Image courtesy of © Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images
The Minnesota Twins’ competitive window has felt perpetually cracked open for the better part of a decade. Rarely slammed shut, never fully open. At the center of that uneasy balance sits Byron Buxton, the face of the franchise and its most complicated variable. Buxton has three years remaining on his team-friendly extension, and as things stand today, there is no clear indication that Minnesota will be a true World Series contender at any point during that stretch. That reality makes the next few seasons feel more like an evaluation period than an opportunity.
Still, baseball has a way of humbling certainty. Teams that look mediocre in March can find themselves dogpiling in October. Rosters that feel one move away can collapse overnight. Buxton’s presence alone keeps the Twins relevant, and his ceiling remains higher than almost any player in the organization. The question is whether the timing ever aligns.
Rumors are already unavoidable. If the Twins fall out of contention again and pivot further toward selling veteran pieces, Buxton’s name will surface in trade conversations. He holds a no-trade clause, but that protection does not mean immovability. Buxton is now in his early 30s, with a lengthy injury history and a finite number of games left in his career. The chance to play meaningful October baseball elsewhere could be tempting, especially if Minnesota’s direction becomes clearer by midseason.
Here’s a look at the next three seasons, what it could mean for the Twins, and how the Byron Buxton winning window is shrinking.
2026: Running It Back and Hoping
The most likely outcome for 2026 is familiarity. The Twins appear poised to run back much of last year’s roster and hope for organic improvement from their young core. FanGraphs’ initial projection of an 82-80 record paints the picture perfectly. Competitive, relevant, but far from secure.
Top prospects are waiting in the wings, and many are expected to debut during the season. Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez, and Gabriel Gonzalez all finished at Triple-A last season. That said, rookies are supplements, not saviors. Expecting them to replace established production is rarely realistic. For Buxton, 2026 represents another season of carrying disproportionate weight, both on the field and in how the franchise is perceived nationally.
2027: Chaos Creates Opportunity
The 2027 season may never resemble a normal year. A looming labor dispute brings a strong chance of a lockout that could delay the start of the season. If negotiations drag on, MLB may shorten the schedule and expand the postseason to preserve revenue. That kind of chaos can flatten the playing field.
More playoff teams mean more paths into October. For a club like Minnesota, that matters. The Twins saw this happen in 2020 during the COVID-shortened season. A hot month or two could be enough. By then, the young pitchers, like Mick Abel and Kendry Rojas, acquired in recent years, may be ready for the spotlight. Arms that currently feel theoretical could become the backbone of a playoff run. In October, structure matters less than momentum, and weird things tend to happen.
2028: Swan Song or Turning Point
The 2028 season could represent Buxton’s swan song in a Twins uniform. He has been clear about wanting to be a Twin for life, but the next three years will test that commitment on both sides. If his performance continues to resemble his 2025 campaign, extensions could remain on the table. If not, the cold reality of aging curves will loom.
Coming out of a potential lockout, this is the ideal time for Minnesota to push more aggressively. A young core featuring Jenkins, Rodriguez, Luke Keaschall, and Kaelen Culpepper could be ready to emerge. Supporting that group properly might finally align Buxton’s timeline with a legitimate window of opportunity.
The Twins do not need to choose between rebuilding and contending just yet, but they are running out of time to avoid that decision. Buxton’s contract provides flexibility, leverage, and pressure all at once. Whether Minnesota capitalizes on that window or watches it quietly close will define the next era of Twins baseball.
Do you believe the Twins can build a true contender before Buxton’s contract runs out, or is a difficult decision inevitable? Leave a comment and start the discussion.