Blue Jays reporter Keegan Matheson breaks down what re-signing Bo Bichette could look like for the Blue Jays and their interest in Kyle Tucker. “Bo Bichette does want to be in Toronto…”
December 4, 2025
Blue Jays reporter Keegan Matheson breaks down what re-signing Bo Bichette could look like for the Blue Jays and their interest in Kyle Tucker. “Bo Bichette does want to be in Toronto…”
26 comments
Hope Bichette gets announced during the winter meetings in a few days. I can’t wait much longer lol
And Toronto wants Bichette
I mean he said he wanted to be in Toronto.
Love Keegan. Love the Jays. LOVE BO SIGNING AT THE WINTER MEETINGS.

It’s really on the front office now. Pay the fucking man his worth.
Bo + Vladdy should make this team contenders for years.
Sign them both! Surely after Rogers got a taste from a deep playoff run, they’ll be itching to do everything possible to get back there
Is tucker objectively better overall than Bo? Probably. And would I like to sign tucker? Absolutely. But I need a Bo deal completed above and beyond anything else. And soon. Like yesterday.
I feel like Ross won’t leave the Winter Meetings until Bo or Tucker sign with us
Give him the same deal they gave Cease, maybe with an extra year or two, and call it a day.
I get that he has his defensive shortcomings but let’s not forget this is the guy that missed a month and a half then just showed up to the World Series and hit .350. Pay the man.
Back the TD Bank truck up to his front door, Rogers’!
Tucker should be the guy. Outfield FA class is awful next year for when we move off of Springer and transition Santander to DH. Compare that to the infield which still has Vlad, Ernie, Gimenez, Barger, and our top two position-player prospects.
There’s a butttttt coming in there isn’t there Keegan
Sorry. But if Bo wants to be a Jay. Like reaalllly wants to be a Jay.
He would have signed forever ago.
Rogers can get both. So much money coming off the books in 2027. Suck it up for one year
I don’t know why, but I think we’re getting both
DH Springer
RF Tucker
1B Vladdy
2B Bichette
C Kirk
LF Santander
3B Barger
CF Varsho
SS Gimenez
Super Sub Clement
Championship
Why hasn’t he signed yet?
Edward just sign them both
Wow to go to this sub now to this… they are a contender so bad
My mom who is 88 and I watched all year to the point I got a job working at her place as maintenance… this would be so special
Bo, Tucker and an elite arm. Do it Rogers.
I’m just hoping Santander can get back to form. Having one of bichette and/or tucker would be such a fucking problem for opposing teams to deal with when top to bottom your lineup can produce offensively and it’s not like sending your 7th to 9th batters our there to just strikeout.
It’d be such a crazy lineup to watch lol.
The Bichette situation is a bit complicated as far as his free agency goes, because both the jays and Bo expressed strong interest to make it work…
Teams are cautious to approach because they don’t want to just increase his Jays salary, and the Jays want to get the best value deal that he feels good about
Ernie said in an interview he was invited to Bo’s wedding early in the New Year. Wouldn’t be surprised if Bo is motivated to get his deal signed in December before his wedding.
Why not both.
No doubt having tucker on the team would be great. They’re talking to him because they should. There’s no guarantee Bo will sign.
After the last place finish in 2024, Schneider, the FO, and players all learned from their mistakes. A few years ago we kept hearing about “the window”. Well, there’s a tremendous opportunity in front of this team now. Signing Bo is like having a perpetual window.
26 comments
Hope Bichette gets announced during the winter meetings in a few days. I can’t wait much longer lol
And Toronto wants Bichette
I mean he said he wanted to be in Toronto.
Love Keegan. Love the Jays. LOVE BO SIGNING AT THE WINTER MEETINGS.

It’s really on the front office now. Pay the fucking man his worth.
Bo + Vladdy should make this team contenders for years.
Sign them both! Surely after Rogers got a taste from a deep playoff run, they’ll be itching to do everything possible to get back there
Is tucker objectively better overall than Bo? Probably. And would I like to sign tucker? Absolutely. But I need a Bo deal completed above and beyond anything else. And soon. Like yesterday.
I feel like Ross won’t leave the Winter Meetings until Bo or Tucker sign with us
Give him the same deal they gave Cease, maybe with an extra year or two, and call it a day.
I get that he has his defensive shortcomings but let’s not forget this is the guy that missed a month and a half then just showed up to the World Series and hit .350. Pay the man.
Back the TD Bank truck up to his front door, Rogers’!
Tucker should be the guy. Outfield FA class is awful next year for when we move off of Springer and transition Santander to DH. Compare that to the infield which still has Vlad, Ernie, Gimenez, Barger, and our top two position-player prospects.
There’s a butttttt coming in there isn’t there Keegan
Sorry. But if Bo wants to be a Jay. Like reaalllly wants to be a Jay.
He would have signed forever ago.
Rogers can get both. So much money coming off the books in 2027. Suck it up for one year
I don’t know why, but I think we’re getting both
DH Springer
RF Tucker
1B Vladdy
2B Bichette
C Kirk
LF Santander
3B Barger
CF Varsho
SS Gimenez
Super Sub Clement
Championship
Why hasn’t he signed yet?
Edward just sign them both
Wow to go to this sub now to this… they are a contender so bad
My mom who is 88 and I watched all year to the point I got a job working at her place as maintenance… this would be so special
Bo, Tucker and an elite arm. Do it Rogers.
I’m just hoping Santander can get back to form. Having one of bichette and/or tucker would be such a fucking problem for opposing teams to deal with when top to bottom your lineup can produce offensively and it’s not like sending your 7th to 9th batters our there to just strikeout.
It’d be such a crazy lineup to watch lol.
The Bichette situation is a bit complicated as far as his free agency goes, because both the jays and Bo expressed strong interest to make it work…
Teams are cautious to approach because they don’t want to just increase his Jays salary, and the Jays want to get the best value deal that he feels good about
Ernie said in an interview he was invited to Bo’s wedding early in the New Year. Wouldn’t be surprised if Bo is motivated to get his deal signed in December before his wedding.
Why not both.
No doubt having tucker on the team would be great. They’re talking to him because they should. There’s no guarantee Bo will sign.
After the last place finish in 2024, Schneider, the FO, and players all learned from their mistakes. A few years ago we kept hearing about “the window”. Well, there’s a tremendous opportunity in front of this team now. Signing Bo is like having a perpetual window.