Popular opinion? I want these to be the alternative jerseys
November 20, 2025
Popular opinion? I want these to be the alternative jerseys
28 comments
Honestly that how we ended up with our current alts so I dig it. I wonder how these would look in reverse colors
Absolutely not a popular opinion lol. I think I am the only one in the world that has positive opinions of these jerseys. Even if we won that game I think most people wouldn’t like it.
I once saw a variant of this jersey that was pretty nice, I think it made the entire section below the orange chest stripe blue.
I personally like it though. There are certain players that I think “match” certain jerseys well and I think this is a good one for some players.
EDIT: Also I gotta say the coach gear for these jerseys was sick. I want that sweatshirt or whatever that Roy was wearing:
These are cursed 👎
Cursed! This jersey just reminds me of blowing a 5 goal lead! And loosing to the rangers on network tv
Do we have a schedule for the alternate jerseys? Doesn’t look like we have one on the team website. Would like to see either the fisherman or NY jersey for a couple games
Contrary to another comment here, if they didn’t blow that game, this jersey would be an all-timer. But they did. And it isn’t. But I accept that extreme pain and PTSD is part of the fandom.
I wouldn’t mind them doing a variation on it, but not these exact ones
i think their hideous ngl pls don’t downvote me just my opinion
Now that we have Darche, and more marketing and creativity in the front office, I’d like an actual nicely designed 3rd jersey. I love the ones I’m seeing around the league like the Redwings and Oilers. I’d hope for something better than this. I’m dying to buy a Schaefer jersey and almost pulled the trigger on the cancer night ones, but decided to wait. I’m really hoping we get a good design.
Can we just wear the reverse retro navy blues as our alternate? We actually won with those on and they look slick.
Lighthouse.
The Islanders current alternates are really clean but I’m ready for a new, more creative take on it. I’m shocked the fisherman retros did not stick around personally
They’re just boring and unimaginative. Wordmark jerseys are almost always utter shit, IMO.
My take is they work better as a sweater than a jersey. I generally like the design but I think it looks too collegiate for an NHL team.
The killer to me though is how awful that game was.
Popular opinion: we lost the game these were made for in an Islanders fashion 3rd period meltdown to our biggest rival. No, thank you.
I often think that when they make jerseys like this one they are not for me and they are trying to hit different demographics. My 1st take was I didn’t like it, It grew on me. Way better than the Islanders across the front black jersey.
If they replaced “Isles” with the primary or fisherman logo yes
I think an orange jersey would be nice. Have lighthouse or outline of LI on it
Not a fan
I want the navy blue with the og logo that they wore during the pandemic to be the primaries
I was very unimpressed when these were released, but then having the added trauma of watching the Isles blow a multi-goal lead on national TV to the #$%&ing Rangers really killed any chance of me ever wanting one.
28 comments
Honestly that how we ended up with our current alts so I dig it. I wonder how these would look in reverse colors
Absolutely not a popular opinion lol. I think I am the only one in the world that has positive opinions of these jerseys. Even if we won that game I think most people wouldn’t like it.
I once saw a variant of this jersey that was pretty nice, I think it made the entire section below the orange chest stripe blue.
I personally like it though. There are certain players that I think “match” certain jerseys well and I think this is a good one for some players.
EDIT: Also I gotta say the coach gear for these jerseys was sick. I want that sweatshirt or whatever that Roy was wearing:
These are cursed 👎
Cursed! This jersey just reminds me of blowing a 5 goal lead! And loosing to the rangers on network tv
Do we have a schedule for the alternate jerseys? Doesn’t look like we have one on the team website. Would like to see either the fisherman or NY jersey for a couple games
Contrary to another comment here, if they didn’t blow that game, this jersey would be an all-timer. But they did. And it isn’t. But I accept that extreme pain and PTSD is part of the fandom.
I wouldn’t mind them doing a variation on it, but not these exact ones
i think their hideous ngl pls don’t downvote me just my opinion
Now that we have Darche, and more marketing and creativity in the front office, I’d like an actual nicely designed 3rd jersey. I love the ones I’m seeing around the league like the Redwings and Oilers. I’d hope for something better than this. I’m dying to buy a Schaefer jersey and almost pulled the trigger on the cancer night ones, but decided to wait. I’m really hoping we get a good design.
Can we just wear the reverse retro navy blues as our alternate? We actually won with those on and they look slick.
Lighthouse.
The Islanders current alternates are really clean but I’m ready for a new, more creative take on it. I’m shocked the fisherman retros did not stick around personally
They’re just boring and unimaginative. Wordmark jerseys are almost always utter shit, IMO.
My take is they work better as a sweater than a jersey. I generally like the design but I think it looks too collegiate for an NHL team.
The killer to me though is how awful that game was.
Popular opinion: we lost the game these were made for in an Islanders fashion 3rd period meltdown to our biggest rival. No, thank you.
I often think that when they make jerseys like this one they are not for me and they are trying to hit different demographics. My 1st take was I didn’t like it, It grew on me. Way better than the Islanders across the front black jersey.
If they replaced “Isles” with the primary or fisherman logo yes
I think an orange jersey would be nice. Have lighthouse or outline of LI on it
Not a fan
I want the navy blue with the og logo that they wore during the pandemic to be the primaries
I was very unimpressed when these were released, but then having the added trauma of watching the Isles blow a multi-goal lead on national TV to the #$%&ing Rangers really killed any chance of me ever wanting one.
I love the fisherman alts personally
https://preview.redd.it/vc7lwi4orb2g1.jpeg?width=816&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f15e03f6cb079de3a1a93d36ad6bf22ac48d3a28
They’re definitley cursed not just for its design…but because they choked that game
I want this (or something like it).
https://preview.redd.it/47xey7a8wb2g1.jpeg?width=4096&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aaf78da3dc6a9ee126cbc20519511e93544e6e85
Do you have a link for this?
Worst jersey in Isles history 👎
Personally I would not like to be reminded of the game that this was worn in