The Cincinnati Reds face a critical decision regarding pitcher Nick Martinez as the World Series concludes and free agency begins. Martinez, who had a standout 2024 season with a 3.10 ERA, experienced a downturn in 2025 with a 4.45 ERA and a higher rate of hits and home runs. After having shown reliability as a pitcher over the years, the Reds must evaluate his future role on the team and whether his contract demands match his contributions. With several starting pitchers lined up for the Reds, Martinez’s potential as a backup option or hybrid reliever makes his return uncertain. His past performance and positioning in the free agency market will influence both his and the Reds’ decisions moving forward.
By the NumbersMartinez recorded a career-high 165.2 innings pitched in 2025.In 2025, he allowed 158 hits and 22 home runs, with a walk rate that more than doubled from previous seasons. Yes, But
Despite his drop in performance, Martinez’s reliability over multiple seasons and ability to contribute both as a starter and in the bullpen makes him a valuable asset. However, the high cost of bringing him back may outweigh his current on-field contributions, especially if other teams view him as a starting option.
State of PlayMartinez made 26 starts and appeared in 14 games as a reliever in 2025.The Reds are currently assessing their pitching depth and potential roles for the upcoming season. What’s Next
The Reds will need to make a decision on Martinez as free agency opens, weighing the benefits of retaining him against the likelihood of higher offers from other teams looking for a starting pitcher. Negotiations could be impacted by market interest and team needs closer to spring training.
Bottom Line
Nick Martinez represents a nuanced decision for the Reds: weighing his past reliability against a difficult 2025 and existing competition for pitching roles. The team must carefully evaluate whether the investment in his return aligns with their broader roster strategy and pitching needs.