Detroit Tigers outfielder Kerry Carpenter (30) tagged out by Boston Red Sox second base David Hamilton (17) (Image via Imagn) The Detroit Tigers may be headed toward one of the most closely watched decisions of the 2025-26 MLB offseason, as a major prediction from The Athletic’s Jim Bowden suggests the franchise could move two-time Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal in a blockbuster deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers. The proposed return features a significant haul, led by starting pitcher Tyler Glasnow, signaling a scenario where Detroit prioritizes long-term value and depth over holding onto its ace for one final season before free agency.
What the Detroit Tigers Would Receive in Proposed Deal
Former MLB general manager Jim Bowden laid out his prediction clearly, stating, “The Tigers trade Tarik Skubal to the Dodgers for starting pitchers Tyler Glasnow and Emmet Sheehan and outfielder Zyhir Hope.” As credited to original writer Matt Sullivan, this projection has ignited widespread debate around the league given the magnitude of talent involved.
Proposed Trade Package
Here’s a full breakdown of the deal Bowden projects:Detroit Tigers ReceivePlayer Details Tyler Glasnow Under club control through 2027; dominant 1.69 ERA in six 2025 postseason appearances Emmet Sheehan Age 26; under club control through 2029; posted 2.82 ERA in 15 appearances (12 starts) during 2025 Zyhir Hope Highly rated outfield prospect who could eventually form a trio with Riley Greene and Max Clark 
Tarik Skubal (Image via Getty)
Los Angeles Dodgers ReceivePlayer Details Tarik Skubal Two-time Cy Young winner; under contract through 2026; considered the best pitcher in baseball
Why the Detroit Tigers Might Consider Moving Tarik Skubal
Skubal remains Detroit Tigers’ best offseason trade chip, and his impending free agency after the 2026 season makes the timing of any potential deal critical. Moving Tarik Skubal now could maximize return before the price diminishes.
Key Factors Driving the Rumor
• Skubal’s elite performance means he would fetch a massive package • Tigers risk losing him for nothing after 2026 • Glasnow provides two more years of team control compared to Skubal’s one • Sheehan adds another reliable arm for the rotation • Hope provides long-term upside in the outfield • Jackson Jobe’s uncertain health entering 2026 increases need for pitching depth
How the Return Strengthens Detroit
Bowden’s projected package offers both short-term stability and long-term promise. Glasnow, when healthy, has demonstrated top-tier ability, punctuated by his dominant 2025 postseason run. Adding Sheehan gives Detroit another proven, controllable starter, helping solidify the rotation for 2026 and beyond.Hope stands out as a potential cornerstone outfielder. Pairing him with Riley Greene and Max Clark could give Detroit one of the most dynamic young outfields in the league.
The Emotional Weight of Trading an Ace
Despite the strong return, moving Skubal would not sit easily with Detroit Tigers fans. As noted in the original report, the idea of parting with a two-time Cy Young winner makes any trade feel difficult to accept. Even with a substantial haul, it’s challenging to view any return as fully equal to what Skubal brings on the mound.However, there’s also the possibility that the Tigers could revisit Skubal in free agency next offseason, meaning a trade wouldn’t necessarily close the door on a future reunion.
Long-Term Outlook for Detroit
If Bowden’s prediction materializes, Detroit gains: • Two rotation-ready starters • A top outfield prospect • Greater 2026 pitching depth • Flexibility heading into the post-Skubal eraFor a team still shaping its long-term core, this package offers a realistic balance between immediate competitiveness and organizational future.
My Final Thoughts On This Mock Trade
The potential trade of Tarik Skubal to the Dodgers stands out as one of the most defining storylines of the offseason. The Tigers will have a difficult decision to make, but the proposed return outlined by Jim Bowden provides a blueprint that could help Detroit build both for 2026 and the years beyond.Also read: MLB trade rumors: New York Yankees predicted to make bold move for $6 million second base to force Jazz Chisholm Jr. into surprising position switchIf the Tigers choose to move their ace, this projected deal may be one of the few offers capable of softening the blow, while still setting the franchise on a strong trajectory moving forward.