The Phillies are entering a pivotal offseason. With the potential return of Kyle Schwarber still uncertain, the front office is reportedly exploring contingency options. According to multiple reports, Philadelphia will pursue All-Star outfielder Kyle Tucker if Schwarber does not re-sign.
Tucker, who spent the 2025 season with the Chicago Cubs, turned in another strong campaign — slashing .266/.377/.464 with 22 home runs, 73 RBIs, and 25 stolen bases. The 28-year-old’s combination of power, speed, and plate discipline has made him one of baseball’s most well-rounded corner outfielders.
From Philadelphia’s perspective, Tucker brings multiple advantages that fit both their short- and long-term goals:
Power-speed blend: 22 homers and 25 steals in 2025
On-base excellence: A .377 OBP would add another dependable bat to the top or middle of the Phillies’ lineup.
Gold Glove defense: Tucker’s range and arm strength would dramatically improve a Phillies outfield that struggled defensively for much of the past two seasons.
Age and upside: At just 28, Tucker is entering his prime — a key factor for a club built around veterans approaching their 30s and beyond.
While it might not be the most popular decision to let Schwarber walk, signing Tucker might give John Middleton and an aging Phillies core the most bang for their buck. Tucker is six years younger, plays right field — checking off a major roster box — and provides elite defense to go with consistent offensive production. It’s a move that could change the Phillies’ lineup without sacrificing star power.
Of course, the pursuit isn’t without risk. Tucker’s batting average (.266) isn’t elite, and his expected free-agent price tag will be significant. But unlike Schwarber, who’s primarily a designated hitter at this stage, Tucker’s all-around game could provide greater roster flexibility and defensive stability.
If Schwarber re-signs, the Phillies will gladly welcome back one of the clubhouse’s emotional anchors. But if not, pivoting to Tucker would represent a savvy balance of present-day competitiveness and future planning.
In short, the Phillies’ rumored interest in Kyle Tucker isn’t just a backup plan — it’s a potential opportunity to reshape the club’s identity with a younger, more complete star ready to anchor right field for years to come.