A’s leave Oakland: ONE Year Later

Here’s Brody Brazil. You know, it’s crazy. Back in the day, I remember how excited I was to get a phone number for my pager. And now I’ve got a phone number for my YouTube channel. It’s an 800 phone number. 8334 Brody. If you’ve got something to say, a question, a comment, or a contribution for this YouTube channel. Phone it in. I listen to all of your voicemails. I get to play back and respond to the very best ones, like right here, right now on a future video. Let’s listen. Wow. I wasn’t ready for that voicemail. That was epic, dude. Hey, my name is Ariel. I’m calling from San Francisco. Longtime uh listener of the show. Thank you. You were talking about the other day of covering A’s and maybe it’s not like your thing. I get it. Uh for me as a fan, old fan of the A’s, uh I need this. It’s almost like a therapy session for me. Um, and imagine for you too, there’s a lot of emotions, uh, a lot of feelings that are so raw and I think it’s almost therapeutic that we talk about this tragedy. It’s like PTSD. Something awful happened to us collectively and we’re victims. We are. We had something stolen from us that we love. And I think we need to talk about it. And it’d be great if you were to talk about it because you have a a platform and also you’re very uh fair professional. Thank you. And you know, you have a unique perspective of being uh part of the AIDS for a moment and also part of our voice because a fan base doesn’t have a voice. So you are a voice. I know that sucks. You probably don’t want to do it, but just saying if you can continue to make some videos about A’s content, uh I really appreciate that. I know that’s probably hard for you. Uh yeah, hope all is well. I’m gonna keep uh watching the show. All right, cheers. Bye. Ariel, thank you very much for uh supporting the channel and calling in. I I just need to take a moment because yeah, that that hits like when you realize as we’re about a year removed as I’m recording this video, as I’ll be releasing this video, we’re about a year removed from something that was traumatic for all of us. And as a sports fan, you come to terms with losing a game, losing a championship, losing your favorite player, but losing your entire team, like that just is not supposed to happen. That’s not something that you sign up for. And I’ll be honest, Ariel, like I went into this summer thinking, you know what? I’m I’m going to make a hard switch and I I might do some Giants here on the channel. I’m going to do a lot of baseball. And I did some baseball coverage. I also just took this first off seasonason of like my real adult life. I mean, I’ve been doing baseball and hockey back toback for 15 plus years, and I finally just kind of eased in and said maybe I just need to kind of take a baseball season off from being tied in to one particular team. Um, and so I I don’t know like what the future holds for me and being, you know, kind of a voice of of A’s fans and and I’ll say doing the A’s hard work, like the hard work of of still keeping this conversation alive. There’s a couple points I want to make here. um what happened with the team and it moving and nobody having the fans back and all of this and I mean like from the commissioner of baseball to the team itself to the city of Oakland to the county of Alamita and and there will be fans who are just trolling and they’re just haters and they’re trying to say to you, well this A’s team, they they moved from Philly to Kansas City, then Kansas City to Oakland, then Oakland to Sacramento, Sacramento to Vegas. They’ve always been a transitional team. Well, yeah, but 57 years in Oakland is that that’s transitional to you. Um, and when they came west, there were reasons for that. And Philadelphia, I know, already had a team and there was a lot going on. There was a lot of teams migrating west. But even when the A’s left Kansas City, what happened the very next year? Baseball got scared because Kansas City made some threats and they were awarded an expansion team. That’s who the Royals are to this day. the Royals exist because of the A’s departure and the fallout from it. And other people will say, well, this is Oakland and Oakland’s got problems and issues. That’s true. And Oakland also lost the Warriors and the Raiders. That’s also true. But this is an individual thing. This is a team that went out and said, “We’re staying. This we’re rooted in Oakland. We’re going to build Howard Terminal. Here’s all the plans. Here’s our backup plan, the Coliseum. Even if this ambitious plan doesn’t work north of Jack London Square, we’ve got a backup plan for that. So, there’s no question that we’re going to be staying here until they change their mind and until they didn’t really show their math on changing their mind. Oh, we tried. Did you show me? Prove it to me. To say that we tried is one thing. To to show me and to prove that you tried, then I might have like I there is another way around this. There is a way the Ace could have departed Oakland and not had all of the dust up that existed. If you showed people the math and you showed people there was no option and you showed people how hard you worked to try and keep this team here. It’s kind of the end of the conversation really. There’s still sadness, but there’s not as much disagreement. But when you say you tried, you don’t show anybody and then you walk out the door. That’s when we get to where we’re at here. Um, I’ve realized that personally there is probably a responsibility on my part of maintaining a voice in all of this and whether it’s here on YouTube or social media or people want to do interviews with me for their documentary or their story. You know, I do feel an obligation and responsibility to be somebody to talk about this because I experienced all of it from start to finish and I still don’t know if we’ve reached the official finish of it yet. Like I I wish we have. I wish that we could move down the road. I wish this could be a chapter in the past. I wish that there weren’t even so many questions that still loom about this entire situation, but I guess there is a responsibility of of being that person because I was entrenched in it. It’s not a role that I rejoice in. Even making this video, Ariel, like I’m I’m doing it because you were so convincing in the call and we are about a year removed and this is something that I I wanted to, you know, bring up here. I don’t mind talking about it, but it’s not something that I’m like can’t wait to do that. because yeah, it it doesn’t feel good to to hash all these things back up to rehash them. I think experience and continuity matter in in documenting this. Uh what what I mean by that is, you know, you can’t just jump into this situation and do all the the the research of what happened. Like if you’re new to this situation, it’s really hard to comprehend. I don’t have to do the research because I I went through it all and the process in Oakland, the process of things cooling off and the pandemic happened and then all of a sudden it’s a hard switch of gears and then it’s parallel paths and then it’s turning the back on Oakland and so many questions in Las Vegas and anyway like experience and continuity do matter. So when you hear somebody covering this story and if look if they’ve just joined the story as part of the Sacramento angle, they don’t really understand the backstory of it. If they’re in Las Vegas and they’re covering the arrival of the A’s and they’re they’re new to this and they they didn’t really live through the 2010s and even before that with the A’s projects in Fremont and downtown Oakland and possibly San Jose. If you don’t understand all of that, you’re new to this story and there’s nothing wrong with that. But there’s a lot of context here that you don’t have in terms of the present and and how things might actually go in the future. All of this again fatiguing beyond belief. Uh I’ll do it and Ariel like I I appreciate you saying that like keep going because it it means a lot to a lot of people. Quite honestly that’s the number one and only reason why I think I’ll even continue to whatever degree. And and I do want to say that maybe next baseball season here on the channel might be different. Maybe I’ll pick a different team. I don’t know. I mean, I I think it could and should be the Giants, but maybe I’ll pick a different Major League Baseball team to follow here a little more closely on the channel. Um something I’ve always been doing in in my summer times of of professional years gone by. So, I don’t know. I just this year it was a little bit confusing and cloudy. And I appreciate the call. I appreciate the comment. And you know, it’s a it’s a role, I guess, that I do take kind of seriously, but to represent the fans in all of this and just to continue documenting it and being a voice. Let me know what you think about all this in the comments section below. Also, thumbs up while you’re down there helps me and this video and this channel. And don’t forget to subscribe. I want to see you back here next time.

