton didn’t win, Chapman has no chance.
Just as a comparison Eric Gagne was the last non-starter to win the Cy Young – Also the ONLY RP since 1992
In 2003 he had a 1.20 season ERA, a .692 WHIP, 137 Ks, and 55 saves (with 0 blown, part of his 84 consecutive streak that spanned from August 2002 into July 2004)
Chapman’s ERA and WHIP are actually a bit better but he’s FAR behind in IP, Ks, and total saves – PLUS he isn’t riding a historic streak of any kind to bolster his story
He’s having a great year and he’ll get votes, could easily finish top 5. He comes nowhere close to winning the award.
No
Legendary woman respector Aroldis Chapman? No thanks.
Fuck no
Like others have said he’d be a candidate for sure but not win. If the field of SPs was weak then in some scenarios I could see such a reliever winning Cy Young, but unfortunately that is just not the case. There are a lot of great pitchers in the AL
Closers don’t win unless there are no starters that have a great year.
Yes, he’ll definitely be a candidate, but a starter will win.
Naw he’s incredible but the other 2 you mentioned deserve it more, not to mention a lot of other dudes. Cy Young isn’t really a reliever reward anyways
He’s not winning but without a doubt he will get some votes. If Chris Martin got some a few seasons ago he most certainly will.
No
See Fernando Rodney’s 2012 season
I haven’t been paying enough attention but he’s easily the best AL reliever, right?
Doesn’t matter what he does, too many better starting pitchers.
He can finish top 5, but no way he wins it.
Not a single chance in hell. Mo Rivera didn’t even win despite being one of the best closers in history.
Yes, he’d be a candidate. But I believe he wouldn’t be the winner. He’s probably not even the best pitcher on his team this season.
Nope. If Clase didn’t do it last year. Chapman won’t this year.
nolan mclean will win the nl cy young next season
If there wasn’t a legit starting pitcher candidate then a closer can be a candidate
32 comments
Candidate? Yeah for sure, but he’s not winning it. He should finish top 5 if that happens, maybe even 3rd
No
Candidate? Absolutely. But, he’s not even winning the Sox Cy Young…
Clase just had a season like that last year and got 3rd.
If he keeps it up with not allowing any hits or runs to end the season. He should be considered maybe he can win it if he gets it to a 1 or below.
Clase had better numbers last year and didn’t win, so no.
Yes. Aside from Skubal and maybe Crochet, the field is weak this year.
He is certainly going to get votes, but if Zack Britton couldn’t win in 2016, Chapman has no chance of winning it.
Sure but he ain’t winning it. Zack Britton’s 2016 season is still the modern gold standard.
He’ll be top 10 in Cy Young voting
No
He’d get votes but no shot of actually winning
Nope. He doesn’t even have 60 innings yet.
If 2016 Britton didn’t win, Chapman has no chance.
Just as a comparison Eric Gagne was the last non-starter to win the Cy Young – Also the ONLY RP since 1992
In 2003 he had a 1.20 season ERA, a .692 WHIP, 137 Ks, and 55 saves (with 0 blown, part of his 84 consecutive streak that spanned from August 2002 into July 2004)
Chapman’s ERA and WHIP are actually a bit better but he’s FAR behind in IP, Ks, and total saves – PLUS he isn’t riding a historic streak of any kind to bolster his story
He’s having a great year and he’ll get votes, could easily finish top 5. He comes nowhere close to winning the award.
No
Legendary woman respector Aroldis Chapman? No thanks.
Fuck no
Like others have said he’d be a candidate for sure but not win. If the field of SPs was weak then in some scenarios I could see such a reliever winning Cy Young, but unfortunately that is just not the case. There are a lot of great pitchers in the AL
Closers don’t win unless there are no starters that have a great year.
Yes, he’ll definitely be a candidate, but a starter will win.
Naw he’s incredible but the other 2 you mentioned deserve it more, not to mention a lot of other dudes. Cy Young isn’t really a reliever reward anyways
He’s not winning but without a doubt he will get some votes. If Chris Martin got some a few seasons ago he most certainly will.
No
See Fernando Rodney’s 2012 season
I haven’t been paying enough attention but he’s easily the best AL reliever, right?
Doesn’t matter what he does, too many better starting pitchers.
He can finish top 5, but no way he wins it.
Not a single chance in hell. Mo Rivera didn’t even win despite being one of the best closers in history.
Yes, he’d be a candidate. But I believe he wouldn’t be the winner. He’s probably not even the best pitcher on his team this season.
Nope. If Clase didn’t do it last year. Chapman won’t this year.
nolan mclean will win the nl cy young next season
If there wasn’t a legit starting pitcher candidate then a closer can be a candidate