🚨Giants Hire Matt Nagy As Offensive Coordinator

49 comments

1. Grade the hire of Matt Nagy? A, B, C, D or F

2. In your opinion, who is out there that would have been better than Nagy for OC?

3. What a disaster! Well this will be the same “what if” Giants

4. He fits the mold. He's got a ton of experience. He's a better OC than HC. The chiefs have had next to no weapons and a mediocre at best OL.

5. All the great candidates out there, this is NOT what I wanted to see as the OC.

6. I'm going to throw a crazy idea out there, so hear me out: Maybe we shouldn't overreact to the news?
   Nagy's play calling has been on limited display since his days as Mitchell Trubisky's HC in Chicago. He gave up play calling duties in Chicago. He's rarely called plays in KC. He may be able to develop Dart into a more Mahomes-esque player.
   I'm not saying I love the hire. But, let's trust the process and let Harbaugh cook.

7. Most of John’s assistant coaches don’t transition into Head Coaches. Know why? Because they’re not that good!! Horrible choices for DC AND OC!!

8. we hired Harbaugh everybody was happy now the coaching staff he's bringing in fans are not happy when we got him everybody trusted him so let's just trust who he hires maybe this hire benefits dart so let's just watch as fans give the hire a chance.

9. Worst thing the Coach has done so far. C-

10. Didn’t Andy Reid call the plays at KC?

11. MATT WHO..? This guy is second fidel. Here ..we go..another Dabol . The office of coordinator " fake". Andy Reid gave this guy a resume and ofcourse we hire him! 🙄

12. Boy… everyone here is a coach….😮😢😅

13. The Chiefs didn’t have all the weapons they had in the beginning either

14. You dont know what really happened with Eric bienemy. It was a much "bigger situation than football" Do your research be talking about "certain topics". 🏴

15. It's really not that bad

16. Oh noooo!!!! Don't like the hire.

17. Kubaic or Kingsbury would have been SO much better options.
    This makes me want to 🤮🤮.

18. MAN IM DONE MATT FUCKING NAGGY THIS IS BULLSHIT 🤦🏾‍♂️

19. He has 2 Superbowl rings

20. Smh Nagy gonna be 👍🏿 👌🏿 Kingsbury too gimmicky

21. Lost a lot of trust in Harbaugh with this one

22. Same Tree .. Same System .. An Upgraded More Experienced Mike Kafka

23. Did the Chiefs go to the Super Bowl last year?

24. Let’s remember, I don’t think Matt Nagy was not high on Harbaughs list as OC!! Also any play caller needs the players to execute!! I do not know Nagys players under his relm but let’s remover that Harbaugh had other OC he wanted but they didn’t want big blue for various reasons

25. You guys gotta cut this foolishness smh you can’t say you’re 100% on board with John Harbaugh and you believe in him and then criticize the move lol obviously he feels like this will work here or else he would not have made the hire. If we believe in the new Coach and the new system, just let him cook. Simple.

26. At this point in time, who would you have hired?

27. What weapons did he have though? Eric B had a prime Hill and Kelce.

28. How can you blame Nagy for a shitty offense, then say Andy Reid called the plays?

29. It’s not that bad Damm

30. Would have preferred Kingsbury but Honestly i don't hate this hire. If we hired him as HC, Id be furious but he's had success at OC and learned from some great coaches like Andy Reid. Id rate this somewhere around a B-/C+ I think we could have done worse.

31. Great hire !!!
    Go Big Blue !!!

32. Anyone who hates this hire is really just butthurt that we didn’t get Monken or Kingsbury.. this is a damn good hire! He will get the best out of our TEs. Dude won the NFC North with Mitch Frighin Trubiski! Then was cursed with having Justin Fields as a starter. In his 2 Super Bowl wins the Chiefs scored 38 points against arguably the best defense in the history of the league against the Eagles and 25 points against the 49ers who also had a great defense! Ignorance is the only reason you can “hate” this hire

33. First mistake…unless he has something new to show us

34. Talented and smart offensive coach with play calling experience and pelts on the wall.

35. Bad hire. Not even KC wanted Nagy…

36. Went from Awesome with Harbaugh, ehhhh with the DC and a big wtf with the OC… not looking good. Everytime the Giants take a big step forward, its always 3 back.

37. He couldn't make a decent offense with Patrick Mahomes as his QB. Yes I know KC had some serious deficiencies on offense, like a bad RB room and an inconsistent WR corp. But IMO this just says Nagy can't make do with what he's handed, he can't make lemonade out of lemons (and a 4 win team is going to have a lot of lemons).

38. As a bears fan I'm
    So sorry get ready for screen passes on 3rd and 20 and no down field plays

39. Smh the only person i didnt want

40. F. Wtf. What happened to Davis Webb?

41. C

42. CRASHOUT 😂😂😂😂

43. Am I the only one that believed in Kafka? Kafka gotten Jones a playoff win and had Dart putting up points every week with zero Wrs, bottom mid O Line and mid rbs….

44. I dont HATE this hire. Nagy isnt terrible, in the world of coaching, i dont know a lot of names but i know Nagy. However, im not so sure this is a good fit at all.

    Especially with Davis Webb and Kliff Kingsbury available. Kingsbury felt soooo good with his preferred scheme.

    Im gonna trust the Harbaugh process here. I mean, he knows wtf hes doing more than I or any of us EVER could. So lets find out what Harbaugh saw.

45. Last I remember of Nagy is when he was the victim of the double doink by Cody Parkey.

46. Marshall Green calm down LOL it's okay LOL where is out was the reason why they didn't hire kliff Kingsbury and its tough to get along with him if that was your second choice now with the Chiefs ain't you going to get on Andy Reid also he was calling the plays plus look what they had to work with you got an old Travis Kelce mahomes was hurt and the receivers was in and out a matter of fact Worthy and the troubled one didn't even play against the Giants remember all nagy did against the Giants was design the plays Andy reid called them out he never really had no quarterback in Chicago and he still won 12 games

47. C

48. John harbaugh had to have asked Andy r e i d about n a g y and you know it will have to be positive all he wouldn't have had hired him

49. Word is out that Kingsbury is hard to get along with even tiki Barber did some digging in and found that out.I also heard about it