Baseball America recently released a comprehensive look back at every organization’s top prospects dating to 1983, the first year it began ranking talent across the league. For the Minnesota Twins, the list provides an opportunity to reflect on the organization’s long history of developing and scouting talent. Some names have become franchise legends, while others faded before ever reaching Target Field or the Metrodome. Together, they tell the story of how the Twins have developed talent for more than 40 years.
Minnesota Twins’ Best Prospects
As part of the retrospective, Baseball America created a “Mount Rushmore of WAR” for each organization. These are players who ranked as top prospects for that team and went on to accumulate the highest career Wins Above Replacement in the major leagues, even if that success came elsewhere. For the Twins, that list included Joe Mauer, Kirby Puckett, Byron Buxton, and Jay Bell.
Mauer is the most iconic homegrown player of his generation. The former number one overall pick in 2001 was a local legend before he even signed, and his career lived up to the hype. Mauer became the face of the franchise, winning three batting titles, an MVP award, and three Gold Gloves while transitioning from catcher to first base late in his career. His 55.2 fWAR with the Twins cements his status among the greatest players in team history.
Puckett’s arrival in the mid-1980s helped shape a golden era for Minnesota baseball. He combined leadership, charisma, and elite performance at the plate and in center field. A six-time Silver Slugger and six-time Gold Glove winner, Puckett’s postseason heroics in 1987 and 1991 are the stuff of Twins legend. Before his career was tragically cut short, he was one of baseball’s true stars and one of the most successful top prospects the organization ever developed.
Buxton represents the modern version of that elite homegrown talent. Once Baseball America’s number one overall prospect, he has flashed game-changing ability on both sides of the ball when healthy. Injuries have prevented him from reaching his full potential. Still, his combination of elite defense, power, and speed keeps him in the conversation as one of the most talented players to ever wear a Twins uniform.
The fourth name on the list, Bell, might surprise some Twins fans. Bell was the eighth overall pick in the 1984 MLB Draft out of high school, and while he never played a game for Minnesota, his inclusion highlights the ripple effects of prospect development. In August 1985, Bell was traded to Cleveland as part of the deal that brought Bert Blyleven back to Minnesota. Blyleven, of course, played a pivotal role in the 1987 World Series championship. Bell went on to enjoy an impressive big-league career, finishing with 37.9 fWAR, two All-Star appearances, a Gold Glove, a Silver Slugger, and multiple seasons of down-ballot MVP consideration.
Worst Big-League WAR
While some prospects became franchise cornerstones, others failed to meet lofty expectations. Among the Twins’ former top prospects, Bryan Oelkers, Billy Beane, and Dave McCarty posted the lowest big-league WAR totals.
Oelkers was Minnesota’s first-round pick in 1982, a left-handed pitcher out of the University of Illinois. He made his debut in 1983 but struggled with command and never established himself in the rotation, finishing his brief career with a -1.7 fWAR.
Beane’s name will always be associated with his front office success more than his playing career. Drafted by the Mets in the first round of the 1980 draft, he was a highly touted outfielder who could not translate his tools into consistent big-league results. His -1.7 fWAR as a player is a far cry from the analytical revolution he later spearheaded as an executive with the Oakland Athletics.
McCarty, the third overall pick in the 1991 draft, had the type of smooth right-handed swing scouts dream about. Unfortunately, it never translated into sustained major league success. He bounced around several organizations and ended his career with a -2.6 fWAR, the lowest among the Twins’ former top prospects.
Names You Likely Forgot
Scrolling through Baseball America’s list also unearths names that may only ring a faint bell for longtime Twins followers. Will Bankes, Adam Johnson, and Rich Garces all appeared as top prospects during their respective eras but never made the impact many expected. Johnson, in particular, was a notable case as the second overall pick in 2000, ahead of future stars like Chase Utley and Adam Wainwright. His career unraveled quickly due to injuries and inconsistency. Garces, meanwhile, eventually found success elsewhere as a reliever for the Boston Red Sox, and Bankes’ name has long since faded into minor league obscurity.
Two former top Twins prospects, Steve Gasser and Johnny Ard, never reached the majors. Gasser, a right-handed pitcher, was a second-round pick in 1985 but struggled with injuries that derailed his path. Ard, a first-round selection in 1988, had a powerful arm but could not find the command needed to move through the system. Both serve as reminders of how unpredictable prospect development can be, even for highly regarded talents.
Looking Back (and Forward)
Baseball America’s retrospective offers a fascinating window into the Twins’ player development journey. For every Mauer or Puckett, there have been players who never realized their promise. Yet across four decades of rankings, one consistent thread emerges: Minnesota has a long history of identifying talent capable of becoming elite at the major league level. Whether those players wore a Twins uniform for one day or a decade, their stories all began in the same place, as prospects with big dreams and the potential to shape baseball history. Now the Twins hope Walker Jenkins becomes the next prospect to join their Mount Rushmore.
What stands out about Baseball America’s list? Leave a comment and start the discussion.
Are you interested in Twins history? Then check out the Minnesota Twins Players Project, a community-driven project to discover and collect great information on every player to wear a Twins uniform!