At the risk of being a homer, I’m going with Dart.
December 31, 2025
At the risk of being a homer, I’m going with Dart.
32 comments
Good
Great
Old
Shit
Dart with dogshit weapons, multiple coaches, nothing but pure will had the best season
Edit: I’m obviously not being nor will I be objective. Dart over everybody else.
They all have proven they can be okay if they are given support around them. Id still take Dart over all of them because I’m a biased Giants fan
Based on the stats and the fact he did all that with nothing don’t even have to be a homer. It’s easily Dart. Can’t wait to see what he can do next year!
it really is dart though. in a redraft hes the first pick.
JD
Look at the saints schedule too lol it’s a joke
bias or not, it’s dart and it’s not close
I love Jaxson Dart, he is so fun to watch!
Gotta be Dart. Not sure why Sanders is even in the conversation beyond media hype.
Based on schedule / opponents, “weapons / talent on the field”, will, determination, creativity, good decisions, moxie, going w Dart.
Oddly enough I can see 3/4 of these guys being good starters in the league. Pretty good for a supposed weak qb class
I haven’t watched enough of shough to make judgement there yet tho
It’s Dart by a looooong shot. Shough has been picking it up of late. But he’s also much older than Dart and has very limited mobility. Dart would also have much better passing stats if not for that ridiculous game against the Vikings, where Kafka basically gave up before it started and made Dart play with a hand and foot tied behind his back.
Admittedly, I haven’t watched tons of Ward because the Titans are dog water. Giants are also dog water, but they’re my dog water. Overall, I was impressed by Dart’s poise and his growth more than anything. Didn’t see him make the same mistakes multiple times and he looked to grow with every rep. He had some really nice touch throws too. I think his deep ball still needs work, but his short and intermediate throws were quite nice.
Shough has been a bit better of a passer statistically, but would love to see Dart’s numbers with Nabers.
Dart blows them all away once you include his running. Statistically he has been the best rushing qb in the league based on EPA (he’s slightly below Josh Allen with 200 less plays)
Ward has been pretty terrible on the stat sheet but seems to have improved over the year and has shown flashes of what he can be.
Shedeur has been pretty bad. Not much else to say. Too early to make any conclusions.
We as a society need to stop bringing Shedeur into every single thing
Dart clears. Give him weapons and a real OC and watch him cook.
Having nabers and Skat would have been insane for him this year.
Why is the “Number of High Fives Recieved by a Referee l” stat omitted from this??
Cam Ward also leads the league for fumbles by a QB this year with 11, so that’s not great.
It really is between Shough and Dart. Shough has the wins, but Dart has been better and gives you the rushing. Even though Dart has started 3 more games, he only has 15 more pass attempts so the 80 more passing yards doesn’t really tell the story when it comes to passing.
I think it’s Dart, even though Shough has more wins, I don’t think anyone is faulting Dart for the losses if that makes sense.
Dart landed exactly where he needed to be. He’s perfect for this market.
How is this even a comparison lol. Shough has Olave, Kamara and Kellen Moore. Still only put up half of Darts total TDs. Like I’m not trying to hate on Shough what he’s doing is pretty cool but one player here is clearly out producing the rest.
And he’s doing it with less than the current ROTY favorite. It’ll be disappointing if Dart doesn’t win.
Dart would have insane passing yards if Olave was on the team.
This stats are the most balanced. If Shough started just as many games, his passer rating would be down.
Darts the type of QB where you go “ok we’re good, now let’s build around him” and that’s exactly what the Giants should do next draft.
DART 🎯
Dart without hesitation, but Shough has been a very pleasant surprise. I’m interested in seeing how he progresses in New Orleans.
Easily Dart based on this graphic alone.
Did I see that ESPN called Cam Ward “elite” in their rookie all-pro list and then say Shough would be all second team? How do they just throw Dart away when he blows these guys out of the water in an 17 game season
Dart will be in the post next year
Shough has played well, but objectively, it has to be Dart. 22 TDs is hard to beat.
Dart, he’s stuck with 💩on a shingle as his so called weapons.