Join channel, access perks ✅ http://brodie.bz/join
LEAVE ME A VOICEMAIL 📞 (833) 4-BRODIE

*Subscribe now, get more* 📺 http://brodie.bz/YouTube

[[ *MY PLAYLISTS* ]]
San Jose Sharks: https://brodie.bz/sharks
San Francisco 49ers: https://brodie.bz/49ers
San Francisco Giants: https://brodie.bz/giants
Golden State Warriors: https://brodie.bz/warriors
Howard Terminal Ballpark: https://brodie.bz/HowardTerminal
Oakland Athletics: https://brodie.bz/athletics

[[ *MY OTHER CHANNELS* ]]
*BRODIE BRAZIL AVIATION* ✈️ http://brodie.bz/Aviation
*HOME STUDIO PRO* 🎥 http://brodie.bz/HomeStudio

📸 *Instagram* ➡️ http://brodie.bz/IG
🐦 *X /Twitter* ➡️ http://brodie.bz/X
👍 *Facebook* ➡️ http://brodie.bz/FB

*Support this channel* 🎉 https://brodie.bz/PayPal

#mlb #baseball #oakland

25 comments
  1. WHAT DO YOU REMEMBER FROM THE END OF THE OAKLAND A'S?

    Some other videos you might like:

    Your best questions, answered (Sept 25, 2025)
    📺 https://youtu.be/pQC4K_deijM

    One company OWNS 33% of Minor League Baseball teams?!
    📺 https://youtu.be/9EtXP1QDJug

    MLB going AUTOMATED for Ball & Strike challenges
    📺 https://youtu.be/D3n6pmkKjdQ

    Is this the BREAKING Point of Sports Ads?
    📺 https://youtu.be/X8hk-QGuko8

    How MLB could PREVENT its NEXT lockout
    📺 https://youtu.be/oPdIswMzrfA

    Why NHL players can now SKIP Suits & Ties
    📺 https://youtu.be/pdISWolB-6E

    Arizona Coyotes COMEBACK takes big step forward
    📺 https://youtu.be/Xaf30PAeNjc

  2. I'm a out-of-sight, out-of-mind kinda person. When it became apparent that both the A's & Raiders were leaving, each time I canceled tickets, threw out my gear and cut it clean. That's it. They're dead to me. And that has worked for me. That said, after almost a year, the A's departure still smarts. I'm still pretty upset about how this all went down.

  3. I follow your channel because I love the Sharks but grew up in the PNW. I greatly disliked the A's. However that meant I also grew up a diehard Sonics fan. I was crushed when they left. That feeling never really goes away. Ive just removed myself from the NBA completely. Even if they come back it wont be the same. I imagine that's how some A's fans are feeling.

