I love Pauly but I have to imagine anyone who picks him over Big Hurt is simply too young to have actually watched prime Frank
On the All-Time team? Yeah Konerko definitely gets left off
This feels like a pretty egregious example of using ragebait to boost engagement.
Who the fuck is Jim Essian?
So these guys know nothing about the White Sox. Their list is nuts.
C: Jim Essian (Who? 9 career WAR with only 4.2 for the Sox? Not Carlton Fisk, who produced 30 WAR for the White Sox, or AJ?)
1B: Thomas
2B: Durham (Nellie Fox, duh)
SS: Jose Valentin (I like Jose, but… Luke Appling with 2749 career hits and a career .310 average?)
3B: Robin Ventura
OF: Dan Pasqua, Mike Cameron, Ivan Calderom (Seriously? Not Ordonez, Carlos Lee, Lance Johnson, Shoeless Freaking Joe?)
DH: Lamar Johnson (Who? Not Harold Baines?)
No disrespect, but Dan Pasqua being on an “all-time” list already shows this is just rage-bait nonsense.
Must be weird AI slop
C – fisk
1B – thomas
2B – collins/fox
Ss – aparicio/appling
3b – ventura
OF – shoeless joe, minoso, baines?
Something like that
Let me guess, this is your article?
Abreu and Frank are better than Paulie
Heavy.com guy is my favorite poster
It’s worth emphasizing for anyone who didn’t read the article or see the MLB Network segment…
The talking point here was *all-time favorite White Sox* not *best* all time White Sox. It wasn’t just meant to be a list of who accumulated the most WAR for the Sox at each position.
Frank is hall of famer Konerko is at best hall of ok
Seems this was a “remember some guys” exercise, tbf
14 comments
I love Pauly but I have to imagine anyone who picks him over Big Hurt is simply too young to have actually watched prime Frank
On the All-Time team? Yeah Konerko definitely gets left off
This feels like a pretty egregious example of using ragebait to boost engagement.
Who the fuck is Jim Essian?
So these guys know nothing about the White Sox. Their list is nuts.
C: Jim Essian (Who? 9 career WAR with only 4.2 for the Sox? Not Carlton Fisk, who produced 30 WAR for the White Sox, or AJ?)
1B: Thomas
2B: Durham (Nellie Fox, duh)
SS: Jose Valentin (I like Jose, but… Luke Appling with 2749 career hits and a career .310 average?)
3B: Robin Ventura
OF: Dan Pasqua, Mike Cameron, Ivan Calderom (Seriously? Not Ordonez, Carlos Lee, Lance Johnson, Shoeless Freaking Joe?)
DH: Lamar Johnson (Who? Not Harold Baines?)
No disrespect, but Dan Pasqua being on an “all-time” list already shows this is just rage-bait nonsense.
Must be weird AI slop
C – fisk
1B – thomas
2B – collins/fox
Ss – aparicio/appling
3b – ventura
OF – shoeless joe, minoso, baines?
Something like that
Let me guess, this is your article?
Abreu and Frank are better than Paulie
Heavy.com guy is my favorite poster
It’s worth emphasizing for anyone who didn’t read the article or see the MLB Network segment…
The talking point here was *all-time favorite White Sox* not *best* all time White Sox. It wasn’t just meant to be a list of who accumulated the most WAR for the Sox at each position.
Frank is hall of famer Konerko is at best hall of ok
Seems this was a “remember some guys” exercise, tbf
I thought their lists were goofy
It’s not all time best
It’s all time favorite