Which ex-Giants player would be the worst manager?

32 comments

1. Hunter Strickland

2. Jean Machi.

3. Ruben Rivera

4. Fred Lewis

5. People love Will Clark, but I feel like he’d be a massive trainwreck.

   Also Coonrod, Huff, Melky, or Strickland

6. Melky

7. Huff

8. My childhood hero – Will Clark

   Not with this modern ball player

9. Tom Murphy

10. Jeff Kent. He was a arrogant douche.

11. I feel like using Pierzynski or the Rally Thong Man are low-hanging fruit, so I’m gonna say Dave Roberts

    Wait a minute

12. Willie Mays. Not because he’d be bad at it, but because he’s dead

13. Melky Cabrera

14. Deion Sanders

15. brian wilson. i mean it would be fun but a disaster

16. Angel Villalona.

17. Casey McGehee

18. A.J. Pierzynski

19. I love Will Clark, but he would be a disaster as a manager.

20. Eric sim

21. huff

22. Absolutely not Bob Melvin

23. Dan Uggla

24. Carlos Rodon with a baseball bat in hand 

25. Matt Williams

26. Joc Pederson

27. Armando Benitez, easily

28. Armando Benitez, not great under pressure

29. I try to forget AJ Pierzynski was ever a Giant, it seems to be a broadcaster for Fox you need to be arrogant and kind of a douche

30. MadBum would be a pretty terrible manager

31. Bob Melvin

32. Brian Wilson