At this point Ohtani and Judge will win the MVPs every year until age regression hits. There’s such a huge gap between them and everyone else.
20 years from now people are going to think its silly this was ever a debate.
Shout out to Cal though, amazing season for a catcher. But Judge is just on another planet.
They got it right
Sanity prevails.
Cal raleigh was statistically half the player judge was lol
Well, we have It’s back-to-back winners in both leagues. Its AL MVP for The Captain!
Point: He deserves it. Counterpoint: BOOOO!!
It was very close. And honestly if the batting averages were just a little bit closer it would have been Cal’s.
not a yankee fan but voters made the right decision.
Boy this is going to be a very civilized conversation, no way people will get mad about this LOL
Fucking hell, getting dick-punched even in the offseason. It never ends.
If cal hit 270 even, it’s probably his. Hitting under 250 is just too low
Honestly shouldn’t have even been that close of competition 🤷🏻♂️
Respect to Cal. Had a crazy season
I mean this leaked earlier today, right? No surprise.
Should have been Cal, but MLB glazes New York and LA.
Future hall of famer Jose Ramirez with another top 3 MVP.
I hate Judge but come on guys, offensively this wasn’t close, nearly 100 points separate their batting average, obp, and ops, and while Raleigh’s defense is good it’s not nearly good enough to make up the difference.
Judge beat voter fatigue and Yankee hate. That’s how much of a generational run he is on.
Cal was robbed
I’m more impressed with a big guy who can hit with his strike zone, than a stubby tiny guy with a strike zone as big as a postage stamp😌.
Most of the writers are not Yankees fans. You sound like a 12 year old
The hate Judge gets just because he’s a Yankee. Does Shohei get the same hate? Yankees live rent free in people’s warped damaged minds…Congratulations Captain, MVP Judge! 👏
It’s Most VALUABLE Player and who added more value to their team and its success…. Judge or Raleigh; because the Yanks are still the Yanks without Judge, but Seattle doesn’t make the playoffs without Cal. 🤷♂️
As others have mentioned, in 20 years people will laugh at the fact that a person who hit 247 was ever considered for an MVP. No position player EVER has won an mvp hitting below .267. The one who did? Marty Marion in a weak mvp class in 1944 while the best players were in the military.
43 comments
Bullshit
Yeah, this is not correct. It should be Cal Raleigh
Cal got robbed. Try squatting all game and then hitting like he did.
Love Cal, but this is obviously the right choice. Judge was unreal this year yet again.
Unfortunately, the only way Cal was winning is if he broke the record and he came up just short
Wow
You had it a minute before Bleacher Report. Congrats!
Should’ve been his 4th if it wasn’t for that fucking cheater back in 2017
Raleigh was robbed, no way if a Yankee catcher had the season Cal Raleigh had that they wouldn’t win the MVP.
If Cal had a better batting average I’m sure he would have won. .247 for an MVP would be crazy regardless of the number of HRs.
https://preview.redd.it/r6gai4etf41g1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f8e39f1fe70caa8fffbb76fd44e917dd53ae78a8
Cal was VERY CLOSE. wow
Seattle Mariners
At this point Ohtani and Judge will win the MVPs every year until age regression hits. There’s such a huge gap between them and everyone else.
20 years from now people are going to think its silly this was ever a debate.
Shout out to Cal though, amazing season for a catcher. But Judge is just on another planet.
They got it right
Sanity prevails.
Cal raleigh was statistically half the player judge was lol
Well, we have It’s back-to-back winners in both leagues. Its AL MVP for The Captain!
Point: He deserves it. Counterpoint: BOOOO!!
It was very close. And honestly if the batting averages were just a little bit closer it would have been Cal’s.
not a yankee fan but voters made the right decision.
Boy this is going to be a very civilized conversation, no way people will get mad about this LOL
Fucking hell, getting dick-punched even in the offseason. It never ends.
If cal hit 270 even, it’s probably his. Hitting under 250 is just too low
Honestly shouldn’t have even been that close of competition 🤷🏻♂️
Respect to Cal. Had a crazy season
I mean this leaked earlier today, right? No surprise.
Should have been Cal, but MLB glazes New York and LA.
Future hall of famer Jose Ramirez with another top 3 MVP.
I hate Judge but come on guys, offensively this wasn’t close, nearly 100 points separate their batting average, obp, and ops, and while Raleigh’s defense is good it’s not nearly good enough to make up the difference.
https://preview.redd.it/wwt653xjh41g1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f541727ad589bf71f10a88edcec28854659af04b
Judge beat voter fatigue and Yankee hate. That’s how much of a generational run he is on.
Cal was robbed
I’m more impressed with a big guy who can hit with his strike zone, than a stubby tiny guy with a strike zone as big as a postage stamp😌.
Most of the writers are not Yankees fans. You sound like a 12 year old
The hate Judge gets just because he’s a Yankee. Does Shohei get the same hate? Yankees live rent free in people’s warped damaged minds…Congratulations Captain, MVP Judge! 👏
OH YEAHHHHHH
Yankee fan living in Seattle, they’re pissed lol
https://preview.redd.it/dpcibfulo41g1.jpeg?width=1347&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1f4f6cfb1ec628ef90024d8f4a3c2ff00b93fdcd
I’ll just leave this here….
It’s Most VALUABLE Player and who added more value to their team and its success…. Judge or Raleigh; because the Yanks are still the Yanks without Judge, but Seattle doesn’t make the playoffs without Cal. 🤷♂️
As others have mentioned, in 20 years people will laugh at the fact that a person who hit 247 was ever considered for an MVP. No position player EVER has won an mvp hitting below .267. The one who did? Marty Marion in a weak mvp class in 1944 while the best players were in the military.
East Coast Bias
Cal was robbed