I don’t fully agree with this list

32 comments
  1. Soto is younger than some of those “young stars on their way.”

    Also, why not Harper, at least on that borderline tier?

  2. Bump up machado, freeman, and goldy.

    I love Soto, but still a little early in his career to say for sure.

  3. I don’t think any of the probably in guys get in except machado. Snell? Insane

    I can see arguments for Cole and Goldschmidt but it’s far from given

  4. Some people really underestimate just how hard it is to make the Hall of Fame. This isn’t basketball.

  5. Blake Snell is in no way “probably in.”
    He’s 33 and only has about 26 fWAR. I’d say it’s way more likely than not he doesn’t get in.

  6. Elly De La Cruz is over hyped. Incredible athlete but needs to get a lot better at baseball to even sniff the HOF

  7. I think Freddie and Jram will be first ballot depending on the class of their first year of eligibility

  8. Freeman should be close to first ballot.

    9x all star, MVP, big time postseason performer , WS MVP, 3 rings, close to 400 HRs . Close to 70 WAR

  9. Jose Ramirez staying in Cleveland for a lifetime probably just sealed his way in. Not many players stay with the same team anymore.

  10. How is Jansen “in” but Chapman is only “probably” and Kimbrell isn’t even mentioned

  11. Where is Harper? Should at least be borderline. 2x MVP, ROTY, 8x All Star, 4x Silver Slugger, NLCS MVP. He really just needs the counting stats and he’s in.

  12. Stupid list. Freddie is a 1st ballot guy. That’s as far as I got before I gave up on this shit list

Leave a Reply