With Gavin Sheets (mostly officially) set to take over as the San Diego Padres’ starting first baseman for 2026, it appears that one of their two remaining lineup questions has been answered. The other, however, remains an unsolved riddle.

Once the Padres exercised Ramón Laureano‘s club option, they settled seven of their nine positions in the lineup. Only first base and designated hitter were left to determine. With the news that Sheets will get the first run at the former, how the team will approach the latter now becomes a matter of some conjecture. Now on the cusp of pitchers and catchers reporting to Arizona, two paths lie before them. 

For one, there’s a chance the Padres attempt to fill the position completely internally. Given how quiet things have been on the transactional front, this one would appear to be the most likely. It’s also the most complex. 

At one point this winter, it might’ve been worthwhile for the team to consider deploying Luis Campusano as part of a regular DH rotation. His upside lives almost exclusively in his bat and, in the absence of other options, it appeared that he finally had a path to regular plate appearances. That could have even extended to a platoon, of sorts, with Sheets. With the latter now assumed to be getting regular field work, that idea dissolves. To say nothing of the fact that Campusano still projects to be the team’s backup catcher. That’s a guy more likely to start on the bench rather than elsewhere considering the logistical nightmare wrought by something happening to Freddy Fermin mid-game. 

With that idea out, the first path is paved for Craig Stammen to rotate someone new in depending on matchups and a desire to create partial off-days. Sung Mun Song‘s presence certainly helps in this regard. He can play any of second base, shortstop, or third, and the team plans to get him some additional run at first and in the outfield. Such utility could be used heavily to their advantage in getting veterans off their feet in the field on occasion. This is particularly true for Manny Machado, whose body has been through plenty of tribulations and who features declining defensive metrics. The same could be true of the outfield, where Bryce Johnson presents at least a stable glove in the event that Stammen wanted to give Fernando Tatis Jr. or Jackson Merrill a bit of a blow on a given day. 

There is a way to execute such a plan in a way that doesn’t alter the lineup too much on a daily basis, as well. If it’s Song, for example, rotating primarily through the group, then you hold his spot and simply rotate positions on an as-needed basis. It’s still a good deal of roster juggling, but could allow the Padres to give their most important bats more frequent rest, at least on a halfway basis. 

The alternative to the expected route is to pursue a bat from outside the organization. This might be someone like Rhys Hoskins or Miguel Andujar on the free-agent market. Hoskins has become nearly unplayable in the field while Andujar at least has some versatility in a bat that bounced back in 2025. If the Philadelphia Phillies were willing to eat enough money, Nick Castellanos could be a somewhat realistic option, too. Such a route has appeal in the form of an additional bat for a team that probably needs more supplemental offense. Considering we don’t know where the team’s financial expectations are at this stage of the winter, however, it’s also a much more difficult route to see to fruition than the expected one. 

With the clarity arriving on Sheets’ role, though, there’s an opportunity for the Padres to pursue the same on the designated hitter front. Even with the team appearing content to run things out with the status quo, it remains difficult to underestimate A.J. Preller’s willingness to do anything he can to improve the roster. With the window to do so waning, we should see the same level of clarity emerge at DH in the coming weeks.

Think you could write an article like this one? We’re looking for additional contributors, and we pay for all our content! Please click here, fill out the form, and someone will reply with more information.