Image courtesy of © Ken Blaze-Imagn Images
When the Minnesota Twins traded Jorge Polanco to the Seattle Mariners before the 2024 season, it felt like more than a typical baseball move. It was a signal about the organization’s financial direction and how the front office would be forced to operate in the coming years. Now, as the team enters another uncertain offseason, that trade may once again serve as a blueprint for what is to come.
The Ownership Caused Payroll Problem
Heading into the 2026 season, the Twins find themselves in a familiar financial position. The organization has just under $100 million tied to next year’s roster if all arbitration-eligible players are brought back. That number alone might seem unreasonable for a team with postseason aspirations, and it provides a challenge in what it represents. There is speculation that ownership may aim to keep payroll lower than last season’s $120-140 million after a disappointing 2025 season saw revenues and attendance both drop sharply.
The connection between attendance and spending is hard to ignore. Fans were slow to return to Target Field after the team flopped at the end of 2024, leading to the lowest attended season in Target Field history. For many, the enthusiasm and optimism that followed the 2023 Wild Card Series win over Toronto have faded. That playoff run was supposed to be the start of something bigger, and the $160 million payroll that year reflected a commitment to winning. But the Pohlads chose to “right-size” spending the following winter, trimming roughly $30 million from the budget.
That shift in philosophy continues to define how the Twins operate. Rather than expanding payroll to maintain a competitive roster, the front office has had to find ways to retool within financial limits. This makes every dollar and every trade critical to sustaining competitiveness.
Revisiting the Jorge Polanco Trade
The decision to trade Jorge Polanco was both financially and strategically motivated. Polanco was set to make $10.5 million in 2024 with a club option for 2025, making him one of the Twins’ more expensive players. When the team sent him to Seattle, it not only saved about $6 million in salary but also reshaped the roster in several subtle ways.
In return, the Twins received right-handed reliever Justin Topa, veteran starter Anthony DeSclafani, and prospects Gabriel Gonzalez and Darren Bowen. DeSclafani’s injury-shortened season limited his impact, but Topa provided a solid bullpen performance in 2025. The real long-term value from the deal came from Gonzalez, a young outfielder who quickly emerged as one of the organization’s most exciting prospects. He finished 2025 as one of the top hitters in the entire system and could debut in Minnesota as early as 2026.
While the trade did not immediately transform the major league roster, it reflected a pattern the Twins may follow again: saving short-term payroll while acquiring controllable talent and upside for the future. The move allowed the front office to bring in Carlos Santana as a stopgap at first base, but it also highlighted the team’s limitations when it cannot spend freely to fill gaps.
What It Means for the 2026 Offseason
The lessons from the Polanco trade may be more relevant than ever as the Twins prepare for another critical winter. The front office will need to find creative solutions to improve the roster without increasing payroll. The most significant needs are clear: a consistent first baseman, more power from the designated hitter spot, and reinforcements for a bullpen that saw five players depart at last year’s trade deadline.
With ownership likely lowering payroll, trades may once again become the primary tool for roster improvement. Players like Ryan Jeffers, Joe Ryan, and Pablo Lopez could become candidates to be moved in exchange for lower-cost options with upside. The front office has shown it can find value in unexpected places, but it will need to do so again if the team hopes to stay competitive in the American League Central.
The Polanco trade showed that the Twins can find future assets even while cutting costs, but it also came at a price. The excitement that followed 2023 has faded, and fan patience is wearing thin. If the front office can blend financial restraint with on-field results, they may yet steer the team back toward contention. But if the upcoming offseason feels like another exercise in cost-cutting, the echoes of that Polanco trade will only grow louder in Twins Territory.
Will the Twins follow the Polanco trade route this winter? Leave a comment and start the discussion.