Would you make this trade? Is anyone off the table?
November 10, 2025
Would you make this trade? Is anyone off the table?
6 comments
The extension is the problem
Why? So we can deplete our farm for a rental? Hard pass. Let some other team (like the Yankees) make that mistake.
I’d have to be what the Dodgers did with Glasnow and complete the extension as apart of the trade agreement
And he’s a local boy, too!
Overwhelmed to me sounds like you’re starting with Eldridge and Roupp plus an mlb guy like Lee or Ramos, not to mention a few more prospects that may need to be thrown in. At that point not sure it’s worth it even if you could extend Skubal.
Just sign him when he becomes a free agent.
Skubal is a Scott Boras client which means he’s not going to sign an extension when his contract hasn’t expired. He will test free agency and sign with the highest bidder. All players represented by Boras do this.
Why should the Giants blow their farm up for a rental that may not be with the team long term?
6 comments
The extension is the problem
Why? So we can deplete our farm for a rental? Hard pass. Let some other team (like the Yankees) make that mistake.
I’d have to be what the Dodgers did with Glasnow and complete the extension as apart of the trade agreement
And he’s a local boy, too!
Overwhelmed to me sounds like you’re starting with Eldridge and Roupp plus an mlb guy like Lee or Ramos, not to mention a few more prospects that may need to be thrown in. At that point not sure it’s worth it even if you could extend Skubal.
Just sign him when he becomes a free agent.
Skubal is a Scott Boras client which means he’s not going to sign an extension when his contract hasn’t expired. He will test free agency and sign with the highest bidder. All players represented by Boras do this.
Why should the Giants blow their farm up for a rental that may not be with the team long term?