The Brewers have enjoyed the fruits of a heist since Opening Day 2023. Through a brilliant move, they secured the long-term services of William Contreras, plus the useful Joel Payamps, for the price of Esteury Ruiz, who’s since been dealt to two other teams. Will catcher still be a strength in 2026?

2025 Review
Contreras held down the fort again in 2025, playing through a broken finger. It cost him somewhat at the plate and in terms of WAR (he dropped from 4.9 WAR in 2024 to 3.9 in 2025), but he was still a borderline All-Star-caliber player. That didn’t leave much for backups Eric Haase and Danny Jansen to do, although both contributed by allowing Contreras to serve as the DH on occasion.

Current Roster Situation
At the start of February, the Brewers have Contreras and former Top 100 prospect Jeferson Quero on the 40-man roster. Contreras figures to be the starter, though barring a financial miracle, his days at Uecker Field are probably numbered. The big question is who takes the No. 2 spot. Backup catchers in Milwaukee haven’t had much to do at times, but it never hurts to have quality when it’s needed.

Quero could be an option even by Opening Day, and has been the Brewers’ catcher of the future for the last few years. The theory behind him as the backup to Contreras would be that he could spend 2026 acclimating to MLB pitching and easing in as the eventual starter. However, he’s still coming off two injury-riddled seasons and may need to play every day, and that can only happen in Triple-A Nashville, given Contreras’s presence. Anthony Seigler is also on the 40-man roster and played 22 games at catcher in Nashville last season, but he’s more of a utility man and emergency backstop.

Then we turn to various non-roster invitees. Veteran Reese McGuire was signed as a free agent, and received an invitation to spring training. He’s the co-favorite (alongside Quero) to be the backup come late March. Ramon Rodriguez had only 81 at-bats in a 2025 season lost to injury. Darrien Miller has been in the organization for a long time, and his OBP skills are strong. Matthew Wood has looked solid, despite being overshadowed by Quero and Marco Dinges. Wood and Miller are both only 24, though neither will be more than a second-tier backup in the majors.

Best-Case Scenario for 2026
The best-case scenario for the Brewers is for Contreras to pick up about 120 starts behind the plate and another 30 or so at designated hitter, with one of the NRIs taking the backup job, allowing Quero a full season at Nashville to give the Brewers an idea of what he will look like at maturity. McGuire and Miller would be the top contenders, with McGuire holding the obvious edge. If Contreras posts something akin to his 2024 numbers, the Brewers could then get a major haul to recharge their farm system.

Worst-Case Scenario for 2026
Contreras has a lengthy stay on the injured list, and Jeferson Quero struggles as his fill-in. The Brewers were lucky that Contreras was able to power through and deliver above-average offense (111 OPS+) even in an injury-diminished campaign. If they are unlucky this time around, the catcher position goes from a strength to a question mark in 2026, and it will also affect the return the Brewers receive in the likely event Contreras is traded in the 2026-2027 offseason.

Overview
There are a number of ways for the catcher spot to go wrong for Milwaukee. Contreras could be injured. The Brewers could end up with Quero sitting on the bench a lot in Milwaukee, because nobody else seizes the backup catcher slot. Catcher can also go right in multiple ways, including Quero delivering average to above-average offense and forcing his way into playing time in Milwaukee. The interesting discussion in Arizona will be who backs up the big guy, but the outcomes for this season all hinge on Contreras himself.