Getty
The Philadelphia Phillies are chasing greatness in 2025, and Kyle Schwarber sits at the center of it all. In the final year of his contract, he has never swung the bat better, carried more presence, or delivered more value. If the Phillies want to keep their championship window wide open, they must bring Schwarber back—no matter the cost.
Schwarber’s Career Season
Even in a lineup stacked with stars, Schwarber has stolen the spotlight. He owns a .937 OPS and a 152 OPS+, both career highs, and he’s dominating pitchers across the league. He leads the National League with 53 home runs and tops all of baseball with 128 RBIs. Add 106 runs scored, 104 walks, and a career-high 4.8 WAR, and you see a player who fuels victories, not just box scores.
What makes this season even more impressive is the balance he’s created. Once labeled a “home run or bust” hitter, Schwarber now produces in every way. He’s ripped 21 doubles, two triples, and even swiped 10 bases. At 32, instead of slowing down, he looks like a player entering a second prime.
ESPN insiders Paul Hembekides and Buster Olney recently broke down Schwarber’s free-agent market. Their predictions shocked fans. Olney believes the Phillies may need to pay $35 million per year to keep him. That’s a hefty figure for a DH in his thirties, but Philadelphia must step up and match it.
The Price of Letting Schwarber Go
The Cubs, Nationals, and Red Sox all let Schwarber walk, and each one regretted the move. He brings more than numbers; he’s the team’s heartbeat in the clubhouse and a fan favorite who connects with Philadelphia’s passionate base like few players ever have. His teammates rave about his leadership, his work ethic, and his ability to shine in big moments.
The Phillies can’t gamble with that kind of presence. They’re firmly inside a contention window, and losing Schwarber would create a self-inflicted wound that derails momentum. With Nick Castellanos’ $20 million deal partially clearing in 2026 and completely off the books in 2027, the Phillies hold enough financial flexibility to sign Schwarber. John Middleton has never hesitated to spend to keep a winner intact, and no case is stronger than Schwarber’s.
Philadelphia thrives on Schwarber’s presence on and off the field. He defines the team’s power-driven identity and playoff swagger. Fans flood Citizens Bank Park because they expect Schwarber moments—towering home runs, curtain calls, and postseason fireworks. That energy fuels wins, boosts revenue, and gives the Phillies a swagger that free agency can’t replace.
Free agency will bring competition, but the Phillies have the inside track. Schwarber has spoken openly about his love for Philadelphia, and the city has embraced him right back. If the front office backs that connection with a strong offer, they’ll secure one of the most impactful bats in baseball for years to come.
The message is simple: let other teams chase a cheaper option. The Phillies already have their guy, and his name is Kyle Schwarber. Pay the man and keep the championship window alive.
Alvin Garcia Born in Puerto Rico, Alvin Garcia is a sports writer for Heavy.com who focuses on MLB. His work has appeared on FanSided, LWOS, NewsBreak, Athlon Sports, and Yardbarker, covering mostly MLB. More about Alvin Garcia
More Heavy on Phillies
Loading more stories