32 comments
Good
Great
Old
Shit
Dart with dogshit weapons, multiple coaches, nothing but pure will had the best season
Edit: I’m obviously not being nor will I be objective. Dart over everybody else.
They all have proven they can be okay if they are given support around them. Id still take Dart over all of them because I’m a biased Giants fan
Based on the stats and the fact he did all that with nothing don’t even have to be a homer. It’s easily Dart. Can’t wait to see what he can do next year!
it really is dart though. in a redraft hes the first pick.
JD
Look at the saints schedule too lol it’s a joke
bias or not, it’s dart and it’s not close
I love Jaxson Dart, he is so fun to watch!
Gotta be Dart. Not sure why Sanders is even in the conversation beyond media hype.
Based on schedule / opponents, “weapons / talent on the field”, will, determination, creativity, good decisions, moxie, going w Dart.
Oddly enough I can see 3/4 of these guys being good starters in the league. Pretty good for a supposed weak qb class
I haven’t watched enough of shough to make judgement there yet tho
It’s Dart by a looooong shot. Shough has been picking it up of late. But he’s also much older than Dart and has very limited mobility. Dart would also have much better passing stats if not for that ridiculous game against the Vikings, where Kafka basically gave up before it started and made Dart play with a hand and foot tied behind his back.
Admittedly, I haven’t watched tons of Ward because the Titans are dog water. Giants are also dog water, but they’re my dog water. Overall, I was impressed by Dart’s poise and his growth more than anything. Didn’t see him make the same mistakes multiple times and he looked to grow with every rep. He had some really nice touch throws too. I think his deep ball still needs work, but his short and intermediate throws were quite nice.
Ward – 148 yds rushing
Dart – 455 yds rushing
Shough – 152 yds rushing
Sanders -143 yds rushing
Shough has been a bit better of a passer statistically, but would love to see Dart’s numbers with Nabers.
Dart blows them all away once you include his running. Statistically he has been the best rushing qb in the league based on EPA (he’s slightly below Josh Allen with 200 less plays)
Ward has been pretty terrible on the stat sheet but seems to have improved over the year and has shown flashes of what he can be.
Shedeur has been pretty bad. Not much else to say. Too early to make any conclusions.
We as a society need to stop bringing Shedeur into every single thing
Dart clears. Give him weapons and a real OC and watch him cook.
Having nabers and Skat would have been insane for him this year.
Why is the “Number of High Fives Recieved by a Referee l” stat omitted from this??
Cam Ward also leads the league for fumbles by a QB this year with 11, so that’s not great.
It really is between Shough and Dart. Shough has the wins, but Dart has been better and gives you the rushing. Even though Dart has started 3 more games, he only has 15 more pass attempts so the 80 more passing yards doesn’t really tell the story when it comes to passing.
I think it’s Dart, even though Shough has more wins, I don’t think anyone is faulting Dart for the losses if that makes sense.
Dart landed exactly where he needed to be. He’s perfect for this market.
How is this even a comparison lol. Shough has Olave, Kamara and Kellen Moore. Still only put up half of Darts total TDs. Like I’m not trying to hate on Shough what he’s doing is pretty cool but one player here is clearly out producing the rest.
And he’s doing it with less than the current ROTY favorite. It’ll be disappointing if Dart doesn’t win.
Dart would have insane passing yards if Olave was on the team.
This stats are the most balanced. If Shough started just as many games, his passer rating would be down.
Darts the type of QB where you go “ok we’re good, now let’s build around him” and that’s exactly what the Giants should do next draft.
DART 🎯
Dart without hesitation, but Shough has been a very pleasant surprise. I’m interested in seeing how he progresses in New Orleans.
Easily Dart based on this graphic alone.
Did I see that ESPN called Cam Ward “elite” in their rookie all-pro list and then say Shough would be all second team? How do they just throw Dart away when he blows these guys out of the water in an 17 game season
Dart will be in the post next year
Shough has played well, but objectively, it has to be Dart. 22 TDs is hard to beat.
Dart, he’s stuck with 💩on a shingle as his so called weapons.