Hunting out the best teams in MLB The Show 26 isn’t about rooting for your favorite clubs, because your choice can totally shape how your Franchise rebuilds, who ends up on your Diamond Dynasty roster, or even how a quick Play Now game feels.
Here’s a rundown of the top teams in MLB The Show 26, ranked by attributes.
Best Teams In MLB The Show 26 
Image: San Diego Studios 1. Los Angeles Dodgers
The Los Angeles Dodgers sit at the top with an average of 87 OVR. Shohei Ohtani (99 two-way), Mookie Betts (92), and Freddie Freeman make their lineup scary. Blake Snell (96) anchors the rotation, and the bench and bullpen are so deep, you won’t spot any weak links.
It’s perfect for anyone who wants to win right away, whether it’s Franchise or Diamond Dynasty; you barely need to fix anything with the Dodgers.
2. New York Yankees
The New York Yankees are strong at the core: Aaron Judge (99 RF) is a monster at the plate, and Stanton blasts homers for fun. Volpe (88 SS) brings youth to the mix, and the rotation’s solid with Gerrit Cole (88 SP) leading it. It’s all about power hitting here that gives them the edge over balanced teams.
It’s perfect for crushing home runs in Play Now or putting together a serious offensive team.
3. Philadelphia Phillies
Philadelphia Phillies shine with Zack Wheeler (90 P), who gives them some of the best pitching, plus Bryce Harper (95 1B) and Trea Turner (90 SS) deliver at the plate and on the bases. Their bullpen comes alive late in games.
It’s solid for players chasing a balanced team that delivers wherever you take it.
4. Seattle Mariners
Seattle Mariners hold George Kirby (89 P) and Logan Gilbert (88 P) on the mound, Cal Raleigh (86 C) performs great behind the plate, and Julio Rodriguez (93 CF) covers a ton of ground. Mariners pitchers dominate AI lineups with ease.
Fans of pitching duels and sim leagues love the Mariners.
5. New York Mets
Juan Soto (99 RF), Francisco Lindor (95 SS), and Devin Williams (84 P) bring contact and power to the New York Mets. Nimmo keeps the outfield steady, while Met’s rotations hold up in longer game modes.
It’s best for high-average hitting in Exhibition.
6. Atlanta Braves
Ronald Acuna Jr (92 RF) mixes speed and power, Chris Sale (97 P) returns stronger, and Spencer Strider returns solid. Their outfield throws stop teams from having big rallies.
It’s a solid pick for stealing bases in Diamond Dynasty conquest.
7. Boston Red Sox
Boston Red Sox show off Sonny Gray (90 P), Garrett Crochet (85 P), Jarren Duran (86 LF leadoff), and Devers mashing lefties. Fenway’s unique setup boosts its attributes, too.
It’s perfect for rebuilding with pitching as your centerpiece.
8. Chicago Cubs
The Chicago Cubs come in with Pete Crow-Armstrong (90 CF lockdown D), Bellinger’s clutch in big moments, and a young roster fitting straight into progression systems.
They stay a solid choice for putting on a fielding clinic in Road to the Show.
9. Pittsburgh Pirates
Pittsburgh Pirates showcase their talent with Paul Skenes (99 P rookie phenom), and Oneil Cruz (83 CF tools) brings versatility. Their overall ratings aren’t great, but the potential is huge.
It’s another solid choice for rebuilding fun with breakout stars.
10. Texas Rangers
Texas Rangers hold Corey Seager (92 SS), Jacob deGrom (94 P), and Langford (84 LF) emerging. Power bats carry the Rangers, making a decent pick for playoff runs with veterans leading the way.
Ratings shift with updates and trades, so hit Practice mode to test which team fits your playstyle best.