If there was a lineup consisting of your favourite franchises biggest enemies, who would be on the lineup???

21 comments

1. Freddy freeman and Josh bell. Who else?

2. P – Jeremy Affeldt (deep cut – he dedicated a portion of his retirement announcement to bitch about us)

   C – Rod Barajas (turned into Mike Piazza against us)

   1B – Yordan Alvarez

   2B – Jeff McNeil (actually disliked)

   3B – Scott Rolen (some fans have forgiven him. Soft)

   SS – Orlando Arcia

   LF – Ryan Braun

   CF – Ender Inciarte (the one that got away)

   RF – JD Drew (the one that forcibly got away)

3. I vote David Wright, 3B NY Muts

4. 3b David Wright. 1b Steve Garvey. OF Larry Walker. OF Joe Carter.

5. P – Spencer Strider
   C – Lance Parish
   1B – Pete Alonso
   2B – Luis Castillo
   SS – Jose Reyes
   3B – Scott Rolen
   OF JD Drew, Joe Carter, Cody Ross

6. I could argue a Brave at basically any position.

   P – pick one from the 90’s.
   C – Javy Lopez
   1B – Freeman
   2B – Albies
   SS – no worthwhile Braves, so I’m going with Dave Concepcion because the Reds stole a couple from the Schmidt era Phillies
   3B – Chipper Jones
   RF – David Justice/Acuna
   CF – Andruw Jones
   LF – Manny Ramirez because somebody needs to be fun.

7. I feel like that fucker Matt Diaz used to always kill us.

   Same with Javier Vazquez

8. Dan Uggla comes to mind for 2B.

9. Hideki Matsui for DH. I STG to this day he was juiced to the gills and never got nailed for it.

10. Pitcher should just be any bad slopballer the 07-11 team seemed to face that would inexplicably throw a gem against that murderers row of a lineup

11. P Greg Maddux

    C Russel Martin

    1B Freddie Freeman

    2B Dan Uggla

    SS Jose Reyes

    3B Scott Rolen

    RF JD Drew

    CF Andruw Jones

    LF Joe Carter

12. Gotta be Chipper Jones at 3B.

13. P- Greg Maddox

    C- Paul Loduca

    1B- Ryan Howard’s Achilles

    2B Dan Uggla

    3B- Larry Jones

    SS- Jose Reyes

    LF- Cody Ross

    CF- Andruw Jones

    RF- Juan Soto

14. Probably not the first person to come to most people’s minds, but I feel like Josh Johnson of the Marlins always pitched really tough against the Phils.

15. Fuck AJ Burnett.

16. Carlos Delgado absolutely killed us when we was with the mets. 

17. Surprised I haven’t seen Brian Mccann on here. I remember him killing us in Philly every year.

18. Can our own players be included?

19. David Wright is rightfully at 3rd but Mike Lowell was also a Phillie killer when he was with the Marlins.

20. If you don’t have Larry Jones at short or third, double check.

21. RF Soto CF Carlos Beltran LF Brandon Nimmo 3B Scott Rolen (depending on who you ask) I’m going Chipper Jones SS Lindor 2B Dan Uggla 1B Freddie Freeman C Brian McCann P/DH Ohtani