The pitching trade market has officially gone off the rails, unexpectedly positioning the Minnesota Twins at the center of off-season speculation—again.
Over the past week, two headline-grabbing trades have reshaped how the league values high-end starting pitching. First came the Mets’ acquisition of Brewers right-hander Freddy Peralta. Then, on Thursday, the Texas Rangers stunned the industry by landing Nationals lefty MacKenzie Gore. Neither deal directly involved the Twins, but both could have significant ripple effects in Minnesota.
Peralta is a very good pitcher, but he is under team control for only one more season. That did not stop New York from sending two of their top five prospects: infielder-outfielder Jett Williams and right-handed starter Brandon Sproat. Prospects are currency, and money is never an obstacle for Mets owner Steve Cohen. Through that lens, the move made sense. However, Williams and Sproat are both highly rated, and dealing them for Peralta (plus swingman Tobias Myers) was a bold stroke for New York.
The Gore trade was even louder. Texas acquired the former top prospect, who is under team control through 2027, in exchange for five prospects. Shortstop Gavin Fien, right-handed pitcher Alejandro Rosario, first baseman and outfielder Abimelec Ortiz, infielder Devin Fitz Gerald, and outfielder Yeremy Cabrera all headed to Washington. That is an enormous return for one pitcher, even if it had a bit of quantity over quality to it.
Now zoom out and look at the Twins. Despite constant offseason rumors, Minnesota has insisted on keeping Joe Ryan and Pablo López. Derek Falvey and company have publicly dismissed trading either ace. Yet, after seeing Peralta and Gore’s return such impressive hauls, it’s only prudent to reconsider.
Ryan and López are in the same tier as those two pitchers, in the eyes of the league. In some front offices, they may even be valued more highly. They’re closer to Peralta in quality, but they each have two years left before free agency, like Gore. That reality gives the Twins leverage. A lot of it.
Even if Minnesota ultimately decides against moving either pitcher before Opening Day, this week made one thing clear: The ceiling on a Ryan or López trade package is enormous. If the Twins find themselves below .500 at the trade deadline and are not confident in a postseason push, the offers could be impossible to ignore.
None of this means Twins fans should be rooting for a teardown. Ideally, Minnesota enters the season with both right-handers anchoring the rotation and plays well enough that dealing either one is off the table in July. That is still the preferred outcome. But there is another side to this.
The Twins were not expected to do much this offseason, which is why the additions of Victor Caratini and Taylor Rogers caught some fans off guard. Those moves helped, but they did not solve everything. The bullpen still needs depth, and the roster still has clear holes. It also sounds like the team has other moves in the works before spring training next month.
Listening on star players is not the same as committing to trading them. In fact, doing so could be the best way to strengthen the organization long-term, if the season goes sideways.
Even after Rogers’s arrival, another reliever would make plenty of sense. While the Twins have publicly refuted the idea of trading Byron Buxton, Ryan, or López, now is exactly the time to keep an ear out for an offer they cannot refuse. All it takes is one desperate team to completely change the calculus.
Buxton remains a long shot, given his no-trade clause, so the focus realistically falls on the two aces. Which teams might get desperate enough to overpay?
The Yankees stand out, immediately. Boston is another name to watch. The Red Sox were tied to Ryan around last year’s deadline, even if that reporting turned out to be premature. It sounds like both sides have put to rest the Ryan trade rumors this winter. However, they have already acquired former Twin Sonny Gray this winter and have made 10 trades overall. An 11th would hardly be shocking.
Baltimore is the sleeper. The Orioles were quiet last offseason, but have been far more active heading into 2026. With a young core built to win now, adding a cost-controlled ace could push them over the top.
Losing a star is difficult, but a clear direction is vital. If Minnesota is truly open to dealing Ryan, López, or even Buxton, the return could quickly redefine the franchise’s future. For now, Minnesota waits. The phone may not be ringing yet, but after last week, everyone knows the price of pitching just went up.
Should the Twins be listening on significant offers for their stars? Leave a comment and start the discussion.