  4. Regardless of what the "math" may have shown there still would have been a "dust up" over the A's departure. There is no good or clean way to move a team. Fans, understandably, are emotional. They don't care whether the A's may have had no alternative or had they "tried harder" they would have stayed. Oakland fans are upset, depressed, annoyed, disgusted, (or add any adjective you like) but even if Fisher laid out all the numbers and they conclusively showed that staying in Oakland was not feasible the fans and the community would still have felt wronged and "they" were not adequately represented. In the end it's always a business (and real estate) decision an owner has to make.

  5. Brodie Brazil, I doubt you'll ever read this, but I'll ask you anyway. This has always bothered me, and just maybe you help me. When Fisher was "negotiating" with Oakland to build a stadium he said he needed a lot of land because he needed to build housing, businesses, office buildings, etc. that was going to help pay for the stadium. If I recall correctly, and you can correct me if I'm wrong, altogether it was going to cost around $12 billion for the complete project, supposedly, and Oakland had come up with around $1 billion, if memory serves, so the other $11 billion was going to have to come from John Fisher himself. Fast forward to today, the latest estimates on the Las Vegas stadium, it's going to cost a minimum of $2 billion, and through loans and Clark County kicking in $380, selling the SJ Earthquakes for, supposedly $500 million, and Aramark giving him around $200 million for the rights to sell concessions, and I read somewhere he got around a $300 million loan from Golden Saks, if my math is correct that's around, give or take, $1.4-$1.5 billion, still short $500 million. So, if he's having trouble coming up with $2 billion, how/where the @#$& was he going to come up with $12 billion to build a mini village around the new stadium at Howard Terminal? Thanks for your time, Mr Brazil. God bless and stay safe!

  6. Please don’t follow the Giants. You’d be exactly following the roadmap laid out by MLB! Manfred even said that Oakland A’s fans could become fans of the SF Giants. This is a big NO for me!! It’d honestly be too hard for me to listen to anything about the Giants. They were complicit in the departure of the A’s. I can’t forgive for that reason.

    I would accept you following any other MLB team if it’s to keep MLB content in your rotation.
    Thanks for all your hard work, Brodie! Appreciate you keeping the spirit of the Oakland A’s alive!!

  7. The people of Oakland need to vote differently. The city is run by leftists who have turned it into a bankrupt, violet hellhole. Major league sports will never want to re-enter that market.

  8. Imagine how the residents of NYC must have felt back in the 50s when both the Giants and the Dodgers abandoned the city for greener pastures out on the west coast. MLB has yet to this day attempted to venture back into Kings County.

    I may be trolling you slightly because you’re a California guy, but I promise it’s all in good fun.

    As for the A’s situation I agree it’s extremely sad and could (probably should) have turned out better both for fans of the team and baseball. Also, why the big push to Vegas now for pro sports? Seems like that would’ve made way more sense 20 years ago. Maybe, just maybe, that could be a future video topic.

    Keep up to good work Brodie.

  9. Thank you as always Brodie, as to what to do next season as far as covering baseball, maybe a rotation of storylines you find compelling. I haven't picked a new team (my son has moved onto the Dodgers). I kind of just root for former Oakland A's. So teams I will look at are: Cleveland (Vogt), Atlanta (Olson, Murphy), Giants (Melvin, Chapman), Texas (Semien). And then I bandwagon it and just follow whoever is doing well.

  10. If you're looking for a baseball team to follow, why not the Angels? Smaller team in their market, pain owner, American League, and trying to do stuff with their stadium (parking lots), does all that sound a bit familiar lol? Lots of interesting things going on while also being on the outside of the whole SF, LA, SD three way rivalry

  11. Spot on Brodie. Especially about reporters, etc. who are coming at this without having experienced it all. As a person old enough to have been a fan since 1968 it's painful! I've not watched any baseball this year or even looked to see what the A's are doing other than what you've shown on the channel. I do appreciate the videos you do about the A's. But I understand how it's fatiguing. I don't know that I'll watch baseball again. I've moved on and it's fine. There are other things to watch. I don't want to "pick" another team to follow. Keep up the good work.

  12. If I was a fan of a team that moved, my loyalty t them would be gone. Doubt I could be a fan of another. I probably would still watch some games but not with the enjoyment I once had. I probably would root for any team that played against my old team.

  13. They took our beloved A's and Raiders to make the league owners richer. Coporate greed is ruining all walks of life. The real fans will always be in the town and east bay.

  14. Brodie, "Hi", My name is Dave and I live here on the Arizona/ Utah border @ St. George. I'm probably one of a very few people that believes that EVERY man or woman has their price. In my heart of hearts I have to believe that there has to be an investment group in the Bay Area that if they wave enough Billions of Dollars under the nose of John Fisher that he might just bend, smile and take the money to give back to Oakland the Team name, colors, and records of the Oakland A's. I can hope can't I?

Leave a Reply