Tyler Soderstrom would be the perfect fit for the Brewers in left field. He just turned 24, has four years of club control remaining, and is coming off a breakout season in which he was worth roughly 4 wins above replacement. Perhaps,most importantly, he has the type of power that the Brewers’ outfield lacked last season, and he could grow into more. In the aftermath of the Brewers’ NLCS loss to the Dodgers, the lack of over-the-fence power the team showed in 2025 has been a major talking point. Even manager Pat Murphy chimed in at the Winter Meetings.
“I hope we are this year,” Murphy said, when prompted by a reporter stating that the Brewers weren’t considered a home run team in 2025.
Soderstrom was the Athletics’ first-round pick in 2020. He entered their player development system as a catcher, but his offense has taken off now that he is no longer behind the plate. The 2025 season was the first time in his professional career that Soderstrom didn’t catch at all, and he had a huge season. Soderstrom’s 25 home runs would have been the second-most on the Brewers after Christian Yelich’s 29, and his maximum exit velocity of 114 MPH would have been second to William Contreras’s 114.1. Soderstrom has above-average bat speed and a solid hard-hit percentage, and while he chases more than most Brewers hitters, he makes above-average in-zone contact. At 6-foot-2 and 200 pounds, the power here is real.
Defensively, Soderstrom initially moved to first base, but he wasn’t very good there. When the A’s promoted eventual Rookie of the Year Nick Kurtz, they moved Soderstrom to left field, where he excelled. Soderstrom has a strong arm and recorded the second-most outfield assists in the American League, with 11. Even more impressive was the range Soderstrom displayed: he finished 5th among all left fielders in Statcast’s OAA and was a finalist for the Gold Glove, losing to Steven Kwan.
While the Gold Glove nod likely over-hyped his defense somewhat, Soderstrom’s combination of power and positive defensive contribution is enticing. Here are the players who had more home runs in 2025 and a more positive defensive impact in the outfield than Soderstrom: Aaron Judge, Julio Rodriguez, Corbin Carroll, Pete Crow-Armstrong, Cody Bellinger, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Andy Pages. Soderstrom will need to prove he can do this again for it to feel like he belongs on a list with those names, but that’s an exciting group of comps.
The A’s almost certainly aren’t looking to move Soderstrom, so the Brewers would likely need to overpay to acquire him. But on the heels of the Isaac Collins trade, the Brewers should look to make another roster-consolidating move, turning multiple player assets into a higher-performing player to maximize the output on the major-league roster. If you are going to overpay for a player, a 24-year-old ascending power hitter who plays solid defense is the type to target. Consider Bellinger, who placed above Soderstrom in defensive value and hit four more home runs last season. He could sign a contract for more than $150 million this winter, and he’s already 30 years old.
For a cost-controlled, power-hitting outfielder who can field his position, what should the Brewers be willing to offer? Like everyone else in the league, the A’s have reportedly been looking to acquire controllable starting pitching. Would Robert Gasser or Logan Henderson get the conversation started? The Brewers could include an additional arm from the upper minor leagues, such as Tate Kuehner or KC Hunt, then complete the offer by dealing from their surplus of corner infielders and include Mike Boeve or Brock Wilken. Acquiring good young players isn’t cheap, but the Brewers have the depth in their system to make a trade like this if they want to.
Tyler Soderstrom isn’t a star right now. He was dislodged from his position and played in the shadow of his award-winning teammate last year. However, another year removed from the stress and grind of catching could change that. The Brewers should trade for Soderstrom before he reaches that next level, and maybe they can reach new highs together.